论文信息
论文解读
AI 辅助整理- 方法
- 以宅基地改革试点为准自然实验,用县级面板数据和交错双重差分法。
- 发现
- 改革显著促进农民增收,通过土地与劳动力优化配置实现,但城镇居民获益更多。
- 机会点
- 可结合数字技术追踪宅基地改革中的土地与劳动力配置,探索缩小城乡福利差距的机制。
论文摘要
引言 农村宅基地是农村社会经济发展的重要基础,其利用制度改革对农民生计和农村可持续发展至关重要。方法 为系统评估这一土地利用转型特别是农村宅基地制度改革的微观福利效应,本文将中国试点政策视为准自然实验,利用县级面板数据和交错双重差分法,评估该政策对农民收入的影响及其内在机制。结果 结果表明,农村宅基地制度改革显著促进了农民收入增长。机制检验表明,这一效应通过土地和劳动力资源的优化配置实现:一是土地资源的空间优化,促进了农业产业融合;二是家庭劳动力的再配置,推动劳动力参与非农就业,同时优化农业劳动效率。此外,农地流转具有显著的正向调节效应,放大了改革对农民收入增长的促进作用。讨论 然而,进一步分析揭示了福利分配上的差异,该政策在更大程度上提高了城镇居民收入;因此,应进一步完善制度安排,着力增强农村居民从改革中获得的福利收益。
全文
Frontiers in Sustainable Food SystemsFrontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 01 frontiersin.org
TYPE Original Research
PUBLISHED 16 November 2026
DOI 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
OPEN ACCESS
EDITED BY
Xuewei Zhang,
Fuzhou University, China
REVIEWED BY
Muhammad Abu Sufyan Ali,
Shaanxi Normal University, China
Zhiguo Fan,
Weifang University of Science and
Technology, China
CORRESPONDENCE
Yujia Lu
202510021@stumail.nwu.edu.cn
RECEIVED 19 September 2026
REVISED 28 October 2026
ACCEPTED 02 November 2026
PUBLISHED 16 November 2026
CITATION
Zhao J and Lu Y (2026) Reallocating
rural land for sustainable livelihoods: the
impact of residential land reform on
farmers' incomes in China.
Front. Sustain. Food Syst. 10:2003651.
doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
COPYRIGHT
© 2026 Zhao and Lu. This is an
open-access article distributed under
the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License (CC BY). The use,
distribution or reproduction in other
forums is permitted, provided the
original author(s) and the copyright
owner(s) are credited and that the
original publication in this journal is
cited, in accordance with accepted
academic practice. No use, distribution
or reproduction is permitted which does
not comply with these terms.
Reallocating rural land for
sustainable livelihoods: the
impact of residential land reform
on farmers' incomes in China
Jiayuan Zhao 1 and Yujia Lu 2
1School of Economics and Management, Northwest University, Xi'an, China, 2Research Institute on
Economy and Development of Western China, Northwest University, Xi'an, China
Introduction: Rural residential land serves as a vital foundation for rural socioeco-
nomic development, and reforming its utilization is crucial for farmers’ livelihoods
and sustainable rural development.
Methods: To systematically evaluate the micro-level welfare effects of this land
use transition, particularly the reform of the rural residential land system, this
paper treats China’s pilot policy as a quasi-natural experiment. Using county-
level panel data and a staggered difference-in-differences method, we assess the
policy’s impact on farmers’ income and its underlying mechanisms.
Results: The results indicate that the reform of the rural residential land system
significantly promotes farmers’ income growth. Mechanism tests suggest that
this effect is achieved through the optimal allocation of both land and labor
resources: first, the spatial optimization of land resources, which promotes the
integration of agricultural industries; and second, the reallocation of household
labor, which drives labor participation in non-agricultural employment while opti-
mizing agricultural labor efficiency. Furthermore, the transfer of farmland exerts a
significant positive moderating effect, amplifying the reform’s role in promoting
farmers’ income growth.
Discussion: However, further analysis reveals disparities in welfare distribution,
as the policy has raised urban residents’ incomes to a greater extent; therefore,
institutional arrangements should be further refined to focus on enhancing the
welfare gains of rural residents from the reform.
KEYWORDS
farmers’ income, labor resource allocation, land resource allocation, reform of the
rural residential land system, staggered difference-in-differences method
1 Introduction
Against the backdrop of rapid global urbanization and industrialization, the massive
migration of rural populations to cities has led to widespread rural land idleness, village hol-
lowing, and the misallocation of spatial resources (Han et al., 2024; Zhang et al., 2022). This
has made rural spatial governance and land use transition major challenges facing countries
worldwide (Yu et al., 2018). How to revitalize idle rural land resources through institutional
innovation, thereby promoting farmers’ income growth while safeguarding their land rights,
is a key issue for achieving sustainable rural development. As the world’s largest developing
country, China has implemented a unique rural residential land system reform. This major
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 02 frontiersin.org
policy intervention, aimed at breaking the constraints of rigid land
property rights and promoting the spatial reallocation of land
resources, provides a quasi-natural experiment for assessing the
impact of land system innovation on microeconomic welfare.
In the past, constrained by a rigid urban-rural dual structure,
China’s rural residential land lacked legal channels for market circula-
tion, leading to severe resource idleness (Zhang et al., 2021). To allevi-
ate the imbalance between land supply and demand and explore
pathways for modern rural spatial governance, China launched two
rounds of large-scale pilot reforms of the rural residential land system
in 2015 and 2020, respectively. The core of this reform lies in granting
farmers more comprehensive property rights through innovations in
the property rights system, namely the separation of ownership, quali-
fication, and use rights. As the reform has deepened, numerous suc-
cessful cases of rural development driven by spatial governance have
emerged in policy practice. For example, in pilot projects in Luhe
County, Guangdong Province, and Shaoxing City, Zhejiang Province,
local governments introduced social capital to integrate idle rural resi-
dential land with emerging business forms such as rural tourism and
leisure agriculture. This not only resulted in a land use transition
toward multifunctional landscapes but also created many non-agri-
cultural jobs, significantly increasing the income levels of village col-
lectives and farmers. These practices demonstrate that reasonable land
policy interventions can effectively break down spatial barriers,
improve land-use efficiency, and unleash the vitality of the rural
economy.
Academic circles have engaged in extensive discussions centered
on the macro-level allocation of rural land resources and micro-level
growth in farmers’ income. On the one hand, regarding the macro-
level allocation of rural land resources, scientific spatial planning
and land governance are viewed as intrinsic drivers for ensuring
global food security and sustaining rural development ( Liu, 2018;
Zhou et al., 2020b; OuY ang et al., 2026). Within this macro perspec-
tive, land property rights systems constitute the core institutional
environment that determines the efficiency of resource allocation
(Ostrom, 2009). Existing studies, whether focusing on enhancing the
resilience of food security systems through multidimensional col -
laborative adaptive mechanisms ( Liu Y . et al., 2026 ), optimizing
human management practices to improve the effectiveness of eco -
system services such as vegetation carbon sequestration ( Qin and
Sha, 2026), or establishing an optimized allocation of agricultural
irrigation water resources to increase land productivity ( Y ang et al.,
2022, 2026), consistently demonstrate that scientific institutional
and management innovations are key to correcting the misallocation
of rural land resources. With regard to land institutional reform,
breaking down rigid institutional barriers can effectively correct
land resource misallocation, activate idle spatial capital (Zhou et al.,
2020a; Chari et al., 2021 ), and promote the transition of marginal
land toward intensive utilization models guided by profitability and
green transformation (Bilande et al., 2026; Chen et al., 2025). On the
other hand, regarding micro-level growth in farmers’ income, the
existing literature generally agrees that the optimal allocation of land
resources is a key driver of farmers’ income growth ( Chen et al.,
2024). Land system reform, by empowering micro-level actors, has
reshaped farmers’ capacity for buffering, adaptation, and transfor -
mation, significantly enhancing their livelihood resilience (Liu X. et
al., 2026). Spatial restructuring of land, through the synergy of land
consolidation and agricultural technology extension, has reduced
transaction costs (Li et al., 2025), providing the spatial carrier for the
introduction of rural tourism and high-value-added horticultural
crops (Gedecho et al., 2025; Niu and Zhou, 2025), while also alleviat-
ing the strain on land carrying capacity caused by the large-scale
expansion of livestock farming and safeguarding smallholder farm -
ers’ opportunities to increase income through diversified operations
(Qian et al., 2022; Yin et al., 2019).
