论文信息
论文解读
AI 辅助整理- 方法
- 整合GIS遥感、水文地质、地球物理、水化学与同位素等多源证据的批判性综述。
- 发现
- 裂隙、碳酸盐溶解、冲积层与暴雨径流是主要污染通道,但现有证据不足以量化风险。
- 机会点
- 可将源-路径-受体框架与同位素示踪、事件监测结合,用于干旱区填埋场风险定量评估。
论文摘要
干旱环境中的垃圾填埋场污染不仅取决于废物组成和工程控制措施,还取决于地质连通性、包气带特性、地下水条件以及间歇性补给。本批判性叙述综述综合了截至2026年9月经过同行评审的沙特阿拉伯证据,并与选定的区域和国际研究进行比较,以评估地质环境如何影响污染物迁移路径以及环境风险推断的强度。所综述的沙特场地环境包括裂隙化的阿拉伯地盾基底、阿拉伯地台的碳酸盐岩地形、浅层冲积层和干谷沉积物以及海岸受体。证据涵盖地理信息系统与遥感、地质与水文地质表征、电法、地震、磁法和雷达地球物理、渗滤液与地下水化学、土壤和沉积物地球化学、排放以及生物效应。已发表的研究表明,与裂隙和风化带、碳酸盐岩溶解、连通的冲积层以及风暴驱动的干谷水流相关的迁移路径控制反复出现。研究还记录了高浓度渗滤液、地下水恶化、局部土壤和海岸金属富集、植物毒性以及与气体相关的问题。然而,场地适宜性评分并不能证明封闭性,地球物理异常并不能唯一识别渗滤液,仅凭污染物检出并不能量化暴露或风险。稳定同位素示踪、直接水力特性测量、基于事件的监测、地球物理与化学同址观测以及长期封场后数据集在沙特垃圾填埋场研究中仍未得到充分利用。由于证据基础异质性强、地理分布不均且未按照前瞻性系统综述的方式汇编,因此未尝试进行汇总性国家风险排名。提出了一种分阶段、迭代的源—路径—受体框架,用于新场地评估以及现有处置场地的调查、修复、封场和监测。
全文
Frontiers in Environmental ScienceTYPE Review
PUBLISHED 16 November 2026
DOI 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
Geological controls on landfill
pollution and environmental risk
in arid Saudi Arabia: a critical
review of hydrogeological,
geophysical, geochemical, and
remote-sensing evidences
Majed A. Almalki*
National Aquatic Science Research Laboratory, King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology (KACST),
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
Landfill pollution in arid environments depends not only on waste composition
and engineering controls but also on geological connectivity, vadose-zone
properties, groundwater conditions, and episodic recharge. This critical
narrative review synthesizes peer-reviewed Saudi Arabian evidence through
September 2026 and compares it with selected regional and international
studies to evaluate how geological setting affects contaminant pathways and
the strength of environmental-risk inferences. The reviewed Saudi settings
include fractured Arabian Shield basement, carbonate terrains of the Arabian
Platform, shallow alluvial and wadi deposits, and coastal receptors. Evidence
spans GIS and remote sensing, geological and hydrogeological characterization,
electrical, seismic, magnetic and radar geophysics, leachate and groundwater
chemistry, soil and sediment geochemistry, emissions, and biological effects.
Published studies indicate recurring pathway controls associated with fractures
and weathered zones, carbonate dissolution, connected alluvium, and storm-
driven wadi flow. They also document high-strength leachate, groundwater
deterioration, localized soil and coastal metal enrichment, phytotoxicity, and
gas-related concerns. However, site-suitability scores do not establish
containment, geophysical anomalies do not uniquely identify leachate, and
contaminant detection alone does not quantify exposure or risk. Stable-
isotope tracing, direct hydraulic-property measurements, event-based
monitoring, co-located geophysics and chemistry, and long-term post-closure
datasets remain underused in Saudi landfill studies. Because the evidence base is
heterogeneous, geographically uneven, and not assembled as a prospective
systematic review, no pooled national risk ranking is attempted. A staged,
iterative source–pathway–receptor framework is proposed for new-site
evaluation and for investigation, remediation, closure, and surveillance of
existing disposal sites.
KEYWORDS
environmental geophysics, geological controls, groundwater contamination,
hydrogeology, landfill pollution, leachate geochemistry, monitoring, risk assessment
OPEN ACCESS
EDITED BY
Vivek Pulikkal,
Civil and Environmental Consultants, Inc.,
United States
REVIEWED BY
Elango Lakshmanan,
Anna University, India
Giovanna Orletti Del Rey,
Catholic University of the North, Chile
*CORRESPONDENCE
Majed A. Almalki,
malmalki@kacst.gov.sa
RECEIVED 17 September 2026
REVISED 30 October 2026
ACCEPTED 31 October 2026
PUBLISHED 16 November 2026
CITATION
Almalki MA (2026) Geological controls on
landfill pollution and environmental risk in
arid Saudi Arabia: a critical review of
hydrogeological, geophysical,
geochemical, and remote-
sensing evidences.
Front. Environ. Sci. 14:2002186.
doi: 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
COPYRIGHT
© 2026 Almalki. This is an open-access
article distributed under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License
(CC BY). The use, distribution or
reproduction in other forums is permitted,
provided the original author(s) and the
copyright owner(s) are credited and that
the original publication in this journal is
cited, in accordance with accepted
academic practice. No use, distribution or
reproduction is permitted which does not
comply with these terms.
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org01
Highlights
• Saudi landfill evidence has progressed from geotechnical
screening toward integrated spatial, geophysical, geochemical,
and environmental monitoring.
• Geological setting governs pathway susceptibility: fractured
basement, carbonate dissolution, shallow alluvium, wadis, and
coastal connectivity require different investigation strategies.
• Geophysical anomalies are valuable screening evidence but
require hydrogeological, geochemical, and, where appropriate,
isotope-based verification.
• Saudi studies document high-strength leachate, groundwater
and soil impacts, coastal metal enrichment, phytotoxicity, and
gas-related concerns, but isotope tracing and time-lapse
calibration remain limited.
• A staged, iterative framework is proposed for both new-site
evaluation and investigation, upgrading, closure, and
monitoring of existing or legacy disposal sites.
1 Introduction
Landfills remain an unavoidable component of municipal solid-
waste systems, even as recycling, biological treatment, and waste-to-
energy capacity expand. Their environmental significance extends
well beyond the waste body itself. A landfill is a coupled
geoenvironmental system in which waste composition, cover
condition, climate, topography, lithology, fracturing, vadose-zone
thickness, aquifer properties, and hydraulic gradients jointly
determine whether leachate and gas are contained, attenuated, or
transported toward sensitive receptors. This coupling is especially
important in arid and hyper-arid regions because low mean annual
rainfall can create a false sense of security: recharge is temporally
concentrated, storm runoff may be focused through wadis, and
fractures or karst features can bypass otherwise protective
unsaturated materials. (Christensen et al., 2001; Kjeldsen et al.,
2002; Odnoletkova and Patzek, 2023).
Saudi Arabia contains a wide spectrum of landfill settings.
Western and southwestern cities lie on the Arabian Shield, where
fractured, weathered crystalline rocks, structural lineaments, and
narrow wadi fills can dominate subsurface flow. Central Saudi
Arabia is underlain mainly by gently dipping sedimentary
successions in which fractured and locally dissolved carbonates
can transmit water rapidly. Coastal sites along the Red Sea add
alluvial, marine, and wadi-connected pathways, while urban
expansion has brought some historical dumps closer to
residential, industrial, agricultural, or coastal receptors. These
conditions mean that the same landfill design criterion cannot be
applied mechanically across the Kingdom. (Kahal et al., 2021; Loni
et al., 2013; Alharbi et al., 2025b).
Figure 1 summarizes the Saudi locations represented by the cited
landfill case studies. The map is limited to the cited study locations
and organized around the three broad geoenvironmental domains
used in this paper: the Arabian Shield, the Arabian Platform, and
Red Sea coastal/wadi settings.
This review addresses the central problem that Saudi landfill
evidence is dispersed across separate siting, geological,
hydrogeological, geophysical, remote-sensing, geochemical, and
environmental-impact studies, making it difficult to determine
which combinations of evidence are sufficient for defensible site
evaluation. The paper therefore progresses from regional and global
analogues (Section 1) to the review methodology (Section 2), Saudi
geoenvironmental controls (Section 3), remote-sensing/GIS siting
methods (Section 4), hydrogeological and geophysical investigations
(Sections 5–6), direct environmental evidence (Section 7), integrated
interpretation and international transferability (Section 8), and a
tiered investigation framework (Section 9). The proposed solution is
an explicitly integrated source–pathway–receptor approach in
which spatial screening is followed by site-specific geology and
hydrogeology, complementary geophysical imaging, direct
borehole and chemical verification, and repeat monitoring
through operation and post-closure.
For regional comparison outside Saudi Arabia, evidence from
neighboring arid Middle Eastern settings shows that low rainfall
does not protect groundwater where landfill leachate is hydraulically
connected to permeable or fractured aquifers. The El-Akader landfill
is in northern Jordan, approximately 27 km east of Irbid near the
Syrian border; groundwater sampling along the regional flow
direction identified landfill-related deterioration over a corridor
extending several kilometers from the disposal area (Abu-Rukah
and Al-Kofahi, 2001). The Ruseifa landfill is near Ruseifa city, about
15 km northeast of Amman, where very-low-frequency
electromagnetic surveys detected conductive leachate-affected
zones and groundwater pollution (Al-Tarazi et al., 2008). More
recent seasonal monitoring at the Humra landfill in Jordan again
demonstrated the need for source control, engineered lining,
surface-drainage management, and routine groundwater
surveillance in an arid carbonate setting (Al-Kharabsheh et al.,
2026). These cases are used as regional hydroclimatic analogues
not as Saudi sites and illustrate processes relevant to Saudi wadis,
fractured rocks, and carbonate aquifers.
Comparable regional siting studies also illustrate how strongly
landfill feasibility can be constrained by hydrology, geology and
urban growth. In Abu Dhabi, GIS-based multi-criteria evaluation
integrating wells, water-table depth, geology, topography, drainage,
urban areas, roads and protected sites classified only part of the
municipality as suitable and explicitly recommended field
verification before final site selection (Issa and Al Shehhi, 2012).
In Muscat, Oman, a weighted GIS analysis of twelve demographic,
land-use, topographic and hydrological parameters found that the
most suitable landfill areas represented only about 2% of the
governorate, with field checks used to test the spatial model
(Hereher et al., 2020). In Alexandria, Egypt, leachate and
groundwater analyses showed that even engineered sanitary
landfills require continued hydrochemical surveillance because
electrical conductivity, dissolved solids, chloride, sulfate, Mn and
Fe may exceed water-quality benchmarks in nearby groundwater
(Abd El-Salam and Abu-Zuid, 2015). Together, these examples
reinforce the importance of combining spatial screening with
direct field evidence rather than treating GIS suitability as proof
of environmental safety.