Although the existing literature offers a wealth of discussion on
the economic effects of rural land institutional reform, most existing
research on this topic has focused on agricultural arable land and land
used for agricultural and pastoral production; there remains room for
further exploration in evaluating the policy effects of rural residential
land system reform. Although a few studies have highlighted the posi-
tive effects of rural residential land system reform on sustainable land
use (Han et al., 2024) and on empowering non-agricultural industrial
development (Wu et al., 2024), the transmission mechanism through
which such reforms penetrate the complex rural economic system and
translate into micro-level income growth for farmers via the dual
mechanisms of spatial land resource optimization and household
labor reallocation remains unclear. Against this backdrop, the primary
objective of this paper is to treat China’s phased pilot reforms of the
rural residential land system as a quasi-natural experiment. Using
county-level panel data and a staggered difference-in-differences
model, this study systematically evaluates the policy effects of these
reforms on rural residents’ income and provides an in-depth analysis
of the underlying transmission mechanisms achieved through the
dual optimal allocation of land and labor resources. The study aims to
enrich and deepen theoretical research on the economic consequences
of rural residential land system reform from a resource allocation per-
spective, providing empirical evidence and policy guidance for coun-
tries seeking to deepen rural land institutional reform, improve
land-use efficiency, increase rural residents’ income, and achieve
inclusive rural growth.
The marginal contributions of this paper are primarily reflected
in three aspects: First, from a research perspective, this paper
focuses on rural residential land, which possesses both subsistence
security and property attributes. Based on resource allocation
theory, it decomposes the complex reform of the residential land
system into two dimensions, namely qualification right confirma -
tion and use right deregulation, and reveals the intrinsic mecha -
nisms through which residential land system reform drives farmers’
income growth via two pathways: the spatial optimization of land
resources and the optimal allocation of household labor resources.
Second, in terms of theoretical expansion, this paper enriches land
tenure security theory. Existing research on land tenure security
and spatial governance has primarily focused on agricultural arable
land or productive land for agriculture and animal husbandry; this
paper extends the theoretical scope to include rural residential land
as a distinct land type. It conceptualizes the “unbundling effect”
associated with the confirmation of qualification rights for rural
residential land, providing a new theoretical framework for under -
standing farmers’ behavioral choices in transition economies. Third,
in terms of research methods and evidence, this paper treats the
pilot programs for rural residential land system reform, imple -
mented by the state in batches, as a quasi-natural experiment. By
employing a staggered difference-in-differences method for empiri -
cal testing, it mitigates issues of model endogeneity and sample
selection bias, thereby providing empirical evidence for a scientific
assessment of the micro-level welfare effects of land property rights
policy reforms.
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 03 frontiersin.org
2 Policy background and research
hypotheses
2.1 Policy background
In the past, China’s rural residential land tenure system was char-
acterized by its closed, non-market nature. Rural residential land was
allocated free of charge to farming households by village collectives,
but its transfer across villages or entry into the market was strictly
restricted. This institutional arrangement, centered on social security,
historically played a crucial role in ensuring the basic housing rights
of hundreds of millions of farmers, safeguarding against the risk of
land loss, and maintaining social stability in rural areas. However, with
rapid urbanization and the large-scale migration of the rural popula-
tion to cities, the socioeconomic foundation of this traditional system
has undergone a fundamental shift, and its function has gradually
evolved from a protective shield into an institutional barrier. As large
numbers of farmers have moved to cities and registered as urban resi-
dents, rural dwellings, which originally served basic housing func-
tions, have become largely idle, and once-vibrant villages have fallen
into a state of severe rural hollowing-out and land abandonment. At
this juncture, the shortcomings of the traditional management model,
namely ambiguous land property rights and the exclusion of market-
based allocation, have been fully exposed: due to the lack of legal
channels for land transfer and exit, farmers are unable to convert their
idle properties into economic returns to support their livelihood tran-
sition in cities; at the same time, the idleness of vast rural land
resources has led to significant spatial resource misallocation and
waste. Consequently, breaking free from the constraints of the old,
rigid property rights system and advancing land system reform have
become inevitable choices for reshaping rural spatial governance, revi-
talizing idle resources, and achieving a land use transition.
In 2015, the central government issued the “Opinions on
Conducting Pilot Programs for Rural Land Expropriation, the Entry
of Collective Commercial Construction Land into the Market, and
Reform of the Rural Residential Land System, ” which for the first time
clearly defined the scope and direction of pilot reforms for the rural
residential land system. The pilot program covered 33 counties and
explored three key areas: the entry of collectively owned land into the
market, rural land expropriation, and the residential land system. This
reform focused on revitalizing rural land resources, providing farmers
with clearer rights protections, and exploring diversified mechanisms
for land transfer. Throughout the policy implementation process, the
pilot program emphasized drawing lessons from practical experience,
resulting in a series of innovative measures worthy of broader adop-
tion. By clarifying land rights and empowering farmers, the reform
further stabilized farmers’ rights and interests. At the same time, the
reform explored approaches such as paid use of residential land, vol-
untary paid withdrawal, and collective buybacks, striving to address
issues like the idling and waste of residential land and the unreason-
able distribution of land revenues, while achieving efficient use of land
resources through improved institutional design.
The pilot program for reforming the rural residential land system
can be summarized in the following three aspects: first, the determina-
tion of qualification rights, under which farmers’ eligibility to acquire
residential land is verified through multiple methods, followed by
rights confirmation and real estate registration within the “separation
of three rights” framework for residential land; second, the
commodification of residential land, which explores mechanisms for
the paid use of residential land and voluntary, compensated with -
drawal; and third, the transfer and repurchase of residential land,
including internal transfers within collective organizations and the
repurchase of idle residential land by collective organizations (Liu and
Xiong, 2019). Regarding the exit from residential land, pilot regions
adhere to the principles of legality, voluntariness, and compensation.
Based on local conditions, they implement compensated exits for
legally acquired residential land and uncompensated exits for illegally
occupied residential land. They are exploring various exit methods,
including permanent exit, temporary exit, property rights exchange,
and monetary compensation, to reduce land idleness and waste and
to refine systems governing the allocation, transfer, exit, use, revenue
distribution, approval, and supervision of residential land. This closed-
loop institutional system, spanning from title confirmation and
empowerment to the activation of land rights, not only provides effec-
tive policy tools for addressing idle rural land but also contributes
valuable Chinese experience to the global exploration of land manage-
ment and circulation systems that balance equity and efficiency.
2.2 Research hypotheses
Land factor allocation theory, based on the principle of optimal
resource allocation, emphasizes the foundational role of land resources
in economic growth and social development; its core objective is to
achieve the efficient utilization of land resources and maximize their
value. Within this theoretical framework, reforms to the rural residen-
tial land system have reshaped the logic of land resource allocation by
breaking down traditional institutional barriers, thereby significantly
enhancing the liquidity of land as a factor of production and the
capacity for resource reorganization (Zhou et al., 2020b). Specifically,
the reform has promoted farmers’ autonomous use and innovative
development of land resources while attracting the inflow of modern
production factors such as external capital and technology, thereby
forming a cross-regional and cross-sectoral pattern of resource alloca-
tion. This reactivation and integration of resources has enabled the
effective development of a large amount of idle rural residential land,
providing a solid land-based foundation for the development of rural
collective non-agricultural economies and paving the way for the
introduction of external industries (Yin et al., 2019; Wu et al., 2024).
The increased flexibility of land as a factor of production has not only
optimized land-use efficiency but also driven profound adjustments
in the rural economic structure (Chari et al., 2021). Furthermore, in
the process of promoting the development of the rural collective econ-
omy, the reform of the rural residential land system has created favor-
able conditions for the formation and improvement of rural factor
markets through multifunctional development and diversified opera-
tions. The reformed land system has provided fundamental support
for the establishment of external industries and the transformation of
local industries, promoting the upgrading of village economies toward
high value-added sectors while driving the modernization of business
models and the extension of industrial chains. Through resource inte-
gration and functional optimization, villages have gradually estab-
lished sustainable income-generation mechanisms that have not only
enhanced the revenue-generating capacity of the village collective
economy but also brought substantial income growth to farmers. The
vitality of land resources unleashed by the reform has not only
enhanced the overall wellbeing of villages and communities but also
strengthened the endogenous momentum of the rural economic
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 04 frontiersin.org
system, laying a solid foundation for achieving the goals of urban-
rural integration and common prosperity.
Against the backdrop of growing demand for urban construction
land and an increasingly prominent conflict with the red line for
arable land protection, the pilot policy on rural residential land system
reform has provided institutional channels for social entities in pilot
areas to participate in the circulation of rural residential land use
rights. These entities participate in the marketization of rural residen-
tial land use rights through leasing, transfer, exchange, and equity
contribution. While improving land-use efficiency, this also allows
rural residential land resources to participate more flexibly in the con-
version of urban and rural construction land quotas ( Zhang et al.,
2021). The implementation of transfer and buyback mechanisms has
provided local governments with effective tools to achieve the central
government’s policy objectives regarding the trading of urban and
rural construction land quotas, and has become a key lever for local
governments to optimize land resource allocation and alleviate the
imbalance between land supply and demand. The urban and rural
construction land quotas generated through the transfer of rural resi-
dential land not only facilitate the rational allocation of rural residen-
tial land resources between urban and rural areas but also objectively
accelerate the process of transforming rural residential land into prop-
erty. This transformation into property, by unlocking the latent value
of rural residential land, infuses land resources with market attributes,
allowing the economic value of rural residential land to be more
clearly reflected in market transactions. The flexible deregulation of
rural residential land use rights has promoted the development and
refinement of the rural land market, enabling the optimal allocation
of rural land resources under the guidance of supply-and-demand
mechanisms, while simultaneously providing a more accurate and
market-based basis for land pricing. For farmers, this reform provides
the foundational conditions for accurately assessing the value of their
land assets, enabling them to make decisions regarding the disposal of
these assets based on more rational economic analysis. Furthermore,
as the marketization process accelerates, farmers can gain access to
more financing channels and risk management tools through the
transfer and trading of land assets, thereby further enhancing the pro-
tection of their property rights and the stability of their income (Liu
X. et al., 2026). Reforms to the rural residential land system, through
the optimal allocation of land resources, have provided much-needed
land factor support for the development of rural industries, driving
the restructuring of the rural industrial sector and the transformation
and upgrading of the economic development model. At the same time,
the increased liquidity of land assets directly raises farmers’ actual
income levels and improves the quality of life for rural residents. This
reform not only promotes the efficient use of land resources at the
micro level but also facilitates the two-way flow of resources between
urban and rural areas at the macro level, laying an important founda-
tion for achieving the goals of urban-rural integration and common
prosperity.
Based on this, this paper proposes the following hypotheses:
H1: The reform of the rural residential land system achieves the
optimal allocation of land resources by fostering rural industrial
development, thereby increasing farmers’ income.
A central tenet of the new economics of labor migration holds
that non-agricultural employment is not merely an economically
rational choice made by individuals, but rather an optimal resource
allocation decision made at the household level after comprehen -
sively weighing risks and benefits ( Stark, 1991). Essentially, non-
agricultural employment reflects the reallocation and optimal
allocation of household labor resources between the agricultural and
non-agricultural sectors (Kung, 2002). This process not only signifi-
cantly reduces the risk of household income uncertainty caused by
fluctuations in agricultural production but also maximizes the
household’s overall economic benefits by allocating labor resources
to sectors with higher returns. At the same time, this labor mobility
promotes income diversification within household economic struc-
tures, further enhancing their resilience to risks. In recent years, as
reforms to the urban and rural household registration system have
deepened, institutional barriers hindering the free movement of
rural labor between urban and rural areas have gradually been dis -
mantled, allowing rural labor to move more freely between these
areas (Tombe and Zhu, 2019; Imbert et al., 2022). Many rural work-
ers have been freed from the “involutionary” agricultural produc -
tion system and have shifted to non-agricultural sectors, which has
not only alleviated employment pressure in rural areas but also
enhanced overall social productivity. From the perspective of house-
hold labor resource allocation theory, some farmers have chosen to
revitalize idle rural residential land through land transfer mecha -
nisms, thereby freeing up labor resources that were previously tied
to the land. These workers have subsequently flowed into higher-
yielding non-agricultural sectors or more efficient modern agricul -
tural fields, thereby enhancing the overall efficiency of household
labor utilization. This adjustment in resource allocation not only
reflects the optimized flow of rural labor but also drives a significant
improvement in household economic performance. More impor -
tantly, the cross-sectoral mobility of the rural labor force has, at the
macro level, broken down the previously rigid social class structure,
creating opportunities for rural households to achieve upward eco -
nomic mobility. By reducing labor surplus in the agricultural sector
and expanding employment options in non-agricultural industries,
farming households have diversified their income sources, leading
to a significant improvement in income levels and stability. This pro-
cess has also, to a certain extent, reduced income inequality between
urban and rural areas as well as within rural communities, creating
conditions for optimizing the distribution of absolute income. From
the perspective of socioeconomic development, the transfer of the
rural labor force to non-agricultural sectors and the resource alloca -
tion function of rural residential land transfers not only help rural
households achieve income growth but also play a vital role in nar -
rowing the urban-rural gap, promoting social mobility, and enhanc-
ing the overall wellbeing of rural society, thereby becoming a key
link in driving rural economic development and achieving common
prosperity.
The recognition of qualification rights for rural residential
land has filled a long-standing institutional gap in the protection
of property rights for such land. By clarifying the attribution of
qualification rights for rural residential land, this policy measure
provides farmers with a stronger sense of tenure security, signifi -
cantly enhances land security and liquidity, and creates the neces -
sary conditions for farming households to achieve the optimal
allocation of labor resources ( Adamopoulos et al., 2024 ). Building
on this, the recognition of qualification rights to rural residential
land has also effectively reduced mobility friction faced by farmers
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 05 frontiersin.org
when seeking employment away from home and mitigated poten -
tial constraints on labor mobility arising from uncertainties
regarding rural residential land rights, thereby providing institu -
tional safeguards for farmers’ participation in non-agricultural
industries. Through this policy arrangement, farmers can more
confidently free themselves from traditional agricultural produc -
tion activities, redirect household labor resources to higher-yield -
ing non-agricultural sectors, improve labor productivity, and
significantly increase household income levels.
The clarity of rural residential land qualification rights not only
enhances the stability of farmers’ non-agricultural employment but
also generates significant incentive effects. This incentive mecha -
nism not only eliminates farmers’ concerns when choosing non-
agricultural employment but also boosts their confidence in
seeking off-farm employment and making non-agricultural invest -
ments through enhanced property rights security, thereby further
unlocking the mobility potential of the rural labor force.
Specifically, the recognition of rural residential land qualification
rights enables farmers to more rationally assess the marginal
returns of household labor resources, optimize the allocation of
household labor between agricultural and non-agricultural sectors,
and direct it toward areas with higher productivity and more sub -
stantial income levels. This process fundamentally improves the
efficiency of rural labor resource allocation and promotes coordi -
nated development between the rural economy and urban-rural
integration. Furthermore, the institutional innovation of recogniz -
ing rural residential land qualification rights not only optimizes
the allocation of household labor at the micro level but also pro -
motes the transformation and upgrading of the rural economic
structure at the macro level. By unlocking the latent value of land
resources, the recognition of rural residential land qualification
rights provides institutional support for the development of the
rural land market while ensuring the availability of land as a key
factor for rural industrial development. In short, by enhancing the
stability and motivation of farmers to engage in non-agricultural
employment, the recognition of rural residential land qualification
rights not only directly boosts farmers’ income levels but also cre -
ates more opportunities for rural households to participate in the
market economy, thereby laying a solid institutional foundation for
rural economic growth and the improvement of farmers’ wellbeing
(Figure 1).
On this basis, this paper puts forward the following
hypotheses:
H2: The reform of the rural residential land system boosts farm-
ers’ income growth by facilitating the optimal allocation of labor
resources within farming households, specifically through farm-
ers’ participation in non-agricultural employment.
3 Research design
3.1 Model specification
The core explanatory variable in this paper is the pilot policy on
the reform of China’s rural residential land system. Given that this
pilot scheme was implemented in two phases in 2015 and 2020 respec-
tively, this paper employs the following staggered difference-in-differ-
ences model:
αα α ε=+× + +++01 2cy cy cy c y cyFI RRLR X u d (1)
In this model, c denotes a county, y denotes the year, and cyFI
is the dependent variable, representing the per capita income of
rural residents in county c in year y. cyRRLR is the core explanatory
variable, representing the pilot policy for reforming the rural resi -
dential land system. This variable is a dummy variable: it is assigned
a value of 1 if county c is a pilot county and year y falls within or
FIGURE 1
Theoretical framework of the micro-level welfare effects driven by rural residential land institutional reform, showing the dual resource reallocation
pathways of land spatial optimization and labor mobility.