At the global scale, landfill investigation has shifted toward
integrated, multi-physics, multi-compartment diagnosis. Classical
electrical resistivity, ground-penetrating radar (GPR), seismic and
magnetic methods remain important for defining waste geometry
and subsurface heterogeneity (Carpenter et al., 1990; Chambers
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org02
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
et al., 2006; Orlando and Marchesi, 2001; Porsani et al., 2004; Prezzi
et al., 2005), but recent work increasingly combines methods that
respond to different physical properties. Joint ERT and time-domain
induced polarization can separate high-resistivity construction
waste from highly chargeable contaminated soil and quantify the
distribution of buried material (Chao et al., 2024). In karst terrain,
ERT reduces siting uncertainty by imaging discontinuities and
conductive pathways that regional geology alone cannot resolve
(May et al., 2024). At a valley-type landfill in South China,
researchers integrated transient electromagnetic detection,
groundwater chemistry, numerical simulation, and risk
assessment to locate four leakage zones at depths of
approximately 15–22 m and distinguish heavily, slightly, and
non-polluted groundwater locations (Lu et al., 2025).
Remote and emerging-contaminant monitoring is also changing
the scale at which landfill impacts can be assessed. Unmanned aerial
vehicle (UAV) photogrammetry can provide repeat high-resolution
digital elevation models (DEMs), orthomosaics, volume change, and
settlement measurements for active and reclaimed landfills (Mello
et al., 2022; Pasternak et al., 2024). Multispectral and radar satellite
data can track landfill footprints, vegetation stress, thermal
anomalies, and surface deformation (Papale et al., 2023).
Atmospheric observations now extend to landfill methane: global
modelling indicates that conventional inventories may
underestimate emissions at individual sites (Wang et al., 2024),
while a global satellite survey confirms strong site-to-site variability
(Dogniaux et al., 2025). Analytical targets are also expanding from
conventional ions, chemical oxygen demand (COD), and metals to
per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) and microplastics.
Tropical-landfill leachate from Puerto Rico contained dozens of
quantifiable PFAS compounds (Robey et al., 2024), recent reviews
emphasize the mobility of short-chain PFAS and the need for
complementary targeted and precursor analyses (Sabba et al.,
2025), and landfill leachate is increasingly recognized as a source
of microplastics to aquatic environments (Sun et al., 2024).
Saudi landfill research has developed in distinct phases.
Engineering-geological assessments in Jeddah emphasized the
consequences of opening waste-disposal sites without adequate
subsurface characterization and introduced geotechnical
screening for replacement sites (Amin, 2000; Qari and Sadagah,
2006). Subsequent work in Riyadh combined satellite images,
hydrology, geology, and groundwater chemistry to document
landfill expansion and contaminant plumes (Loni et al., 2013),
while chemical studies characterized highly saline, high-strength
FIGURE 1
National distribution of the reviewed Saudi landfill and dumpsite study areas and the schematic geoenvironmental domains used for synthesis.
Markers denote cited study areas rather than surveyed facility boundaries. Broad shading distinguishes the Arabian Shield, Arabian Platform, and Red Sea
coastal/wadi settings to emphasize contrasting source–pathway–receptor controls; domain boundaries are schematic and are not a substitute for site-
scale geological or hydrogeological mapping.
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org03
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
leachate (Al-Wabel et al., 2011). The last decade has seen rapid
growth in GIS–multi-criteria siting studies (Alkhuzai, 2019; Mallick,
2021; Al Khaldi et al., 2021; Arshad et al., 2023; Elkhrachy et al.,
2023), integration of explainable AI (Al Awadh and Mallick, 2024),
direct environmental-risk mapping (Alharbi et al., 2024; 2025a;
2025b), and site-scale geophysics using resistivity, seismic,
magnetic, GPR, and MASW methods (Kahal et al., 2021; Morsy,
2023; Abdelrahman and Alarifi, 2026).
Despite this progress, the national literature is fragmented by
discipline. Siting papers often treat geology and groundwater as
raster layers; hydrochemical studies may not include geophysical
pathway imaging; geophysical investigations can be interpreted
without direct borehole or fluid sampling; and remote sensing
frequently measures surface expansion rather than subsurface
risk. A review organized around the source–pathway–receptor
concept is therefore needed to connect the evidence and identify
which method combinations are defensible for arid Saudi
conditions.
This review has five objectives: (1) synthesize Saudi landfill and
dumpsite investigations that use geological, hydrogeological,
geophysical, geotechnical, remote-sensing, GIS, geochemical,
atmospheric, or biological evidence; (2) compare the diagnostic
value and limitations of the major methods; (3) evaluate what the
published results collectively imply about landfill vulnerability in
contrasting Saudi geological settings; (4) identify methodological
and geographic gaps; and (5) propose a tiered national framework
for landfill siting, baseline characterization, operational monitoring,
closure, and post-closure assessment.
2 Review approach and evidence
boundaries
2.1 Literature identification, eligibility, and
verification
This study is a structured critical narrative review of Saudi
landfill and dumpsite literature, supplemented by selected regional
and international methodological comparisons. We updated
searches and bibliographic checks through 12 September
2026 using Google Scholar, PubMed/PMC, publisher databases,
DOI/Crossref records, backward/forward reference chaining, and
targeted verification of literature suggested during peer review.
Search concepts combined terms for Saudi Arabia, the Arabian
Peninsula, and the Middle East with landfill, dumpsite, site selection,
environmental impact, geology, hydrogeology, groundwater,
leachate, remote sensing, GIS/MCDA, geophysics, gas emissions,
emerging contaminants, ecotoxicity, and risk assessment. The
review was not prospectively registered and reproducible
database-by-database screening logs and record counts are not
available; therefore, it would be inappropriate to retrospectively
label it a systematic review or to construct a PRISMA/ROSES flow
diagram. Transparency is instead provided through explicit scope,
eligibility logic, extracted evidence fields, qualitative appraisal
criteria, and clear acknowledgment of review limitations.
I prioritized peer-reviewed studies that directly investigated a
Saudi landfill or dumpsite, evaluated a Saudi candidate disposal area,
or supplied a method directly relevant to the review questions. I used
general municipal-waste-management papers only when they
provided necessary operational context, and I selected
international studies as methodological or process benchmarks
rather than climatic equivalents. For each Saudi study, the review
extracted the location, geological or hydrogeological setting (where
reported), data sources, spatial and field methods, measured
environmental media, key quantitative results, inferred transport
pathways, and principal limitations. Did not pool incompatible
concentrations, suitability indices, or geophysical parameters
across different sampling designs. Because study identification
was narrative rather than systematic, selection, publication,
language/indexing, and geographic-coverage biases remain
possible; absence from this review should not be interpreted as
evidence that no study exists.
I applied a central interpretive rule throughout: an anomaly does
not equal contamination. Low electrical resistivity can arise from
clay, salinity, moisture, or leachate; low seismic velocity can reflect
disturbed fill, weathering, fracturing, porosity, or elevated moisture;
and spectral or land-cover change does not by itself establish
subsurface migration. Stronger conclusions require convergence
between the conceptual geological model, hydraulic evidence,
direct chemistry, and one or more geophysical or spatial datasets.
2.2 Evidence appraisal and synthesis logic
I assessed evidence strength qualitatively based on convergence
among independent observations. Highest confidence was assigned
where a landfill source was linked to a receptor by a defensible
hydrogeological pathway and supported by direct chemistry plus an
independent spatial, geological, or geophysical line of evidence.
Intermediate confidence was assigned to well-designed site
studies based on either direct chemistry or geophysics with
credible geological control but limited temporal replication.
Screening-level evidence included GIS suitability maps, remote-
sensing change detection, isolated geophysical anomalies, or
single-campaign chemical surveys lacking adequate background
or upgradient controls. Throughout the manuscript, verbs such
as “reported,” “measured,” and “found” denote findings from the
cited studies, whereas phrases such as “this review interprets,” “the
synthesis suggests,” and “I propose” identify interpretations
developed in this review. Modeled quantities are distinguished
from measured observations in the tables. This hierarchy also
separates contaminant occurrence from exposure and risk:
concentrations are evaluated separately from pathway
connectivity, receptor exposure, ecological indices, human-health
metrics, and biological effects (Chambers et al., 2006; Kondracka
et al., 2021; Alao, 2025).
2.3 Contemporary methods for landfill
investigation and environmental-impact
assessment
Modern landfill assessment is increasingly multiscale. Regional
screening now combines multispectral optical imagery, Sentinel-
class radar, DEM derivatives, land-use/land-cover change, drainage
and geomorphology within GIS–MCDA frameworks. Recent
systematic evidence shows that road access, groundwater and
surface-water protection, slope and settlement buffers remain
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org04
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
among the most consistently used criteria, while fuzzy-AHP,
sensitivity analysis and explainable machine learning are
increasingly used to represent uncertainty and expose model
drivers (Al Awadh and Mallick, 2024; Bidira et al., 2026). For
operational or closed landfills, UAV structure-from-motion
photogrammetry provides centimeter-to decimeter-scale surface
models for cell geometry, volumetric change, settlement, and
cover inspection; repeat campaigns have demonstrated agreement
with conventional surveying while improving spatial coverage and
safety (Mello et al., 2022; Pasternak et al., 2024). Satellite
multispectral, thermal, and radar data extend monitoring over
longer periods and can identify surface-temperature anomalies,
vegetation response, footprint expansion, and deformation
patterns (Papale et al., 2023).
The methodological sequence also builds on two well-
established foundations. First, landfill leachate composition and
plume behavior evolve with waste age, redox conditions,
sorption, dilution, and biodegradation; therefore, monitoring
designs should interpret field chemistry within a biogeochemical
framework rather than against concentration thresholds alone
(Christensen et al., 2001; Kjeldsen et al., 2002). Second, GIS–
AHP site-selection studies have shown for more than a decade
that suitability is inherently multi-criteria and scale-dependent
(Uyan, 2014). Recent Saudi work extends that logic by adding
reliability and fuzzy-sensitivity analysis to test how design,
operation, resources, and site-selection variables affect landfill
sustainability (Chowdhury et al., 2025).
Subsurface methods are likewise shifting from single 1-D
soundings toward 2-D, 3-D and time-lapse imaging. ERT
remains the most widely transferable technique for mapping
conductivity contrasts associated with moisture, salinity, clay, and
leachate, but its non-uniqueness motivates integration with time-
domain IP, FDEM/TEM, GPR, seismic refraction or MASW, and
magnetics depending on the target (Kondracka et al., 2021; Chao
et al., 2024; Alao, 2025). IP can improve discrimination between
conductive pore fluids and polarizable waste or contaminated soil;
TEM is effective for deeper conductive leakage zones and has
recently been combined with groundwater chemistry and risk
modelling (Lu et al., 2025); seismic refraction and MASW
constrain stiffness, weathering, and mechanically weak pathways;
GPR provides high-resolution shallow structure in resistive ground
but loses penetration in saline or clay-rich media; and magnetics can
delineate ferrous waste or structural trends. Joint inversion and
petrophysical coupling, such as combining resistivity and seismic
information to estimate landfill water content, reduce ambiguity
when surface conduction and heterogeneous waste complicate
interpretation (Konstantaki et al., 2015; Steiner et al., 2022).
Hydrogeological investigation should progress in parallel with
geophysics. Current best practice includes nested or multilevel
monitoring wells, surveyed water levels and hydraulic gradients,
continuous pressure/temperature logging where feasible, slug or
pumping tests, vadose-zone characterization, storm-event
monitoring and numerical flow/transport modelling. Regional
evidence from 129 landfills demonstrates quantitatively that
landfill age and hydrogeological conditions strongly control
groundwater deterioration: shallow groundwater and gravelly
vadose zones were associated with substantially higher
exceedance rates than deeper groundwater or finer-grained
vadose materials (Wen et al., 2025). Recent valley-landfill work
integrates transient electromagnetics with groundwater chemistry,
flow simulation, and risk-based corrective-action modeling (Lu
et al., 2025), while high-density resistivity combined with
hydrogeochemical forward modeling and dissolved-organic-
matter spectroscopy can delineate core pollution zones and
separate transport, ion exchange, and organic-matter
transformation processes (Wang et al., 2025). These approaches
are particularly relevant to Saudi wadis, fractured basement and
carbonate aquifers because pathway connectivity can dominate over
mean annual rainfall.
Chemical and ecotoxicological assessment is also expanding
beyond conventional pH, electrical conductivity/total dissolved
solids (EC/TDS), major ions, chemical oxygen demand/
biochemical oxygen demand (COD/BOD), nutrients, and metals.
Fluorescence excitation-emission matrices and spectroscopic
indices can track humic-, protein-, and tryptophan-like dissolved
organic matter and, when paired with conservative ions such as
chloride, improve discrimination of landfill influence (Wang et al.,
2025). Targeted liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry
(LC-MS/MS) and precursor assays are increasingly required for per-
and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) because short-chain
compounds are highly mobile and conventional treatment can
transform precursors into terminal perfluoroalkyl acids (Robey
et al., 2024; Sabba et al., 2025). Microplastics are another
emerging leachate constituent; micro-FTIR or Raman
spectroscopy can assess their abundance, polymer type, and size
distribution after appropriate digestion and filtration (Sun et al.,
2024). For impact assessment, concentration data should be
complemented, where appropriate, by groundwater-quality
indices, contamination/enrichment factors, ecological-risk indices,
species-sensitivity bioassays, and human-health metrics such as
hazard quotient, hazard index, and lifetime cancer risk (Lu
et al., 2025).
Stable-isotope methods provide an additional layer of source
attribution when conventional ions or geophysical anomalies are
non-unique. δ2H and δ18O can constrain recharge, evaporation,
water sources, and leachate-groundwater mixing; δ13C of dissolved
inorganic carbon can identify carbon derived from landfill
degradation; and nitrogen-species isotopes can resolve
nitrification, denitrification, and other transformations along the
waste–vadose zone–groundwater pathway. Applications in the
Philippines, Poland, Italy, Israel, China, and Brazil demonstrate
the value of combining isotopes with major ions and hydrogeology
(Castañeda et al., 2012; Porowska, 2015; Andrei et al., 2021; Aharoni
et al., 2022; Zhan et al., 2024; Del Rey et al., 2025). Isotope signatures
are not unique fingerprints: mixing, evaporation, fractionation,
redox reactions, and overlapping non-landfill sources can alter
them, so source attribution requires suitable background samples
and a site-specific conceptual model.
Gas and surface-emission monitoring should distinguish
ground-based, aerial, and satellite methods (Kumar et al., 2024).
Ground-based monitoring includes surface-emission scans, flux-
chamber measurements, and monitoring at landfill-gas wells
(Mønster et al., 2019). These measurements should be
accompanied by meteorological observations to interpret flux
variability, particularly that associated with changes in
atmospheric pressure (Xu et al., 2014).
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org05
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
At the facility scale, unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) platforms
can rapidly map topography and thermal or gas anomalies while
reducing personnel exposure to unstable surfaces (Mello et al., 2022;
Pasternak et al., 2024).
At regional to global scales, atmospheric methane observations
provide an independent check on first-order-decay inventories.
Global analyses indicate that conventional bottom-up inventories
can underestimate landfill methane emissions (Wang et al., 2024),
while high-resolution satellite surveys show strong intermittency
and uncertainty among individual facilities (Dogniaux et al., 2025).
For Saudi Arabia, these developments support a nested monitoring
architecture: regulatory ground measurements for compliance,
UAV surveys for facility-scale diagnosis, and satellite
observations for regional screening and prioritization.
The evidence-selection and synthesis sequence are summarized
in Figure 2. It describes a structured narrative appraisal rather than a
documented systematic-review screening process. Table 1
consolidates representative Saudi landfill and dumpsite
investigations, allowing direct comparison of their methods,
quantitative evidence, and interpretive strengths and limitations.
3 Geoenvironmental controls on
landfill vulnerability in Saudi Arabia
3.1 Aridity, episodic recharge, and wadi-
focused transport
Saudi landfills operate mainly under arid to hyper-arid climatic
conditions, but aridity does not eliminate leachate risk. National-
scale precipitation is highly heterogeneous: most of the Kingdom
receives less than 100 mm/year, while the Empty Quarter receives
near 20 mm/year and southern mountain areas approach 500 mm/
year (Odnoletkova and Patzek, 2023). These averages mask short,
high-intensity events that can generate rapid infiltration through
disturbed cover, preferential flow along waste–soil interfaces, and
focused recharge in wadis. In southeast Riyadh, very low mean
rainfall coexists with drainage capable of transporting runoff and
leachate during storm events (Loni et al., 2013); at Khamis Mushait,
structurally influenced drainage and fractured/weathered basement
increase pathway connectivity (Kahal et al., 2021); and Wadi Al-Asla
in Jeddah illustrates the combination of seasonal valley flow and
high-strength leachate loading (Alkunaydiri et al., 2026). As an
event-scale western Saudi benchmark, the major Jeddah flash floods
of 2009 and 2011 were associated with approximately 70 and
111 mm of rain, respectively, each concentrated over about
3 hours (Youssef et al., 2016), illustrating how a single storm can
deliver a substantial fraction of the local annual rainfall within hours.
Annual-average rainfall is therefore a weak standalone indicator
of landfill safety. Site models should consider storm magnitude and
recurrence, catchment geometry, run-on/runoff routing, wadi
connectivity, infiltration capacity, antecedent moisture, and
seasonal groundwater response. Event-based sampling after major
storms is especially important because short dry-season monitoring
records can underestimate transient recharge and plume movement.
3.2 Contrasting geological and
hydrogeological settings
The reviewed sites fall into three broad geoenvironmental
settings. The first is the Arabian Shield terrain of western and
southwestern Saudi Arabia. Here, crystalline basement may
appear competent at outcrop scale while weathering, joints, faults
and narrow alluvial fills create hydraulically connected weak zones.
The Khamis Mushait open dumpsite near the industrial zone in
southwestern Saudi Arabia illustrates this behavior: geophysical data
FIGURE 2
Critical-narrative evidence-synthesis workflow used in this review. The sequence links literature identification and eligibility assessment to evidence
extraction/appraisal and thematic synthesis, with geological and hydrogeological context guiding interpretation of spatial, geophysical, geochemical, and
environmental observations.
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org06
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
TABLE 1 Representative Saudi landfill and dumpsite investigations forming the core national evidence base of this review.
Site/year Investigation Key evidence References
2000; Jeddah (Wadi
Nakhil)
Engineering geology/landfill design The legacy site lacked prior geotechnical characterization;
the study framed criteria for replacement siting and safe
closure
Amin (2000)
2006; Jeddah Satellite imagery + engineering geology + field geotechnics Screening, lineament interpretation, permeability, density
and in situ testing used to select a disposal site
Qari and Sadagah
(2006)
2011; Riyadh Leachate chemistry (80 samples) chemical oxygen demand (COD) 13,900–22,350 mg/L; TSS
2,280–8,912 mg/L; EC 42.5–58.3 dS/m; pH 5.49–6.32
Al-Wabel et al. (2011)
2013; SE Riyadh Satellite change detection + geology + hydrology +
hydrochemistry
Landfill expanded markedly; TDS/nitrate plume and metals
supported downstream leachate influence
Loni et al. (2013)
2019; Al Baha GIS suitability mapping Suitable zones concentrated in the southeastern part of the
region
Alkhuzai (2019)
2020; Makkah Geographic information System/Analytic hierarchy process
(GIS/AHP) + vertical electrical sounding (VES) + ground-
penetrating radar (GPR)
Three candidate sites identified; reported water-table depth
about 12 m at selected sites
Osra and Kajjumba
(2020)
2021; Asir Remote sensing + GIS + fuzzy-AHP High/very-high suitability concentrated in NE, east-central
and SE sectors; some existing sites fell in low-suitability
zones
Mallick (2021)
2021; Dammam Geographic information system (GIS) + multi-criteria
decision making/Analytic hierarchy process (MCDM/AHP)
Existing landfill achieved 63% suitability but violated
distance-to-wells and waste-generation-center criteria
Al Khaldi et al. (2021)
2021; Khamis Mushait VES + seismic refraction tomography + magnetics Conductive (<30 Ωm) and low-velocity zones plus mapped
faults indicated potential preferential contaminant pathways
Kahal et al. (2021)
2021; Al-Madinah Leachate +54 groundwater +44 soil samples 59.3% of water samples unsuitable for irrigation; multiple
trace elements exceeded drinking-water criteria; soil
enrichment was anthropogenic
Alghamdi et al. (2021)
2021; Kaakia, Makkah Waste characterization + LandGEM Quantified landfill-gas generation and long-term methane
recovery potential
Osra et al. (2021)
2023; Kaakia, Makkah Air quality + GPR + borehole context GPR indicated three shallow units and signal attenuation
associated with leachate-affected saturated alluvium
to ~13 m
Morsy (2023)
2023; Abha–Khamis Remote sensing + geographic information system (GIS) +
analytic hierarchy process-group decision making
(AHP-GDM)
Faults and drainage ranked highest; 20 candidate sites (100–
595 ha) were identified
Arshad et al. (2023)
2023; Najran Remote sensing + GIS + AHP/FAHP + sensitivity analysis 18.0% of area classified most suitable and 18.2% suitable;
nine thematic layers included groundwater depth
Elkhrachy et al. (2023)
2023; Asir/Abha Fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (fuzzy-AHP) + geographic
information system (GIS) + self-organizing map (SOM)/
k-means + explainable artificial intelligence (XAI)
20.6% classed very highly suitable; optimized model R2
~0.882; SHAP/LIME improved interpretability
Al Awadh and Mallick
(2024)
2024; Al-Mufarrihat,
Madinah
Leachate characterization + plant bioassays Species EC50 values ~2.67–5.51% leachate confirmed
substantial phytotoxicity
Taha et al. (2024)
2024; southern Riyadh GIS change mapping + soil geochemistry + contamination
indices
Mean Pb 561.7 mg/kg, Zn 356.8 mg/kg; ecological-risk index
averaged 154.95 with strong local hotspots
Alharbi et al. (2024)
2024; Tabuk LandGEM emissions modeling Projected landfill emissions and >15 million kWh/y
potential biogas energy by 2050
Lakhouit (2024)
(Continued)
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org07
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
resolved topsoil, weathered material, partly weathered/fractured
basement, and fresh basement, while magnetic and seismic
results identified structural trends that could transmit
contaminants toward shallow groundwater (Kahal et al., 2021).