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 06 frontiersin.org
after the pilot period; it is assigned a value of 0 if county c is a pilot
county but year y precedes the pilot period; and it is assigned a
value of 0 for all non-pilot counties. cyX represents a set of control
variables; α0 denotes the intercept term; cu represents the county
fixed effect; yd represents the year fixed effect; εcy represents the
error term.
3.2 Variable definitions and descriptive
statistics
Dependent variable (FI ). The dependent variable in this study is
rural residents’ income, measured by the per capita disposable income
of rural residents.
Explanatory variable (RRLR ). The explanatory variable in this
study is the implementation of pilot programs for rural residential
land system reform. Specifically, the coding is as follows: observations
from pilot counties in the year the policy was implemented and sub-
sequent years are coded as 1, and 0 otherwise; observations from non-
pilot counties in any given year are all coded as 0.
Control variables. T o account for other factors that may influ-
ence rural residents’ income, this study selects the following set of
control variables. County-level control variables include: level of
economic development (lnGDP), measured by the logarithm of per
capita regional gross domestic product; the level of financial develop-
ment (lnLoan), measured by the logarithm of the year-end balance
of loans from financial institutions; fixed asset investment (lnInvest-
ment), measured by the logarithm of total social fixed asset invest -
ment; the level of household consumption ( lnconsumption),
measured by the logarithm of total retail sales of consumer goods;
and household savings capacity (lnDeposit), measured by the loga -
rithm of the balance of savings deposits held by urban and rural resi-
dents. The descriptive statistics for the county-level variables are
shown in Table 1; the results of the descriptive statistics for each
control variable are broadly consistent with those in the existing
literature.
3.3 Sample selection and data sources
The variables at the micro-farmer and macro-regional levels
discussed in this paper are primarily sourced from the China
County Statistical Y earbook, the China Regional Economic
Statistical Y earbook, and the China Labor-force Dynamics Survey
(CLDS) across various years. The core explanatory variable was
manually compiled based on the list of reform pilot counties pub -
lished by the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs and their
designation dates. Additionally, dummy variables indicating des -
ignation on the “List of National-Level Poverty-Stricken Counties”
were introduced to control for confounding effects from other
concurrent macroeconomic policies. To enhance data quality, the
data in this paper were processed according to the following cri -
teria: first, observations experiencing major adjustments to
administrative divisions or severe missing values in the core
dependent variable were excluded; second, for partially missing
control variables, we prioritized consulting local Statistical
Bulletins on National Economic and Social Development to man -
ually fill in the gaps, and for the very few years where data
remained unavailable, linear interpolation was used to impute the
missing values. Based on data availability and suitability, the over -
all study period selected for this paper is from 2010 to 2024.
4 Empirical tests
4.1 Baseline estimation results
Table 2 presents the baseline regression results for the impact of
rural residential land system reform on rural residents’ income.
Column (1) of Table 2 shows the regression results without control
variables, where the estimated coefficient on rural residential land
system reform is 0.179 and significantly positive at the 1% level.
Column (2) further incorporates county-level control variables, and
the regression coefficient on the core explanatory variable is 0.171,
which remains significantly positive at the 1% level. This indicates
that rural residential land system reform significantly promotes rural
residents’ income growth, consistent with our theoretical
expectations.
4.2 Ex-ante parallel trend test
A prerequisite for using the staggered difference-in-differ -
ences model is passing an ex-ante parallel trend test, which exam -
ines whether pre-reform trends in rural residents’ income
differed significantly between pilot counties and non-pilot coun -
ties prior to the implementation of the rural residential land
system reform pilot program. First, as shown in Figure 2 , which
plots the dynamic effects of rural residential land system reform
on rural residents’ income, prior to the implementation of the
pilot program, the interaction coefficients between the
TABLE 1 Variable descriptive statistics.
Variable name Observations Mean S.D. Min Max
RRLR 28,392 0.017 0.129 0 1
FI 28,392 0.608 0.419 0.050 3.656
lnGDP 28,392 9.807 1.064 4.443 16.686
lnLoan 28,392 12.71 1.494 1.099 18.758
lnInvestment 28,392 12.82 1.684 0 18.589
lnconsumption 28,392 12.29 1.566 1.792 16.973
lnDeposit 28,392 12.88 1.421 1.792 17.931
The level of economic development, level of financial development, fixed-asset investment, household consumption level, and household savings deposits have all been log-transformed.
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 07 frontiersin.org
pre-treatment relative-year dummies and the pilot policy indica -
tor were all near zero and statistically insignificant, indicating
that there was no significant pre-existing difference in rural resi -
dents’ income trends between pilot and non-pilot counties before
the reform was implemented. Furthermore, based on the post-
reform dynamic effects over time, as the pilot program for rural
residential land system reform progressed, the policy’s positive
impact on rural residents’ income in pilot counties gradually
strengthened.
4.3 Robustness tests
4.3.1 Considering the impact of omitted variables
To avoid potential interference from omitted variables on the
empirical results, this study, taking into account the availability of
county-level data, incorporates four additional control variables
that may influence rural residents’ income into the model design:
the number of regular primary and secondary schools, the number
of beds in hospitals and township health centers, the number of
beds in social welfare institutions, and the actual amount of for -
eign capital utilized. These variables not only reflect the level of
public service provision within a county, such as education,
healthcare, and social security, but also indirectly reflect regional
economic development and the degree of openness to the outside
world, thereby effectively controlling for the interference of non-
policy factors that may lead to changes in rural residents’ income.
The results of the regression analysis are shown in Column (1) of
Table 3. Even after controlling for these potentially omitted vari -
ables, the estimated coefficient on the reform of the rural residen -
tial land system remains significantly positive at the 5% level. This
result indicates that the implementation of the rural residential
land system reform indeed plays a significant role in promoting
farmers’ income growth.
4.3.2 Considering the impact of sample selection
To fully account for the potential impact of sample selection on
the empirical results, this study conducted robustness tests on the
model from multiple perspectives, including the selection of the
analysis window, outlier treatment, and selection bias in pilot regions.
First, regarding the selection of the analysis window, based on the
availability of county-level data, this study selected the period from
2010 to 2024 as the analysis window in the baseline regression. To
examine whether the choice of the time window distorted the empiri-
cal results, this study redesigned the time window by centering on
the policy implementation years and selecting symmetrical time
intervals before and after the policy, resetting the analysis window to
the period from 2010 to 2020 and re-estimating the model. As shown
in Column (2) of Table 3, the estimated coefficient on the rural resi-
dential land system reform remains significantly positive, indicating
that the study’s conclusions remain robust under alternative time
windows. Second, to eliminate the potential impact of extreme values
on the regression results, the sample data underwent winsorization
at the 1% level, and the regression analysis was re-estimated on the
winsorized dataset. As shown in Column (3) of Table 3, the estimated
coefficient remains significantly positive, further validating the
robustness of the model’s results. Finally, given that the selection of
pilot counties for the rural residential land system reform may
involve subjective selection bias, this study introduced the propensity
score matching difference-in-differences (PSM-DID) method to con-
duct robustness tests. Within the sample of non-pilot counties, using
caliper nearest-neighbor matching, we selected non-pilot counties
that shared highly similar characteristics with each pilot county prior
to policy implementation to construct a matched control group, and
then conducted the estimation using the staggered DID method. As
shown in Column (4) of Table 3, the estimated coefficient remains
positive at the 5% significance level, indicating that the estimated
effects of the rural residential land system reform are not significantly
driven by pilot county selection bias.
4.3.3 Avoiding inter-sample effects
To further mitigate potential interactions among samples, particu-
larly given the unique situation where the second round of rural resi-
dential land system reform pilots included three prefecture-level cities,
this study conducted detailed robustness tests to address possible
interactions between counties within the same city or between cities
within the same province. Specifically, by adjusting the clustering cri-
teria and setting the standard error clustering levels at the city and
provincial levels, respectively, this study controlled for potential error
correlations in county-level data arising from geographical and
administrative interdependencies. As shown in Columns (5) and (6)
of Table 3, the estimated coefficients on the rural residential land
system reform pilot policy are significantly positive at both clustering
levels, indicating that the paper’s core conclusions remain robust after
adjusting the clustering level. At the same time, this study further con-
siders potential confounding from time-varying shocks at the city and
provincial levels. In the model extension, this study introduces city-
by-year and province-by-year interaction terms as fixed effects to con-
trol for potential systematic variations across time and space. By
incorporating these interactive fixed effects, this study minimizes the
potential risk of time-varying regional and administrative factors
TABLE 2 Baseline estimation results.
Variables
(1) (2)
FI FI
Coef. Std.
Err.
Coef. Std.
Err.
RRLR 0.179*** 0.044 0.171*** 0.042
lnGDP 0.093*** 0.006
lnLoan 0.040*** 0.004
lnInvestment −0.039*** 0.003
lnconsumption −0.010* 0.006
lnDeposit −0.152*** 0.008
County FE Control Control
Year FE Control Control
Observations 28,392 28,392
Adjusted 2R 0.898 0.904
*, **, and *** indicate significance at the 10%, 5%, and 1% levels, respectively; cluster-robust
standard errors are reported.
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 08 frontiersin.org
simultaneously influencing the regression results. As shown in
Columns (7) and (8) of Table 3, even under this more rigorous model
specification, the estimated coefficient on rural residential land system
reform remains significantly positive, consistent with the paper’s core
conclusion.
4.3.4 Excluding the alternative hypothesis of the
targeted poverty alleviation policy
At the end of 2015, the campaign against poverty was launched
in full force, marking the entry of China’s targeted poverty allevia -
tion policy into its full-scale implementation phase. Subsequently,
policy packages and initiatives such as the “Six Precisions and Five
Batches” and the “Six Poverty Alleviation Actions and Ten
Targeted Poverty Alleviation Projects” were rolled out on a large
scale nationwide in 2016. Centered on precise identification and
precise assistance, the targeted poverty alleviation policy signifi -
cantly improved the economic conditions and income levels of
low-income rural groups by providing tailored support to impov -
erished farming households. Therefore, given the policy’s direct
impact on farmers’ income and the overlap between its implemen -
tation period and the study window selected in this paper, the
targeted poverty alleviation policy may introduce confounding
effects into the research findings. To eliminate the potential influ -
ence of the targeted poverty alleviation policy on the estimated
effects of rural residential land system reform, this paper excludes
national-level poverty-stricken counties from the sample based on
the official list published by the State Council Leading Group
Office of Poverty Alleviation and Development, and re-estimates
the regression using the remaining subsample. Through this
approach, this paper effectively isolates the potential impact of the
targeted poverty alleviation policy on changes in farmers’ income,
ensuring an independent evaluation of rural residential land
system reform. As shown in Column (9) of Table 3, even after
excluding national-level poverty-stricken counties from the
sample, the estimated coefficient on the reform of the rural resi -
dential land system remains significantly positive and consistent
with the baseline regression results. This indicates that the tar -
geted poverty alleviation policy causes minimal interference with
our conclusions, and that the income-increasing effect of the rural
residential land system reform exhibits strong independence and
robustness.
4.3.5 Placebo test
To rule out potential interference from unobservable variables on
the empirical results of this study, we further conduct a placebo test to
verify the robustness and significance of the findings through ran-
domized simulations. Specifically, this study randomly selects a
number of counties from the sample equal to the actual number of
pilot counties for rural residential land system reform, while simulta-
neously generating random policy implementation years, thereby
constructing a pseudo-treatment variable with both pilot counties and
implementation years randomly assigned. On this basis, the simula-
tion is repeated 500 times to estimate the placebo impact of rural resi-
dential land system reform on rural residents’ income. The test results
are shown in Figure 3. The kernel density distribution of the estimated
coefficients for the pseudo-reform in the randomized samples is pre-
dominantly concentrated around zero (within the range of −0.15 to
0.15). This indicates that under randomly assigned pilot regions and
implementation times, the estimated policy effects are largely insig-
nificant, with the p-values for the vast majority of randomized simula-
tions exceeding 0.1 and failing to pass the significance test. At the
same time, judging from the kernel density distribution, the estimated
FIGURE 2
Parallel trends test.
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 09 frontiersin.org
coefficients in the randomized experiments are distributed entirely to
the left of the true baseline estimate (0.171, indicated by the vertical
dashed line), demonstrating that the statistical significance of the true
estimate is not a coincidence, but rather reflects the genuine causal
effect of the rural residential land system reform. Further comparison
of the randomized simulation results confirms that the true estimate
deviates significantly from the placebo distribution, indicating that the
positive impact of rural residential land system reform on rural resi-
dents’ income is genuine and robust rather than driven by unobserv-
able factors.
5 Mechanism testing
Based on the theoretical analysis, reforms to the rural residential
land system may increase farmers’ income through two main path -
ways: first, by promoting rural industrial development, optimizing
the allocation of land resources, and improving the efficiency of land
use; and second, by facilitating the optimal allocation of labor
resources within farming households and guiding farmers to transi-
tion toward non-agricultural employment, thereby diversifying and
upgrading their income structure. Within this framework, reforms
to the rural residential land system, by clarifying rights to residential
land and enhancing land liquidity and market-oriented attributes,
not only unlock the latent value of land resources but also provide
the necessary land-based support for the development of village col-
lective economies and the introduction of external industries,
thereby driving the upgrading and transformation of the rural eco -
nomic structure. At the same time, by releasing labor resources pre-
viously tied to rural residential land, the reform has reduced the
TABLE 3 Robustness test results on the impact of rural residential land system reform on farmers’ income growth.
Variables
Dependent variable: FI
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Including
omitted
variables
Changing the
window period
Winsorization PSM-DID Clustering by city
RRLR 0.158** 0.108*** 0.128*** 0.077** 0.171***
(0.057) (0.029) (0.029) (0.032) (0.042)
Controls Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s
County FE Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s
Year FE Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s
Observations 28,392 15,345 28,392 3,484 28,392
Adjusted 2R 0.908 0.937 0.915 0.948 0.904
Variables
Dependent variable: FI
(6) (7) (8) (9)
Clustered by
province
City-by-year FE Province-by-year FE Excluding targeted
poverty alleviation
RRLR 0.171*** 0.158*** 0.158*** 0.101***
(0.042) (0.043) (0.043) (0.027)
Controls Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s
County FE Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s
Year FE Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s
Observations 28,392 28,392 28,392 18,606
Adjusted 2R 0.904 0.908 0.908 0.933
*, ** and *** indicate significance at the 10%, 5%, and 1% levels, respectively; the figures in brackets represent cluster-robust standard errors.
FIGURE 3
Placebo test results.
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 10 frontiersin.org
mobility costs for farmers to participate in non-agricultural employ-
ment, further enhancing rural households’ capacity for economic
decision-making and income optimization. To further explore this
theoretical mechanism, this section empirically examines the impact
of rural residential land system reform on these mechanism vari -
ables. By analyzing how the reform influences farmers’ decision-
making behavior at the household level, such as participation in
non-agricultural employment and the inter-sectoral allocation of
labor resources, and how it promotes the revitalization of land
resources and structural adjustment of the rural economy at the vil-
lage collective level, this paper seeks to reveal the intrinsic pathways
through which rural residential land system reform enhances farm-
ers’ income. Specifically, this paper examines whether the reform of
the rural residential land system has effectively reduced farmers’
mobility friction, improved land-use efficiency through a clear prop-
erty rights system, and promoted the expansion of the village collec-
tive economy into non-agricultural sectors. Testing the significance
of these mechanism variables not only reveals the multifaceted
effects of the reform on resource allocation and income growth, but
also provides empirical support for understanding the operational
logic of reform policies within the rural economic system.
First, based on the theoretical inferences discussed earlier, reforms
to the rural residential land system may drive the development of rural
industries by promoting the optimal allocation of land resources,
thereby fostering the growth of village collective economies and
increasing farmers’ income. Given this hypothesis, this paper utilizes
data from four waves of the China Labor-force Dynamics Survey
(CLDS) covering the period from 2012 to 2018 and matches them
precisely with counties piloting rural residential land system reforms.