Similar structural complexity is relevant to the Abha–Khamis
urban study area in Asir Region, where faults and drainage
received the highest decision weights in landfill-siting analysis
(Arshad et al., 2023). Comparable Saudi VES work in
southwestern hard-rock terrain shows that electrical sounding
can delineate weathered and fractured groundwater-bearing
zones within Arabian Shield settings (Alarifi et al., 2022),
supporting its use as a structural-hydrogeological complement to
landfill investigations rather than stand-alone evidence of
contamination.
The second setting is the central Arabian Platform, where
Cretaceous and younger carbonate units are locally mantled by
alluvium, sheet gravel, eolian deposits and anthropogenic fill.
Southeast Riyadh studies emphasize fractured limestone and
wadi-connected flow (Loni et al., 2013), whereas the Rumah
landfill overlies carbonate rocks affected by weathering, fracturing
and dissolution. MASW at Rumah detected repeated low-stiffness
zones in the upper tens of meters, conservatively interpreted as
susceptibility pathways that require drilling, chemistry, and fluid-
sensitive geophysics for confirmation (Abdelrahman and
Alarifi, 2026).
The third setting includes coastal and alluvial landfill
environments. The Kaakia landfill in Makkah city is underlain
by shallow alluvial sequences in which GPR delineated sand,
sand–gravel, and saturated alluvium/rock-fragment units; the
strongest signal attenuation occurred where leachate influence
was inferred near the upper aquifer (Morsy, 2023). At the Al-
Qunfudhah landfill on the Red Sea coast of western Saudi Arabia,
the environmental receptor is not only groundwater but also the
coastal zone, where potentially toxic elements in landfill material
were spatially linked to elevated concentrations in nearby
sediments (Alharbi et al., 2025b).
Near-surface materials add a second level of heterogeneity.
National soil mapping indicates that sandy textures dominate
approximately 65.64% of Saudi Arabia, followed by loam
(18.16%), loamy sand (7.18%), sandy loam (5.28%), and clay
loam (3.74%) (Alharbi and Al Rohily, 2026). These broad classes
are useful for regional context but cannot substitute for site-
specific mineralogy, grain-size distribution, porosity,
permeability, hydraulic conductivity, sorption capacity, or
gypsum/carbonate/salt content. The reviewed Saudi landfill
literature rarely reports a complete set of these quantitative
properties, which limits direct comparison of attenuation
capacity among sites and is therefore treated as a research
gap rather than filled by regional assumptions. Figure 3
summarizes these conceptual settings and distinguishes cover
deposits, bedrock, structural pathways, the water table, and a
possible leachate plume. It illustrates processes rather than
measured stratigraphy or confirmed contamination at a
specific site.
4 Remote sensing, GIS, and multi-
criteria landfill evaluation
4.1 Evolution from screening maps to
explainable decision models
Remote sensing and GIS have become the dominant tools for
regional landfill screening in Saudi Arabia because they can
integrate topography, drainage, land use, protected areas, roads,
urban buffers, groundwater depth, geology, soil, rainfall, and
lineaments over large areas. Early work in Jeddah used satellite
imagery together with engineering geology to narrow candidate
areas before field testing (Qari and Sadagah, 2006). Al Baha GIS
screening similarly showed that acceptable sites were spatially
restricted, predominantly to the southeastern part of the region
(Alkhuzai, 2019).
Methodological sophistication increased markedly in Asir.
Mallick (2021) combined remote sensing, geographic information
systems (GIS), fuzzy membership, and the Analytic Hierarchy
Process (AHP) using drainage density, land use/land cover, slope,
TABLE 1 Continued
Site/year Investigation Key evidence References
2025; Al-Qunfudhah GIS + soil/coastal sediment geochemistry + multivariate
analysis
Pb reached 1,160 mg/kg in landfill material and 120 mg/kg in
coastal sediment; spatial maps indicated migration toward
the coast
Alharbi et al. (2025b)
2025; national/arid-
landfill assessment
AHP + HAN-fuzzy sensitivity analysis Resource, design/operation and site-selection variables
dominated sustainability sensitivity
Chowdhury et al.
(2025)
2026; Rumah Historical imagery +26 MASW profiles Low-Vs weak zones (<0.76 km/s) mainly within upper 2–
12 m; used as pathway-susceptibility screening rather than
direct proof of leachate
Abdelrahman and
Alarifi (2026)
2026; Wadi Al-Asla,
Jeddah
Leachate chemistry + GPS-X process modeling Average COD 17,050 mg/L, BOD5 10,058 mg/L, NH3-N
989 mg/L and total N 1223 mg/L confirmed high-strength
leachate
Alkunaydiri et al.
(2026)
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org08
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
elevation, lineament density, the Normalized Difference
Vegetation Index (NDVI), rainfall, roads, airport proximity,
and geology. The resulting suitability model was also used to
evaluate existing landfill locations, showing that some are in
low-suitability zones, not just new candidate sites. Arshad et al.
(2023) expanded the criteria set and used AHP group decision-
making (AHP-GDM); faults (14.28%) and drainage
networks (12.80%) received the highest weights, followed by
urban proximity, land use, and roads. The study retained
20 candidate sites of 100–595 ha. Al Awadh and Mallick
(2024) subsequently coupled fuzzy-AHP with self-organizing
maps (SOM), k-means clustering, bagging, and explainable
artificial intelligence (XAI). They used SHapley Additive
exPlanations (SHAP) and Local Interpretable Model-agnostic
Explanations (LIME) to identify the factors driving
model predictions. The resulting landfill suitability
potential index classified 20.60% of the area as very
highly suitable and achieved an optimized R2 of
approximately 0.882.
Najran provides a complementary arid-city example.
Elkhrachy et al. (2023) used remote sensing and GIS to
prepare nine thematic layers, including groundwater depth,
drainage density, land use, soil, roads, elevation, slope,
residential distance and protected-area distance. AHP and
fuzzy-AHP weighting, followed by one-factor-at-a-time
sensitivity testing, classified 18.0% of the area as most suitable
and 18.2% as suitable. In Dammam, retrospective GIS/MCDM
assessment of the operating landfill produced a 63% suitability
score but identified two important non-compliances: distance to
wells and distance to the center of waste generation (Al Khaldi
et al., 2021).
4.2 Strengths and limitations of geospatial
siting models
The strength of GIS–MCDA is its ability to make regional decisions
explicit and reproducible. It can identify areas that violate regulatory
buffers, compare alternatives, and quantify sensitivity to criterion
weights. Remote sensing adds independent information on land-use
change, vegetation, drainage, urban encroachment, and change in the
areal footprint of disposal sites. Loni et al. (2013) used multi-temporal
imagery to document expansion of the mapped landfill footprint at the
southeast Riyadh disposal area; more recent studies in southern Riyadh,
Al-Qunfudhah, and Rumah likewise quantified changes in landfill
footprint through historical imagery (Alharbi et al., 2024; 2025b;
Abdelrahman and Alarifi, 2026). Thus, “landfill expansion” here
refers to an increase in mapped disposal area or landfill footprint,
not to an increase in the number of landfill facilities.
However, most suitability models simplify the subsurface. A
geology polygon does not resolve thin alluvium, buried channels,
karst cavities, fracture corridors, or local permeability contrasts. A
single groundwater-depth layer may not capture seasonal or
pumping-driven changes. Drainage density and slope cannot
replace site-scale runoff and infiltration analysis. Therefore, treat
GIS suitability as a screening layer rather than final proof that a site is
hydrogeologically safe. The strongest Saudi siting study in this
respect is Makkah, where GIS/AHP was followed by VES and
GPR to verify subsurface conditions and groundwater depth
before recommending candidate sites (Osra and Kajjumba, 2020).
Table 2 summarizes how Saudi geospatial studies progressed
from satellite-image and field-geotechnical screening to fuzzy-AHP,
group decision-making, sensitivity analysis, machine learning, and
explainable AI. The table also shows that the most defensible studies
FIGURE 3
Conceptual geological-hydrogeological settings relevant to Saudi landfill risk assessment: (A) Arabian Shield crystalline basement beneath
Quaternary wadi/alluvial cover, (B) Quaternary cover over weathered or fractured carbonate rocks of the Arabian Platform, and (C) a legacy landfill above a
shallow aquifer. Dashed lines denote faults/fractures or preferential structural pathways; solid arrows indicate conceptual migration directions; open
circles in panel (B) represent dissolution/karst features; and the shaded plume in panel (C) represents conceptual leachate migration.
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org09
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
combine regional suitability modelling with field verification or
independent environmental data.
5 Geological and hydrogeological
investigation
Geological and hydrogeological characterization converts a landfill-
siting map into a defensible environmental model. At minimum,
investigation should establish lithology, weathering profile, depth and
continuity of low-permeability units, fracture and fault architecture,
karst potential, vadose-zone thickness, aquifer type, groundwater depth,
gradient, hydraulic conductivity, and surface-water connectivity. Saudi
studies repeatedly show why this information matters. In southeast
Riyadh, sandy cover and fractured limestone favor downward migration,
while groundwater flows toward agricultural areas. Loni et al. (2013)
linked geology, drainage, imagery and hydrochemistry to a TDS/nitrate
plume emanating from the landfill. The companion groundwater-
impact literature reported higher EC, TDS, hardness, chloride,
sulfate, nitrate and Zn close to the landfill than farther away.
In the western region, Alghamdi et al. (2021) provided one of the
strongest direct environmental datasets: three leachate samples,
54 groundwater samples and 44 surface-soil samples around the
Al-Hamra Al-Assad landfill. Fifty-nine percent of the evaluated
groundwater samples were unsuitable for irrigation under the
applied criteria, and most were unsuitable for drinking due to
elevated nitrate and multiple trace elements. Soil enrichment
factors indicated extreme Mo enrichment, strong Cd and As
pollution, and significant Pb, Zn and Co enrichment, consistent
with anthropogenic influence from the landfill.
Hydrogeological risk is not determined by depth to water alone.
Deep water tables may reduce short-term risk but can still be vulnerable
where the unsaturated zone contains permeable alluvium, fractures,
karst, or preferential flow along buried drainage pathways. Conversely,
shallow groundwater beneath a thick, continuous low-permeability unit
may be better protected than a deeper but fracture-connected aquifer.
Saudi site selection would therefore benefit from moving beyond a single
’groundwater depth’ raster toward vulnerability models that include
hydraulic conductivity, recharge, aquifer confinement, vadose
attenuation, and structural connectivity.
6 Geophysical investigation of landfill
sites
6.1 Electrical, seismic, magnetic, GPR, and
MASW evidence
Geophysical methods provide the missing spatial continuity
between sparse boreholes and monitoring wells. The clearest
TABLE 2 Evolution of remote-sensing, GIS, and multi-criteria approaches in Saudi landfill studies.
Study/site Spatial approach Primary criteria or data Main contribution
Qari and Sadagah
(2006), Jeddah
Satellite imagery, geomorphology, lineaments, field
geotechnics
Area, slope, soil cover, geology, drainage, engineering
properties
Regional screening followed by
field verification
Alkhuzai (2019), Al
Baha
GIS Geological, environmental, economic and social
criteria
Suitable sites mainly in the
southeast
Mallick (2021), Asir Sentinel-2, ALOS DEM, GIS, fuzzy-AHP Drainage, land use/land cover (land use/land cover
(LULC)), slope, elevation, lineaments, Normalized
difference vegetation index (Normalized difference
vegetation index (NDVI)), rainfall, roads, airport,
geology
Sensitivity analysis; existing
landfills benchmarked
Al Khaldi et al. (2021),
Dammam
GIS, AHP/MCDM Groundwater/wells, urban area, waste-generation
center, slope, permeability, airport, highways
63% suitability; two major criteria
violated
Arshad et al. (2023),
Abha–Khamis
remote sensing (RS), GIS, analytic hierarchy Process–
Group decision-making (AHP-GDM)
15 criteria; faults and drainage highest 20 candidate sites, 100–595 ha
Elkhrachy et al. (2023),
Najran
remote sensing (RS), geographic information system
(GIS), analytic hierarchy process/fuzzy analytic
hierarchy process (AHP/FAHP), OFAT sensitivity
9 layers including groundwater depth and protected
areas
18.0% most suitable; 18.2%
suitable
Al Awadh and Mallick
(2024), Asir
Fuzzy-AHP, GIS, self-organizing map (SOM),
k-means, bagging, SHAP/LIME
Geoecological, geophysical, socioeconomic criteria 20.60% very high suitability; XAI
improved interpretability
Alharbi et al. (2024),
Riyadh
GIS + field soil chemistry Landfill boundaries, temporal expansion,
contamination indices
Surface expansion linked to
geochemical risk hotspots
Alharbi et al. (2025b),
Al-Qunfudhah
Esri historical imagery + GIS + geochemistry 2014–2025 landfill footprint and coastal
contamination
Spatial expansion integrated with
PTE migration mapping
Abdelrahman and
Alarifi (2026), Rumah
Historical imagery + MASW Landfill growth and subsurface weak-zone network Surface history combined with
pathway-susceptibility imaging
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org10
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
Saudi example is the Khamis Mushait dumpsite, where VES, seismic
refraction tomography, and ground magnetics were integrated over
fractured basement. Electrical soundings resolved topsoil, weathered
material, partly weathered/fractured basement and fresh bedrock.
Values below about 30 Ωm near the dumpsite were interpreted as
conductive, leachate-affected material. Seismic tomography
identified a corresponding low-velocity zone and an NE–SW
structure, while magnetic data mapped several fault/fracture
trends. The concurrence of conductivity, low velocity, structure,
topography and shallow groundwater made the pathway
interpretation more credible than any single dataset alone (Kahal
et al., 2021).
In Makkah city, geophysics has been used for both candidate-
landfill siting and investigation of the operating Kaakia landfill. Osra
and Kajjumba (2020) incorporated VES and GPR after GIS/AHP
screening, thereby reducing the risk that a regional suitability model
would overlook local groundwater conditions. Morsy (2023) used
100- and 400-MHz GPR at the Kaakia landfill in Makkah city and
identified a shallow alluvial sequence consisting of sand, sand and
gravel, and saturated alluvium mixed with rock fragments. Strong
attenuation at depth was associated with leachate percolation and
groundwater impact. The case also demonstrates a methodological
limitation: conductive leachate and clay-rich or saline materials can
attenuate radar energy so strongly that GPR imaging depth
decreases precisely where contamination is greatest.
The 2026 Rumah study represents a different geophysical target.
Multichannel analysis of surface waves (MASW) estimates shear-
wave velocity from Rayleigh-wave dispersion and therefore
primarily characterizes mechanical stiffness rather than leachate
chemistry (Park et al., 1999). At Rumah, 26 profiles delineated three
broad Vs. domains and repeated low-Vs weak zones (<0.76 km/s)
mainly in the upper 2–12 m (Abdelrahman and Alarifi, 2026). The
study treated these zones as susceptibility features that may reflect
disturbed ground, elevated moisture, weathering, fracturing, or
combinations of these factors, rather than as direct proof of
active leachate migration. MASW is therefore valuable for
locating weak or fractured pathways and landfill-base
heterogeneity, whereas ERT/IP, hydrochemistry, and direct
drilling are better suited to confirming conductive fluids
(Abdelrahman and Alarifi, 2026). This interpretation aligns with
recent Saudi MASW site-characterization work at Al-Ammariah,
where shear-wave velocity defined mechanical layering and near-
surface ground conditions for engineering assessment rather than
contaminant identification (Abdelrahman and Alarifi, 2025).
Figure 4 synthesizes the complementary information provided
by the principal geophysical methods discussed above. The matrix is
intentionally qualitative: ERT/VES and IP are strongest for fluid-
sensitive conductivity/chargeability contrasts, GPR is strongest for
shallow high-resolution boundaries in resistive ground, seismic
refraction and MASW constrain mechanical layering and weak
zones, and magnetic methods are most useful for ferrous waste
and structural trends. No single rating should be interpreted
independently of the site geology and verification data.
Table 3 compares Saudi geophysical case studies by target, result,
and interpretive limitations. Its main purpose is to make explicit
where direct hydrogeological or chemical calibration remains
necessary before an anomaly is attributed to landfill leachate.
As a concluding synthesis of the geophysical evidence,
international experience reinforces the need to integrate methods.
Resistivity soundings can define landfill geometry (Carpenter et al.,
1990), 3-D ERT can map waste and leachate distributions (Ogilvy
et al., 2002), and time-lapse ERT can image recirculation or plume
evolution (Clément et al., 2011). Joint electrical and seismic
inversion can improve water-content estimates and reduce non-
uniqueness (Steiner et al., 2022). FDEM provides rapid areal
conductivity mapping (Deidda et al., 2022), while integrated
FIGURE 4
Relative information contribution of commonly used landfill geophysical methods. The in-figure legend defines High, Moderate, Low, and dash (not
a principal application) ratings. The matrix is a qualitative survey-design aid rather than a universal performance ranking; actual response depends on
geology, moisture, salinity, waste composition, survey geometry, and target depth.
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org11
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
cluster analysis of geoelectrical data can help separate leachate-
related patterns from background heterogeneity (De Donno et al.,
2025). However, detailed ERT studies consistently show that
conductivity should be calibrated against ionic strength or direct
chemistry (Maurya et al., 2017), and recent multi-method studies
combine geophysics, spectroscopy and hydrogeochemistry to
strengthen groundwater-pollution attribution (Wang et al., 2025).
A complementary Saudi arid-region example from Al-Hofuf used
VES to map saline groundwater and seawater-intrusion signatures
(Abdelrahman et al., 2026), underscoring a key landfill-
interpretation constraint: low resistivity may reflect salinity from
non-landfill sources and therefore requires hydrochemical and
hydrogeological calibration.
7 Geochemical evolution and
environmental evidence
7.1 Leachate geochemistry and
biogeochemical evolution
Saudi landfill leachate studies report high dissolved salts, organic
load, and ammonium, but the available datasets represent different
landfill ages and operating conditions and should not be treated as a
single national composition. Riyadh leachate sampled by Al-Wabel
et al. (2011) had electrical conductivity of 42.5–58.3 dS/m, COD of
13,900–22,350 mg/L, TSS of 2,280–8,912 mg/L, and pH 5.49–6.32.
Wadi Al-Asla leachate was likewise high strength, with mean COD
17,050 mg/L, BOD5 10,058 mg/L, ammonia-N 989 mg/L, and total
nitrogen 1,223 mg/L (Alkunaydiri et al., 2026). These source-study
observations indicate substantial treatment demand, but cross-site
comparison is constrained by differences in sampling time, waste
history, analytical scope, and operational controls.
Leachate geochemistry evolves with waste age and stabilization
stage rather than responding to recharge by simple dilution alone.
Established process models describe shifts from acidogenic to
methanogenic conditions, with associated changes in pH, BOD/
COD, dissolved organic carbon, ammonium, methane, sulfate,
nitrate, iron, manganese, and dissolved inorganic carbon
(Christensen et al., 2001; Kjeldsen et al., 2002). Seasonal work at
a tropical landfill further showed that rain-derived oxygen can alter
redox conditions, organic-matter degradation, methane production,
and redox-sensitive species (Del Rey et al., 2020). The Saudi studies
reviewed here generally lack sufficiently long time series or
consistently reported waste age, redox state, and stabilization
metrics to reconstruct leachate evolution by stage. This is an
important limitation: high concentrations measured at one
campaign cannot by themselves define long-term source behavior.
7.2 Groundwater impacts and source
attribution
The strongest Saudi evidence for groundwater impact comes
from studies that combine source information with spatial
groundwater observations. At Al-Hamra Al-Assad, researchers
evaluated leachate, 54 groundwater samples, and 44 soil samples
together; trace elements, nitrate, electrical conductivity,
microbiological indicators, and enrichment patterns supported
landfill-related anthropogenic influence (Alghamdi et al., 2021).
Southeast Riyadh studies likewise reported a TDS/nitrate plume
and higher contamination toward the groundwater-flow direction
from the landfill (Loni et al., 2013). These cases support
monitoring designs with documented background/upgradient
conditions and multiple downgradient transects rather than
isolated wells.