During data processing, to ensure the accuracy of the analysis, obser-
vations where the community type was an urban “residents’ commit-
tee” were excluded, as were observations with missing values for key
variables. Ultimately, this paper employs the staggered difference-in-
differences model in Equation 1 for empirical analysis, replacing the
control variables with a series of village-level variables that may influ-
ence the village collective economy and farmers’ income. These
include: the actual residential population of the village, the total area
of agricultural land, the logarithm of village fiscal revenue, the loga-
rithm of fiscal subsidies from governments at all levels, the educa -
tional attainment of the village director, the presence of a primary
school within the village, the presence of a public transit stop within
the village, and the proportion of paved roads in total village road
area. To specifically measure the impact of rural residential land
system reform on the village collective economy and industrial devel-
opment, this paper selects two key proxy variables. First, to measure
the development of the village collective economy, this paper uses “last
year’s unified operating revenue of village groups (including remit-
tances from village collective enterprises)” as a proxy for the village’s
non-agricultural collective operating revenue; second, to measure
rural industrial development, this paper uses “last year’s revenue
remitted to the village by various enterprises other than village collec-
tive enterprises” as a proxy for enterprise remittances. Using these two
variables, this paper systematically analyzes whether the reform of the
rural residential land system has significantly promoted the growth of
the village collective economy and rural industries. As shown in
Columns (1) and (2) of Table 4, the results indicate that the reform of
the rural residential land system has significantly increased the operat-
ing revenue of the village collective economy while also significantly
driving the growth of enterprise remittances. Specifically, by optimiz-
ing the allocation of land resources, the reform policy has unleashed
the potential for non-agricultural industrial development within the
village collective economy, validating Hypothesis 1 of this paper. This
indicates that the reform of the rural residential land system has not
only played a positive role in the market-oriented and intensive use of
land resources, but has also promoted the transformation and upgrad-
ing of the rural economic structure through industrial development
effects.
Second, based on the theoretical inferences presented earlier, the
reform of the rural residential land system may lead to significant
growth in farmers’ income by promoting the optimal allocation of
household labor resources and encouraging greater participation of
household members in non-agricultural employment. By clarifying
the attribution of rural residential land rights and reducing the bind-
ing ties between land and labor, the reform has freed up a portion of
the rural labor force, enabling workers to shift from traditional agri-
cultural production to more profitable non-agricultural sectors,
thereby raising overall household income levels. To verify this mecha-
nism, this paper selects the proportion of non-agricultural employees
in total rural employment as a proxy variable for farmers’ participation
in non-agricultural employment. Through empirical analysis, we fur-
ther examine whether the reform of the rural residential land system
significantly influences farmers’ participation in non-agricultural
TABLE 4 Test results on the mechanism by which the reform of the rural residential land system affects farmers' income growth.
Variables
(1) (2) (3)
Village operating income Amounts remitted by
enterprises
Non-agricultural
employment
Coef. Std. Err. Coef. Std. Err. Coef. Std. Err.
RRLR 0.044** 0.018 0.030** 0.013 0.024*** 0.009
Controls Control Control Control
County FE Control Control Control
Year FE Control Control Control
Observations 715 763 28,392
Adjusted 2R 0.448 0.050 0.831
*, ** and *** indicate significance at the 10%, 5%, and 1% levels, respectively; standard errors are cluster-robust standard errors.
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 11 frontiersin.org
employment. As shown in Column (3) of Table 4, the estimated coef-
ficient on the reform of the rural residential land system is signifi -
cantly positive at the 1% significance level. This result indicates that
reforms to the rural residential land system have significantly pro-
moted the transition of farm household members into non-agricul-
tural employment, thereby validating Hypothesis 2 of this paper.
Specifically, by optimizing the circulation and utilization of rural resi-
dential land resources, these reforms have not only freed up household
labor resources, but also, by enhancing the marketization of land
rights, created more opportunities for farmers to seek work away from
home or engage in non-agricultural industries. The implementation
of the policy has effectively reduced barriers to farmers’ non-agricul-
tural employment transition, for instance by alleviating concerns
stemming from uncertainty regarding land rights and leveraging the
role of optimized land resource allocation in promoting labor mobil-
ity, thereby significantly increasing the proportion of the rural labor
force shifting to the non-agricultural sector. Further analysis indicates
that this promotional effect of the rural residential land system reform
is reflected not only in optimized decision-making at the household
level, but also in the policy’s macro-level impact on adjusting the
structure of the rural labor market. Through these reforms, the
resource attributes and property rights security of rural residential
land have been strengthened, providing rural households with greater
economic freedom and enabling them to make more rational and effi-
cient allocation decisions between land and labor resources. At the
same time, the shift of the rural labor force toward non-agricultural
industries has not only raised farmers’ income levels, but also pro-
moted the diversification and modernization of the rural economic
structure.
6 Further research
6.1 Reform of the rural residential land
system and the urban-rural income gap
In fact, as an important factor of production, rural residential
land inevitably forms a complementary relationship with labor. In
rural areas, rural residential land not only serves a residential and
productive function, but is also intrinsically linked to farmers’
employment choices and labor mobility. As the rural residential land
system has been gradually liberalized, the use and transfer of rural
residential land are no longer confined to rural villages; the strength-
ening of its market-oriented attributes has significantly driven the
migration of the rural labor force to cities and their participation in
non-agricultural employment. Against this policy backdrop, the het-
erogeneous impacts of rural residential land system reforms on the
incomes of urban and rural residents have become an important
topic worthy of investigation. This paper further analyzes the impact
of rural residential land system reform on urban residents’ income,
with the regression results reported in Column (1) of Table 5. The
results indicate that the coefficient on rural residential land system
reform is significantly positive at the 1% level, suggesting that such
reforms exert a significant income-increasing effect on both urban
and rural residents.
However, are there differences in the welfare effects of rural resi-
dential land system reform on income growth between urban and
rural residents? Specifically, does this policy have a greater stimulatory
effect on urban residents’ income, or a more pronounced driving effect
on rural residents’ income? To answer this question, this paper further
examines the impact of rural residential land system reform on the
urban-rural income gap, with the regression results shown in Column
(2) of Table 5. The analysis indicates that the impact of rural residen-
tial land system reform on the urban-rural income gap is significantly
positive at the 1% level. This finding is consistent with our theoretical
expectation that the existing pilot policies for rural residential land
system reform exhibit a “selective effect” in their income-generating
impacts across urban and rural residents.
Further analysis of possible causes suggests that two main mecha-
nisms may account for this result: First, the income-increasing effect
of the rural residential land system reform has accelerated the urban
settlement and household registration of some farmers as well as their
transition into non-agricultural employment. Due to this shift in resi-
dence and economic activity, the additional income earned by these
former rural residents is counted within the statistical scope of urban
residents’ income, thereby making the overall income-increasing
effect appear more pronounced for urban residents. Second, the
reform of the rural residential land system may have generated a
“trickle-down effect” on urban residents, whereby market-oriented
TABLE 5 Impact of rural residential land system reform on urban residents’ income, the urban–rural income gap, and the modulating effect of agricultural land transfers.
Variables
(1) (2) (3)
Urban residents’ income Urban–rural income gap Rural residents’ income
Coef. Std. Err. Coef. Std. Err. Coef. Std. Err.
×RRLR Land transferred 0.355*** 0.046
RRLR 0.206*** 0.018 0.123*** 0.013 0.117*** 0.009
Land transferred 0.201*** 0.032
Controls Control Control Control
County FE Control Control Control
Year FE Control Control Control
Observations 11,378 11,378 12,980
Adjusted 2R 0.941 0.856 0.942
*, ** and *** indicate significance at the 10%, 5%, and 1% levels, respectively; standard errors are cluster-robust standard errors.
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 12 frontiersin.org
resource transfers and rural economic development indirectly boost
the urban economy and in turn drive further growth in urban resi-
dents’ income.
6.2 The moderating effect of agricultural
land transfers
The promulgation of the Rural Land Contracting Law of the
People’s Republic of China in 2003 marked a crucial step forward in
China’s rural land institutional reform. This law clarified farmers’
rights to contracted land, allowing them to transfer their land contrac-
tual management rights in the market in accordance with the law
while retaining collective ownership of the land by rural collectives.
Under this policy framework, farmers within a village collective can
contract land from that collective and enjoy land contracting rights,
while transferring the land management rights in the market to
achieve market-based allocation of land resources. Further reform
took place in 2018, when China’s rural land system formally imple-
mented the “separation of three rights” for agricultural land, refining
the structure of property rights. Specifically, land ownership belongs
to rural collectives, land contracting rights belong to farming house-
holds, and land management rights belong to agricultural operators.