Stable isotopes can strengthen source attribution when salinity,
nitrate, dissolved inorganic carbon, or electrical conductivity could
come from multiple sources. International landfill studies have used
δ2H and δ18O to evaluate recharge and leachate-groundwater
mixing, δ13C-DIC to identify landfill-derived carbon, and
nitrogen-species isotopes to resolve nitrogen transformations
(Castañeda et al., 2012; Porowska, 2015; Andrei et al., 2021;
Aharoni et al., 2022; Zhan et al., 2024; Del Rey et al., 2025).
Their principal value is as an independent line of evidence
integrated with hydraulic gradients and chemistry, not as a
standalone fingerprint. Mixing, fractionation, evaporation, and
alternative sources can modify signatures. No multi-isotope
landfill-tracing study was identified in the Saudi evidence set
TABLE 3 Saudi landfill geophysical investigations: primary targets, principal results, and interpretation constraints.
Site Methods Primary target Principal result Key caveat
Makkah candidate sites VES + GPR + GIS/AHP Water-table depth and shallow
stratigraphy
Supported selection of three sites;
~12 m groundwater depth reported
Soundings and radar need
borehole/hydraulic confirmation
Khamis Mushait VES + seismic refraction
tomography + ground magnetics
Conductive zones, weak/
weathered layers, faults
<30 Ωm and coincident low-velocity
zones near dumpsite; multiple
structural trends
Low resistivity/velocity are non-
unique without chemistry
Kaakia, Makkah 100/400 MHz GPR + borehole
context
Shallow layering and leachate-
affected saturated zone
Three layers; attenuation to ~13 m
interpreted as leachate influence
Conductive media reduce GPR
penetration
Rumah 26 MASW profiles + historical
imagery
Mechanical weak zones/
preferential-pathway
susceptibility
Low-Vs zones mainly upper 2–12 m;
competent carbonate >1.5 km/s
Vs. anomaly indicates stiffness,
not contaminant chemistry
Recommended next-
generation
ERT/IP + MASW + GPR/FDEM
- boreholes + chemistry
Fluid, structure, stiffness and
geometry
Cross-property integration can rank
verification targets
Requires repeat surveys and
consistent co-location
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org12
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
reviewed here, making isotope-enabled source attribution a clear
research priority.
Saudi groundwater studies outside landfill settings further
illustrate why background characterization is essential before
attributing salinity or dissolved constituents to waste disposal. In
Wadi Fatimah, hydrochemical and geostatistical analyses showed
strong spatial associations among TDS, chloride, sodium,
magnesium, and calcium, reflecting the combined influence of
geology, seawater intrusion, evaporation, and anthropogenic
inputs (Alshehri and Abdelrahman, 2023). Along the
northwestern Red Sea coast, groundwater salinization and
associated health-risk patterns likewise varied spatially (Alharbi
et al., 2023). These regional analogues are not evidence of landfill
impact; rather, they define plausible non-landfill background
processes that should be excluded or quantified when
interpreting landfill-related groundwater anomalies.
7.3 Soil, coastal-sediment, and
ecological risk
Alharbi et al. (2024) added a spatially resolved contamination-
index framework for surface soils around three southern Riyadh
landfills. Mean soil concentrations were particularly elevated for Pb
(561.7 mg/kg) and Zn (356.8 mg/kg). Although many metal values were
within broad global background ranges, anthropogenic enrichment was
evident for As, Cr, Pb, Zn and Cu, and isolated samples reached very
high contamination categories. The potential ecological risk index
ranged from 5.35 to 2281 with a study-wide mean of 154.95; this
spread shows that a single study-wide average can obscure localized
hotspots. These results illustrate substantial within-site heterogeneity
and should not be extrapolated to all Saudi landfills.
At Al-Qunfudhah, landfill risk extended beyond terrestrial soil
into a coastal receptor. Pb reached 1,160 mg/kg in landfill material
and 120 mg/kg in coastal sediment; Zn reached 278 and 157 mg/kg,
respectively. GIS mapping and multivariate analysis showed spatial
gradients from the landfill toward the shoreline, and several
potentially toxic elements exceeded sediment-quality thresholds
at some locations (Alharbi et al., 2025b). This Saudi case matters
because it broadens landfill assessment from aquifer protection to
marine sediment quality and shows the value of coupling historical
footprint mapping with field geochemistry.
A contrasting 2025 study of two Al-Kharj landfills analyzed
32 surface-soil samples using GIS, contamination indices, and
multivariate statistics. Most measured elements remained within
the study’s adopted screening limits; only three samples exceeded
the cited 30 mg/kg Pb threshold, and the reported ecological-risk
values remained below 40, although localized anthropogenic
enrichment of Pb, Zn, and Cr was identified (Alharbi et al.,
2025a). The contrast between Al-Kharj and hotspot-dominated
southern Riyadh shows why landfill risk should reflect site-
specific spatial patterns and background context rather than a
single national contamination label.
7.4 Air emissions, methane, and
biological effects
Landfill risk also includes gas and particulate emissions. At the
Kaakia landfill in Makkah city, measured CH4 and PM10 exhibited
pronounced local elevations, with methane peaks and
PM10 concentrations near 1 mg/m3 during the reported survey
(Morsy, 2023). LandGEM studies at Kaakia and Tabuk indicate
substantial long-term methane-generation potential and possible
energy recovery (Osra et al., 2021; Lakhouit, 2024). These models
help plan gas collection, but their uncertainty depends on waste-
placement history, degradable carbon, moisture, temperature, cover
conditions, and model parameters; field flux measurements remain
necessary for verification.
Phytotoxicity provides a biological endpoint that chemical
concentration alone cannot capture because biological response
depends on contaminant bioavailability, mixture effects, and
species-specific sensitivity. In Al-Madinah Province, Al-
Mufarrihat leachate inhibited germination and seedling growth in
cucumber, tomato, cabbage, and corn; reported EC50 values ranged
from approximately 2.67%–5.51% leachate, with lower
EC50 indicating greater sensitivity (Taha et al., 2024). This
evidence supports a broader Saudi monitoring strategy that
complements total metal concentrations with dissolved fractions,
speciation or bioaccessibility measurements, and selected
ecotoxicological assays.
The direct environmental evidence is consolidated in Table 4.
The cases span groundwater, soil, coastal sediment, air, gas
modeling, and biological receptors. The table intentionally
separates measured observations from modeled outputs and
demonstrates that both impact magnitude and evidentiary
strength vary substantially among sites.
8 Critical synthesis: geological
controls, pathways, and
environmental risk
The synthesis indicates that pathway connectivity is a more
defensible organizing principle than climate class alone. In the
fractured Arabian Shield basement, risk concentrates along
weathered zones, joints, faults, and wadi fills; at Khamis
Mushait, convergent electrical, seismic, magnetic, and
topographic evidence suggests these features but still requires
direct chemical calibration. In the central Arabian Platform,
carbonate fracturing and dissolution can create preferential
pathways that regional polygons poorly represent; Rumah
MASW study therefore provides stiffness/pathway-
susceptibility evidence rather than proof of leachate. In shallow
alluvial settings such as Kaakia, short vadose travel paths and
conductive saturated material increase both contamination
susceptibility and GPR attenuation. Coastal and wadi-
connected settings add surface-water and marine receptors, as
illustrated by Wadi Al-Asla and Al-Qunfudhah. These setting-
specific contrasts deliver the geological synthesis implied by the
title and support site-specific source–pathway–receptor models.
(Kahal et al., 2021; Abdelrahman and Alarifi, 2026; Morsy, 2023;
Alkunaydiri et al., 2026; Alharbi et al., 2025b).
Remote sensing and GIS provide their greatest value at regional
and temporal scales: they can exclude unsuitable land, quantify
landfill-footprint change, identify drainage and urban
encroachment, and support transparent multi-criteria decisions.
They cannot resolve the thin or discontinuous subsurface
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org13
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
features that often control leachate migration; consequently,
satellite-derived suitability should trigger rather than replace
geotechnical, hydrogeological, and geophysical investigation.
Geophysical interpretation is most defensible when
complementary methods respond to different physical properties.
Electrical methods are sensitive to salinity, moisture, and clay;
seismic methods to stiffness and fracturing; magnetics to ferrous
waste and structural trends; GPR to dielectric contrasts and shallow
interfaces; and FDEM to rapid lateral conductivity variation. Co-
located electrical and seismic data supported by boreholes and
chemistry provide a stronger basis for interpretation than any
single method. The Khamis Mushait investigation approaches
this strategy, whereas the Rumah study provides a structural/
stiffness screen that still requires fluid-sensitive confirmation
(Kondracka et al., 2021; Alao, 2025; Kahal et al., 2021;
Abdelrahman and Alarifi, 2026).
Landfill risk spans multiple environmental media and receptor
types. Saudi studies document groundwater-quality degradation,
soil-metal enrichment, coastal-sediment contamination, air
pollutants, methane generation, and plant toxicity. A monitoring
plan based only on groundwater wells is therefore incomplete;
receptor-specific networks may need to include soil, wadi
sediment, surface runoff, shallow and deep groundwater, coastal
sediment, gas flux, air particulates, vegetation, or biological assays.
(Alghamdi et al., 2021; Morsy, 2023; Alharbi et al., 2024; 2025b; Taha
et al., 2024).
The national evidence also remains geographically and
temporally uneven. Asir Region (including the Abha–Khamis
area), the Makkah/Jeddah urban corridor, Riyadh Region, and
Al-Madinah Region have relatively strong case-study coverage,
whereas large areas of the Kingdom are represented mainly by
broad waste-management statistics or siting models (Mallick, 2021;
Morsy, 2023; Loni et al., 2013; Alghamdi et al., 2021). Even at well-
studied landfills, few datasets span multiple wet/dry cycles, and
direct comparisons among pre-operational baseline, operation,
closure, and post-closure remain rare.
8.1 Regional-scale comparison: Arabian
Peninsula and neighboring arid
environments
Regional analogues reinforce the Saudi interpretation that
aridity must not be equated with low groundwater risk.
Northern Jordan provides a long temporal perspective. At El-
Akader, researchers investigated leachate influence over
approximately 6 km along the groundwater-flow direction and
judged it a serious threat to the local aquifer (Abu-Rukah and
Al-Kofahi, 2001). The Ruseifa case showed that VLF-EM
conductive plume mapping can extend sparse borehole
information in an arid urban landfill setting (Al-Tarazi et al.,
2008). Two decades later, seasonal sampling at the Humra
landfill in Jordan again identified the need for liners, drainage
control, routine monitoring and emergency planning (Al-
Kharabsheh et al., 2026). Across these Jordanian cases, source
loading, vadose attenuation, groundwater connectivity, and
drainage management, rather than annual rainfall alone, are the
controlling variables; these processes are directly relevant to Saudi
wadis and fractured-rock aquifers.
TABLE 4 Direct environmental evidence from Saudi landfill and leachate studies, including quantitative findings and interpretive scope.
Site Evidence base Selected quantitative findings Interpretation References
Riyadh 80 leachate samples EC 42.5–58.3 dS/m; COD 13,900–22,350 mg/L; TSS
2,280–8,912 mg/L
High salinity and organic load require controlled
leachate management
Al-Wabel et al.
(2011)
SE Riyadh Groundwater + remote
sensing + hydrology
TDS/nitrate plume initiated near landfill; metals
supported same pattern
Fractured carbonate and drainage connectivity
increased risk
Loni et al. (2013)
Al-Madinah 3 leachate, 54 groundwater,
44 soil samples
59.3% of water unsuitable for irrigation; many
drinking-water exceedances
Strong case for upgradient/downgradient
monitoring
Alghamdi et al.
(2021)
Kaakia Air quality + GPR CH4 peaks; PM10 ~955–994 μg/m3; leachate-affected
saturated zone inferred
Multi-media risk: air + groundwater Morsy (2023)
Al-
Mufarrihat
Leachate + plant bioassays EC50 ~2.67–5.51% leachate Direct evidence of phytotoxicity Taha et al. (2024)
Southern
Riyadh
36 soil samples + GIS Mean Pb 561.7 mg/kg; Zn 356.8 mg/kg; RI mean
154.95
Local risk hotspots despite heterogeneous overall
contamination
Alharbi et al.
(2024)
Tabuk LandGEM >15 million kWh/y modeled biogas potential by 2050 Gas control can be linked to energy recovery Lakhouit (2024)
Al-
Qunfudhah
18 landfill soils +19 coastal
sediments
Pb to 1,160 mg/kg in landfill and 120 mg/kg coast Evidence for coastal contaminant transfer Alharbi et al.
(2025b)
Wadi Al-
Asla
Leachate characterization +
process modeling
COD 17,050; BOD5 10,058; NH3-N 989; TN
1223 mg/L
High-strength leachate requires integrated
treatment
Alkunaydiri et al.
(2026)
Al-Kharj 32 surface-soil samples +
GIS + multivariate analysis
Localized Pb, Zn, and Cr enrichment; three samples
exceeded the cited 30 mg/kg Pb threshold; reported
ecological-risk values < 40
Mostly low overall ecological risk with localized
anthropogenic hotspots; continued monitoring
warranted
Alharbi et al.
(2025a)
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org14
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
Regional siting studies provide a second point of comparison.
Abu Dhabi used GIS–multi-criteria evaluation to combine water-
table depth and wells with geology, topography, drainage, and urban
and infrastructure constraints; although sizable areas were classified
as suitable, the authors explicitly required further field investigation
before final selection (Issa and Al Shehhi, 2012). In Muscat
Governorate, Oman, only around 2% of the governorate emerged
as highly suitable after integrating twelve demographic, topographic,
land-use and hydrologic parameters, and field verification was used
to test the model (Hereher et al., 2020). These studies support the
hierarchy proposed for Saudi Arabia: regional GIS should reduce the
search space, but local acceptance should depend on field geology,
hydrogeology and geophysics. This is especially important where
regional maps cannot resolve buried wadis, thin alluvium, fault
corridors or karstic permeability.
The Egyptian case from Alexandria illustrates another regional
lesson: engineered landfills still require environmental surveillance.
Leachate was chemically aggressive, and nearby groundwater
exceeded salinity-related parameters and selected metals (Abd El-
Salam and Abu-Zuid, 2015). This does not imply uniform
contamination across an entire site; rather, it shows spatially
heterogeneous impacts, where localized hotspots can coexist with
less-affected monitoring points. Saudi datasets show similar
heterogeneity, so landfill condition should be represented by
spatial patterns, pathway connectivity, and temporal trends rather
than a single binary label such as “contaminated” or
“uncontaminated.”
8.2 Global case studies and methodological
transferability
Recent global case studies show a clear transition from anomaly
detection to integrated process diagnosis. Chao et al. (2024)
combined ERT and time-domain IP to distinguish construction-
and-demolition waste, contaminated soil and mixed electrical
signatures, illustrating how chargeability can add discriminatory
power where resistivity alone is ambiguous. At a valley landfill in
South China, Lu et al. (2025) combined transient electromagnetics,
groundwater chemistry, numerical simulation and human-health
risk assessment; the geophysical survey identified four leakage areas
in the liner system at depths of approximately 15–22 m, and
chemistry then separated heavily, slightly and non-polluted wells.
Wang et al. (2025) went further by integrating high-density
resistivity, hydrogeochemistry, forward mixing calculations and
dissolved-organic-matter spectroscopy, identifying a core
pollution zone within about 100 m downstream and resolving
ion exchange, mineral precipitation and organic-matter
transformation. These studies represent the current benchmark
for Saudi investigations because they link geophysical geometry
to transport processes and direct chemical evidence.
Large-sample hydrogeological evidence also provides context
for interpreting Saudi site-to-site variability. Wen et al. (2025)
evaluated 129 landfills and found that pollution patterns changed
systematically with landfill age and hydrogeological setting. Shallow
groundwater, permeable gravel-rich vadose materials and pore-
water aquifers showed greater exceedance frequencies than
deeper water tables or finer-grained protective layers. This
regional-scale evidence supports the Saudi review’s emphasis on
vadose-zone texture, aquifer type and burial depth as primary
modifiers of risk. It also suggests that monitoring intensity
should be risk-stratified: sites over shallow, permeable or
structurally connected aquifers warrant denser wells, higher
sampling frequency and repeat geophysics than sites protected by
thick, continuous low-permeability sequences.
Global geophysical experience further demonstrates why
multimethod designs are preferable. Earlier landfill investigations
showed that resistivity, GPR, seismic and magnetics can delineate
waste boundaries and plume-like anomalies (Chambers et al., 2006;
Mota et al., 2004; Orlando and Marchesi, 2001; Porsani et al., 2004;
Prezzi et al., 2005), while later work emphasized 3-D/time-lapse
imaging and direct correlation with ionic strength (Clément et al.,
2011; Maurya et al., 2017). Modern reviews now treat multimethod
geophysics as a monitoring framework rather than a one-time
mapping exercise (Kondracka et al., 2021; Alao, 2025). The
Kentucky karst case is particularly relevant to Saudi carbonate
terrain because ERT reduced siting risk associated with
discontinuous karst features that surface mapping alone cannot
predict (May et al., 2024).
Remote monitoring broadens the definition of landfill
performance beyond subsurface contamination. UAV
photogrammetry has demonstrated repeatable measurement of
landfill geometry, operational volume and settlement (Mello
et al., 2022; Pasternak et al., 2024), and satellite reviews show
that multispectral, thermal and radar observations can support
footprint mapping, surface-temperature assessment, vegetation
response and deformation screening (Papale et al., 2023). For
climate-relevant emissions, global analyses show that first-order
decay inventories can substantially underestimate methane at
individual landfills (Wang et al., 2024), while direct satellite
observations reveal strong temporal and inter-facility variability
(Dogniaux et al., 2025).
Emerging contaminants provide an additional global
benchmark. Puerto Rico landfill leachate contained
51 quantifiable per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS)
among 92 analytes, with mean total PFAS concentrations
around 38,000 ng/L in the reported dataset (Robey et al.,
2024). A subsequent treatment-focused review emphasized that
mobile short-chain PFAS and precursor transformation
complicate interpretation and that comprehensive
characterization requires multiple analytical approaches (Sabba
et al., 2025). Microplastics also occur in landfill leachate and may
act as both contaminants and vectors for other chemicals (Sun
et al., 2024).
Isotope geochemistry provides a further international
benchmark for source attribution. Castañeda et al. (2012)
combined environmental isotopes and major ions to trace
leachate influence but also showed that dilution can mask
isotopic signatures. Porowska (2015) used δ13C-DIC to
investigate dissolved inorganic carbon around a reclaimed
landfill; Andrei et al. (2021) demonstrated the utility of δ2H and
δ18O in landfill–groundwater interaction; Aharoni et al. (2022)
resolved nitrogen transformations using multiple N-species
isotopes; and Zhan et al. (2024) and Del Rey et al. (2025)
combined carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, or conventional
geochemical indicators to localize or interpret landfill influence.
These examples also show that mixing, fractionation, and
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org15
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
overlapping sources must be constrained before isotope signals are
interpreted as landfill-specific.
Taken together, the international evidence suggests several
method classes that are particularly transferable to Saudi Arabia:
ERT/IP or complementary electrical methods where carbonate
fractures, wadis, or saline pore fluids create non-unique
conductivity anomalies; multimethod geophysics plus
chemistry where pathway geometry is uncertain; UAV/satellite
monitoring for settlement, footprint, cover, and methane
screening; and stable isotopes where evaporation, natural
salinity, wastewater, agriculture, or carbonate reactions
complicate hydrochemical source attribution. Emerging-
contaminant analysis is most defensible where waste
composition and receptor sensitivity justify it. These are
methodological transfers rather than imported concentration
thresholds or assumptions of environmental equivalence (May
et al., 2024; Chao et al., 2024; Lu et al., 2025; Castañeda et al., 2012;
Andrei et al., 2021; Zhan et al., 2024).
Table 5 compares Saudi evidence with selected regional and
global benchmarks. The comparison identifies transferable
practices, particularly field verification after GIS screening,
multimethod geophysics, chemistry-based calibration, emerging-
contaminant analysis, and direct methane monitoring, rather
than implying that environmental conditions are identical across
regions.
8.3 Implications for Saudi landfill
monitoring design
The transfer lessons above translate into an explicitly adaptive
Saudi monitoring design and two distinct use cases. For a proposed
new site, regional GIS–MCDA and high-resolution remote sensing
are screening tools, followed by field geology/hydrogeology, target-
specific geophysics, and direct verification before engineering
acceptance. For an existing open dump, active landfill, or legacy
site, the investigation may enter at the field/geophysical stages, with
priority shifted toward defining actual pathways, receptors,
containment condition, and evidence of impact. Closed sites
intended for redevelopment require additional settlement, cover-
integrity, gas, and post-closure surveillance. In all cases, shallow
groundwater, wadis, karst, faulting, high-permeability alluvium,
coastal receptors, or unexplained anomalies justify escalation to
TABLE 5 Regional and global comparator studies used to benchmark Saudi landfill investigation and identify transferable methodological lessons.