This separation of rights further clarified the legal basis and opera-
tional pathways for agricultural land transfers, provided institutional
safeguards for standardized farmland circulation, and simultaneously
promoted greater efficiency in agricultural land use. In recent years,
policies governing the transfer of agricultural land have gradually
become more standardized and have emerged as a key engine of the
Rural Revitalization Strategy. This policy has played a significant role
in raising farmers’ income levels, optimizing the allocation of agricul-
tural resources, and promoting the upgrading of the rural economic
structure. Through the transfer of agricultural land, farmers can lease
their land management rights to professional agricultural enterprises
or capable large-scale farmers, thereby securing stable rental income.
This additional income source has significantly increased the house-
hold income of farmers who transfer out their land and improved
their living standards. At the same time, the transfer of agricultural
land has promoted intensive and large-scale farming operations and
facilitated the coordinated development of the agricultural value
chain, which has not only significantly improved production efficiency
and overall agricultural returns, but also created additional income
sources for land transferees. Furthermore, existing research indicates
that the transfer of agricultural land can in turn influence farmers’
non-agricultural employment behavior ( Kung, 2002). To analyze
whether the transfer of arable land plays a moderating role in the
income-increasing effects of rural residential land system reform, this
paper introduces the county-level proportion of transferred arable
land as a measure of agricultural land transfer into the baseline model,
further exploring the moderating effect of agricultural land transfer in
the process through which rural residential land system reform pro-
motes farmers’ income growth. As shown in Column (3) of Table 5,
the coefficients on both agricultural land transfer and the interaction
term are statistically significant and positive at the 1% level, indicating
that arable land transfer plays a significant catalytic role in amplifying
the positive impact of rural residential land system reform on farmers’
income growth. A possible explanation for this result is that agricul-
tural land transfer reduces farmers’ dependence on farmland and less-
ens their excessive attachment to land resources, thereby enhancing
their stability when engaging in non-agricultural employment.
Agricultural land transfer frees up more labor resources for farming
households, enabling them to focus more on non-agricultural indus-
tries or other high-return economic activities. In addition, the stan-
dardization and scaling of agricultural land transfers have created a
more efficient agricultural operating environment, further enhancing
the profitability of agricultural production and supporting the diver-
sification of farmers’ income.
7 Conclusions and discussion
7.1 Conclusions
As global urbanization accelerates, the outflow of rural popula-
tions and the idleness of rural land have intensified, making rural land
use transition a major challenge facing countries worldwide. How to
achieve the optimal allocation of land resources and promote farmers’
income growth through institutional innovation has become an
urgent issue to be addressed. This paper focuses on the reform of
China’s rural residential land system. Based on county-level panel data
from 2010 to 2024, it employs a staggered difference-in-differences
model to assess the causal effects of rural residential land system
reform on farmers’ income and its underlying mechanisms. The main
findings are as follows: First, the reform of the rural residential land
system exerts a significant positive effect on promoting farmers’
income growth. By breaking the constraints of rigid land property
rights, these reforms have effectively unleashed the vitality of the rural
economy, significantly raised the income levels of farming households,
and provided empirical evidence for countries seeking to improve
farmers’ livelihoods through land policy interventions. Second, the
reform of the rural residential land system operates through the dual
pathways of optimizing the allocation of both land and labor
resources. Mechanism tests indicate that rural residential land reform
not only boosts the development of rural industries and contributes
to farmers’ income growth through the optimal allocation of land
resources, but also effectively alleviates households’ mobility con -
straints, facilitates the reallocation of household labor resources, and
encourages greater participation in non-agricultural employment,
thereby raising farmers’ income. Third, although the reform of the
rural residential land system has increased farmers’ income, its
income-boosting effect on urban residents is even more pronounced,
which objectively hinders the narrowing of the urban-rural income
gap. Fourth, the transfer of agricultural land plays a significant positive
moderating role in the income-boosting effects of residential land
reform. The linkage between transfer participants and transfer willing-
ness across different rural land types enables the two policies to form
an effective policy synergy in promoting farmers’ income growth.
7.2 Discussion
Based on Chinese county-level panel data from 2010 to 2024, this
study employs a staggered difference-in-differences model to system-
atically examine the causal effects of rural residential land system
reform on farmers’ income growth and its underlying transmission
mechanisms. The results indicate that rural residential land system
reform significantly promotes farmers’ income growth, operating
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 13 frontiersin.org
through two pathways: the spatial optimization of land resources and
the reallocation of household labor. First, in terms of research perspec-
tive and mechanisms of action, unlike existing literature that largely
focuses on the macro-policy effects of institutional reforms regarding
agricultural arable land or productive agricultural and pastoral land
(Zhou et al., 2020a), this study focuses on rural residential land, which
possesses both subsistence security and property attributes. Previous
literature on rural spatial planning and residential land governance
has largely been limited to qualitative case studies of specific regions
or descriptions of static correlations (Yu et al., 2018; Yin et al., 2019;
Qian et al., 2022). Drawing on resource allocation theory, this paper
deconstructs the complex reform of the residential land system into
two dimensions: the confirmation of qualification rights and the
deregulation of use rights. It empirically reveals the dual transmission
pathways of spatial optimization of land resources and the reallocation
of household labor, thereby opening the “black box” of the mecha-
nisms through which residential land reform empowers county-level
economies and increases farmers’ income. Second, in terms of theo-
retical expansion and the perspective of land tenure security, this
paper enriches and extends the boundaries of land tenure security
theory. Existing research on land property rights security and spatial
governance has primarily focused on agricultural arable land or pro-
ductive agricultural and pastoral land (Chari et al., 2021; Adamopoulos
et al., 2024), examining its impact on agricultural production effi -
ciency or farmland transfers. In contrast to these studies, this paper
extends the theoretical scope to the specific land category of rural
residential land. It proposes that the confirmation of qualification
rights for rural residential land provides property rights protection
and reduces labor mobility frictions, demonstrating that safeguarding
qualification rights can effectively alleviate farmers’ concerns about
leaving their hometowns for off-farm work. This provides a new theo-
retical framework for understanding farmers’ behavioral choices and
livelihood adaptations in the face of institutional changes within tran-
sition economies. Third, in terms of research methodology and causal
identification evidence, this paper overcomes the endogeneity limita-
tions of traditional studies. Unlike previous studies that relied on static
descriptions or isolated case studies, this paper treats the pilot reforms
of the rural residential land system, implemented by the state in
batches, as an ideal quasi-natural experiment. It employs the staggered
difference-in-differences method for empirical testing, effectively
mitigating issues of model endogeneity and sample selection bias, and
providing rigorous large-sample empirical evidence for the scientific
assessment of the micro-level welfare effects of land property rights
policy reforms. Furthermore, this study also finds that the reform gen-
erated more pronounced income spillover effects for urban residents
in its early stages; this conclusion reveals the potential risk of urban-
rural imbalances in benefit distribution during the process of rural
factor marketization. This finding aligns with the discussions by Chen
et al. (2024, 2025) regarding distributional disparities during transi-
tion periods, serving as a reminder that policymakers must balance
efficiency and equity when advancing spatial restructuring, and
enriching academic discourse on the relationship between land use
transition and inclusive growth. Although this study has made prog-
ress in causal identification and mechanism testing, several limitations
remain to be addressed in future research:
First, regarding the selection of research subjects, future stud -
ies could delve deeper into the micro level of individual farming
households. This paper primarily relies on county-level panel data
for empirical analysis; while this effectively reflects the average
income-increasing effects of reform pilot programs at the county
level, it struggles to capture the heterogeneous characteristics
within individual farming households in detail. Households with
different income levels, livelihood types, and generational struc -
tures may respond differently to the relaxation of residential land
property rights. Future research could incorporate micro-level
household longitudinal survey data to further explore the specific
impact pathways of land policies on different types of households,
and construct a comprehensive index of household livelihood
resilience using micro-survey data to assess the long-term welfare
effects of the reform.
Second, regarding the mechanisms of action, future research may
explore the underlying mechanisms through which policy effects are
realized from additional perspectives. This paper focuses on the per-
spective of factor reallocation and empirically examines two core
pathways: the spatial optimization of land resources and the realloca-
tion of household labor. Future research may further consider medi-
ating or moderating variables, such as credit support, entrepreneurial
activity, and digital village construction, to build a more comprehen-
sive framework for mechanism analysis.