Region/
case
Setting Integrated methods Transferable lesson for
Saudi Arabia
References
Jordan: El-
Akader/Ruseifa/
Humra
Arid carbonate and
groundwater-dependent
setting
Seasonal hydrochemistry; VLF-
EM; source–pathway evaluation
Aridity does not prevent multi-km
groundwater impact where hydraulic
connection exists
Abu-Rukah and Al-Kofahi (2001),
Al-Tarazi et al. (2008), Al-Kharabsheh
et al. (2026)
UAE: Abu Dhabi Hyper-arid regional siting GIS–MCE using wells, water
table, geology, topography,
drainage and urban constraints
Regional suitability requires field
verification before final siting
Issa and Al Shehhi (2012)
Oman: Muscat Mountain–wadi–coastal arid
terrain
Weighted GIS overlay + field
verification
Only ~2% of region classified as most
suitable
Hereher et al. (2020)
Egypt: Alexandria Engineered landfill near
groundwater receptors
Leachate + groundwater
chemistry
Operational landfills still require
continued hydrochemical surveillance
Abd El-Salam and Abu-Zuid (2015)
China: Solid-waste
deposit
Heterogeneous buried waste/
contaminated soil
ERT + time-domain IP Chargeability improved discrimination
beyond resistivity alone
Chao et al. (2024)
China: Valley
landfill
Leakage through liner system TEM + groundwater chemistry
- numerical/RBCA risk
modelling
Geophysics identified leakage geometry;
chemistry/risk metrics verified impact
Lu et al. (2025)
China: Landfill–
river system
Groundwater plume
downstream of landfill
High-density resistivity +
hydrochemistry + DOM
spectroscopy + mixing model
Integrated approach resolved core plume
and transformation processes
Wang et al. (2025)
Puerto Rico Tropical island MSW landfills 92-target PFAS analysis +
conventional leachate chemistry
Emerging contaminants require targeted
analytical surveillance
Robey et al. (2024)
Global methane
benchmark
Landfills across multiple
climates and management
regimes
Bottom-up model correction +
satellite observations
Facility-scale methane emissions are highly
variable and may be underestimated
Wang et al. (2024), Dogniaux et al.
(2025)
International
isotope-tracing
studies
Landfill-affected groundwater
in contrasting climatic and
hydrogeological settings
δ2H/δ18O, δ13C-DIC,
N-species isotopes +
conventional hydrochemistry
Use isotopes as an independent source/
mixing/process tracer with background
characterization; avoid treating isotope
values as unique fingerprints
Castañeda et al. (2012), Porowska
(2015), Andrei et al. (2021), Aharoni
et al. (2022), Zhan et al. (2024), Del Rey
et al. (2025)
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org16
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
denser verification and repeat monitoring (Osra and Kajjumba,
2020; May et al., 2024; Lu et al., 2025).
Analytical scope should follow the source profile and receptors.
Major ions, nutrients, COD/BOD, and metals provide a core dataset,
while dissolved-organic-matter spectroscopy, PFAS, microplastics,
and stable isotopes can be added when justified by the investigation
question (Wang et al., 2025; Sabba et al., 2025; Sun et al., 2024;
Castañeda et al., 2012). Saudi landfill studies on PFAS, microplastics,
and isotope tracing remain sparse, so treat this absence as a
monitoring gap rather than evidence of absence. Regional
natural-background baselines are particularly important in saline
arid groundwater, where chloride, sulfate, TDS, and some trace
elements may have non-landfill sources. Standardized reporting of
coordinates, dates, detection limits, QA/QC, hydraulic conditions,
and geophysical acquisition parameters, together with open or
interoperable data where permissible, would greatly improve
cross-site comparison. Event-based monitoring after major floods
should complement routine schedules at wadi-connected and
shallow-alluvial sites.
8.4 Integrated environmental hazard and
risk assessment
Hazard describes a landfill source’s potential to cause harm; risk
also depends on release likelihood, pathway connectivity, receptor
exposure, consequences, and the performance of existing controls.
The reviewed Saudi studies motivate several site-specific scenarios:
leachate movement through fractures, karst or alluvium to
groundwater; storm-driven transport through wadis; metal
accumulation in soil or coastal sediment; gas and particulate
exposure; and biological effects (Kahal et al., 2021; Alghamdi
et al., 2021; Morsy, 2023; Alharbi et al., 2025b; Taha et al., 2024).
These observations do not provide numerical probabilities or justify
a national ranking of all Saudi landfills.
A defensible risk assessment should document the source–
pathway–receptor chain and the uncertainty in each link.
Quantitative human-health or ecological risk estimates require
explicit exposure assumptions and appropriate toxicity or
consequence models; where those inputs are unavailable,
conclusions should remain qualitative and bounded. Before
attributing geophysical anomalies to landfill contamination, test
them against natural salinity, clay, lithology, hydraulic
observations, and direct chemistry (Maurya et al., 2017; Lu et al.,
2025).
8.5 Mitigation hierarchy and implications for
future landfill selection and
engineering design
Mitigation should begin by avoiding demonstrable flood,
groundwater, structural, and stability vulnerabilities. Follow
regional suitability classes with field verification of geology,
seasonal water levels, permeability, drainage connectivity, and
sensitive receptors before final acceptance (Osra and Kajjumba,
2020; Kahal et al., 2021). Buffer distances and foundation
requirements should follow applicable Saudi requirements and
FIGURE 5
Staged geoscience-informed framework for landfill investigation, design, upgrading, and monitoring in Saudi Arabia. Proposed new sites generally
enter through regional screening and progress to field characterization before targeted verification, whereas existing dumps and operating or closed
landfills may enter directly at the field-model, geophysical, or verification stages according to available evidence and risk.
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org17
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
site-specific evidence; the reviewed literature does not justify
universal numerical thresholds.
Engineering controls should follow the verified conceptual site
model and waste characteristics. Key elements include an
appropriate liner or containment system, leachate collection and
treatment capacity, clean-water diversion, gas control, stable cell
geometry, erosion-resistant cover, and contingency provisions for
liner defects, drainage blockage, extreme storm loading, differential
settlement, or collection-system interruption. International good-
practice guidance provides a technical benchmark for these controls
but should not be presented as a substitute for Saudi legal
requirements (International Finance Corporation, 2007).
For new facilities, baseline monitoring should precede major
waste placement and include appropriate background/upgradient
and downgradient locations. Existing open dumps require a
different priority: source containment, fire and slope safety where
relevant, leachate/runoff control, pathway verification, and a
technically justified closure or upgrading plan. Closure
assessment should track cover integrity, leachate, gas, settlement,
and groundwater until site-specific performance criteria are met;
cessation of filling alone does not demonstrate stable
performance. Repeat geophysics can supplement direct
observations when acquisition geometry and interpretation are
reproducible (International Finance Corporation, 2007; Clément
et al., 2011).
9 A staged, iterative investigation and
monitoring framework
The staged framework in Figure 5 is a decision-support sequence
rather than a rigid one-way protocol. Proposed new landfills
normally enter at Tier 1 and proceed toward engineering
acceptance only after progressively reducing uncertainty. Existing
open dumps or operating landfills may enter at Tier 2 or Tier
3 because the location is already fixed, while closed sites may
emphasize Tier 6. The loop between Tiers 2–4 is deliberately
iterative: mapping and existing-well data define initial
hypotheses, geophysics refines the location of verification points,
and drilling/chemistry can require reinterpretation or additional
geophysics.
Decision gates are qualitative unless an applicable regulatory
threshold is available. A proposed site should not advance from
Tier 1 if mandatory exclusion criteria or unacceptable receptor
conflicts cannot be resolved. Uncertain or potentially connected
pathways identified in Tiers 2–3 trigger Tier 4 verification rather
than automatic acceptance. Contradictory drilling, hydraulic, or
chemical evidence sends the investigation back to the conceptual
model and survey design. Site acceptance, remediation, or closure
decisions should therefore be based on predefined, project-
specific criteria and documented uncertainty, not checklist
completion.
TABLE 6 Integrated landfill-investigation methods: principal targets, strengths, and interpretation limitations.
Method Main target Strength Limitation
Remote sensing/GIS Regional screening, footprint change,
drainage, land use, buffers
Synoptic, repeatable, cost-effective Cannot resolve subsurface pathways or
groundwater chemistry
AHP/fuzzy-AHP/MCDA Transparent ranking of candidate sites Integrates many criteria; supports sensitivity
analysis
Weights can be subjective; output depends on
input resolution
Explainable AI Nonlinear classification and sensitivity Can expose global/local drivers Requires careful training, independent
validation and interpretable inputs
ERT/VES Leachate conductivity, moisture, stratigraphy,
plume geometry
Strong fluid sensitivity; scalable Clay, salinity and lithology can mimic leachate
IP/TDIP Chargeability and waste/leachate
discrimination
Adds information beyond resistivity Longer acquisition; interpretation can be
complex
GPR Waste boundaries, shallow layering, voids,
interfaces
High resolution in resistive ground Strong attenuation in saline/clayey/leachate-
rich media
FDEM/EM Rapid areal conductivity screening Fast mapping over large sites Depth resolution and inversion ambiguity
Seismic refraction/MASW Stiffness, weathering, fractures, weak zones Mechanical characterization; useful for
stability/pathways
Low velocity is not specific to contamination
Magnetic Ferrous waste, lineaments, structural trends Rapid structural/waste mapping Non-unique and sensitive to cultural noise
Boreholes/wells Ground truth, stratigraphy, groundwater,
permeability
Direct verification Sparse and expensive; may miss narrow
pathways
Hydrochemistry/
geochemistry
Contaminant identity, concentration and
source indicators
Direct environmental evidence Requires temporal/background design to
attribute source
Gas/air monitoring CH4, CO2, VOCs, PM and emissions Direct operational and climate relevance High temporal variability; model results need
flux validation
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org18
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
Tier 1: Regional screening. For proposed sites, use recent satellite
imagery, DEMs, drainage, land use, protected areas, urban growth,
roads, airports, geology, lineaments, soil, and available groundwater
information. Apply mandatory exclusion criteria first, then MCDA
and sensitivity analysis to rank the remaining alternatives. For
existing sites, Tier 1 is used mainly to define receptors,
catchments, land-use change, and off-site constraints.
Tier 2: Field geological and hydrogeological model. Map
lithology, weathering, fractures, karst, wadis, geomorphic
boundaries, and containment features. Inventory and survey
existing wells to establish preliminary groundwater levels,
seasonal range, and flow direction where data are available.
Identify data gaps and candidate monitoring
locations, but defer new verification drilling and installation of
dedicated monitoring wells to Tier 4 unless an urgent safety or
regulatory need requires otherwise.
Tier 3: Targeted geophysical imaging. Select methods by target:
ERT/IP or FDEM/TEM for conductive fluids and moisture; GPR for
shallow interfaces in resistive ground; seismic refraction/MASW for
stiffness and weak zones; and magnetics for ferrous waste or
structural trends. Co-locate profiles with existing wells where
possible, use repeatable acquisition geometry, and use the
resulting anomaly/pathway model to optimize Tier 4 borehole
and monitoring-well locations.
Tier 4: Direct verification and calibration. Drill targeted boreholes
and, where needed, install monitoring wells at locations selected from
Tiers 2–3. Obtain lithological logs and samples, measure permeability/
hydraulic properties and water levels, and