Finally, regarding spatial spillover effects, future research could
introduce spatial econometric methods to examine cross-regional
factor linkages. Land use transition and spatial governance typi -
cally exhibit significant geographical correlations and network dif -
fusion effects. The staggered difference-in-differences model used
in this study primarily identifies the direct income-increasing
effects of the reform within individual counties and has not yet
fully accounted for the spatial externalities of the policy. Future
research could further construct spatial difference-in-differences
models or spatial Durbin models to systematically examine the
spatial spillover effects and radiation boundaries of rural residen -
tial land system reforms, thereby providing more comprehensive
empirical evidence to advance cross-regional collaborative rural
spatial governance.
Data availability statement
The raw data supporting the conclusions of this article will be
made available by the authors, without undue reservation.
Author contributions
JZ: Methodology, Data curation, Validation, Investigation,
Software, Formal analysis, Writing – original draft, Conceptualization.
YL: Visualization, Resources, Project administration, Writing – review
& editing, Supervision, Funding acquisition.
Funding
The author(s) declared that financial support was received for
this work and/or its publication. This work was supported by the
Zhao and Lu 10.3389/fsufs.2026.2003651
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 14 frontiersin.org
Association Project of the National Social Science Fund of China
(Grant No. 24SGC025).
Conflict of interest
The author(s) declared that this work was conducted in the
absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be
construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Generative AI statement
The author(s) declared that Generative AI was not used in the
creation of this manuscript.
Any alternative text (alt text) provided alongside figures in this
article has been generated by Frontiers with the support of artificial
intelligence and reasonable efforts have been made to ensure accuracy,
including review by the authors wherever possible. If you identify any
issues, please contact us.
Publisher’s note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors
and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organiza -
tions, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any
product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be
made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the
publisher.
References
Adamopoulos, T., Brandt, L., Chen, C., Restuccia, D., and Wei, X. (2024). Land security
and mobility frictions. Q. J. Econ. 139, 1941–1987. doi: 10.1093/qje/qjae010
Bilande, K., Veipane, U. D., Nipers, A., and Pilvere, I. (2026). A framework for profitabil-
ity-focused land use transitions between agriculture and forestry: a case study of Latvia.
Land 15:204. doi: 10.3390/land15020204
Chari, A., Liu, E. M., Wang, S.-Y ., and Wang, Y . (2021). Property rights, land misalloca-
tion, and agricultural efficiency in China. Rev. Econ. Stud. 88, 1831–1862. doi: 10.1093/
restud/rdaa072
Chen, C., Peng, R., Wu, Z., and Y e, F . (2025). The impact of high-standard farmland
construction on farmers' agricultural green production technologies adoption behavior.
Front. Sustain. Food Syst. 9:1581894. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2025.1581894
Chen, X., Xue, Z., Han, G., and Gao, Q. (2024). The impact of land consolidation on
farmer income: evidence from high-standard farmland construction in China. Front.
Sustain. Food Syst. 8:1412095. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2024.1412095
Gedecho, K. A., Y asin, A. S., Kovács, B. H., and Bacsi, Z. (2025). Rural tourism and land
use: unveiling global research trends, gaps, and future pathways. Land 14:1934. doi:
10.3390/land14101934
Han, Q., Zhou, K., Guo, Z., and Kumar, R. (2024). Understanding rural household migra-
tion and homestead exit intentions: toward sustainable land use and development goals.
J. Geochem. Explor. 267:107595. doi: 10.1016/j.gexplo.2024.107595
Imbert, C., Seror, M., Zhang, Y ., and Zylberberg, Y . (2022). Migrants and firms: evidence
from China. Am. Econ. Rev. 112, 1885–1914. doi: 10.1257/aer.20191234
Kung, J. K.-S. (2002). Off-farm labor markets and the emergence of land rental markets
in rural China. J. Comp. Econ. 30, 395–414. doi: 10.1006/jcec.2002.1780
Li, F ., Pan, X., Liu, Y ., and Wu, J. (2025). Agricultural technology extension and farmers’
income: evidence from China. Economies 13:331. doi: 10.3390/economies13110331
Liu, Y . (2018). Introduction to land use and rural sustainability in China. Land Use Policy
74, 1–4. doi: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2018.01.032
Liu, Y ., Chen, J., Cheng, W ., Wang, X., Pan, T., Liu, J., et al. (2026). Multidimensional
synergistic adaptation enhances the systemic resilience in China’s food security. Natl. Sci.
Rev. 13:nwaf587. doi: 10.1093/nsr/nwaf587.
Liu, X., Liu, D., Li, X., Gong, H., and Li, Y . (2026). Land-use policy and farmers’ livelihood
resilience: a structured review of conceptual pathways to rural revitalization. Agriculture
16:1852. doi: 10.3390/agriculture16171852
Liu, S., and Xiong, X. (2019). Property rights and regulation: the evolution and reform of
China’s rural homestead system. China Econ. Stud. 6, 17–27. 10.19365/j.
issn1000-4181.2019.06.02 (in Chinese)
Niu, J., and Zhou, Y . (2025). How rural tourism development affects farmers' livelihood
resilience: based on comprehensive survey data of rural revitalization in China. Front.
Sustain. Food Syst. 9:1573149. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2025.1573149
Ostrom, E. (2009). A general framework for analyzing sustainability of social-ecological
systems. Science 325, 419–422. doi: 10.1126/science.1172133.
OuY ang, J., He, Y ., and Hu, Y . (2026). Land resource misallocation and rural house -
hold development resilience in China's urban–rural transition. Front. Sustain. Food
Syst. 10:1933343. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1933343
Qian, Q., Wang, J., Zhang, X., Wang, S., Li, Y ., Wang, Q., et al. (2022). Improving
herders' income through alpine grassland husbandry on Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau.
Land Use Policy 113:105896. doi: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2021.105896
Qin, Z., and Sha, Z. (2026). Optimizing anthropogenic management practices can
effectively enhance the vegetation carbon sequestration in China. J. Environ. Manag.
411:130196. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2026.130196 .
Stark, O. (1991). Migration in LDCs: risk, remittances, and the family. Financ. Dev.
28, 39–41. doi: 10.5089/9781451951790.022.A013
Tombe, T., and Zhu, X. (2019). Trade, migration, and productivity: a quantitative
analysis of China. Am. Econ. Rev. 109, 1843–1872. doi: 10.1257/aer.20150811
Wu, Z., Zhao, J., and Zhang, H. (2024). Land policy deregulation and new urbanisa -
tion of county territory: evidence from rural homestead reforms. J.
Lanzhou Univ. (Soc. Sci.) 52, 26–40. doi: 10.13885/j.issn.1000-2804.2024.01.003 (in
Chinese)
Y ang, G. Q., Li, M., and Guo, P . (2022). Monte Carlo-based agricultural water man -
agement under uncertainty: a case study of Shijin Irrigation District, China. J.
Environ. Inf. 39, 152–164. doi: 10.3808/jei.202000441
Y ang, G., Li, H., Zhao, X., Y ang, J., Guo, H., Wei, D., et al. (2026). Optimized alloca -
tion of irrigation water resources based on uncertainty: model construction and
dynamic regulation mechanism. Water 18:612. doi: 10.3390/w18050612
Yin, Y ., Hou, Y ., Langford, C., Bai, H., and Hou, X. (2019). Herder stocking rate and
household income under the grassland ecological protection award policy in
northern China. Land Use Policy 82, 120–129. doi: 10.1016/j.
landusepol.2018.11.037
Yu, Z., Wu, C., Tan, Y ., and Zhang, X. (2018). The dilemma of land expansion and
governance in rural China: a comparative study based on three townships in
Zhejiang Province. Land Use Policy 71, 602–611. doi: 10.1016/j.
landusepol.2017.09.054
Zhang, J., Liu, S., Zhao, Z., Li, B., and Fan, B. (2022). Spatio-temporal features and
influencing factors of homesteads expansion at village scale. Land 11:1706. doi:
10.3390/land11101706
Zhang, Y ., Torre, A., and Ehrlich, M. (2021). Governance structure of rural home -
stead transfer in China: government and/or market? Land 10:745. doi: 10.3390/
land10070745
Zhou, Y ., Li, X., and Liu, Y . (2020a). Rural land system reforms in China: history,
issues, measures and prospects. Land Use Policy 91:104330. doi: 10.1016/j.
landusepol.2019.104330
Zhou, Y ., Li, Y ., and Xu, C. (2020b). Land consolidation and rural revitalization in
China: mechanisms and paths. Land Use Policy 91:104379. doi: 10.1016/j.
landusepol.2019.104379
论文原文与出版信息
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems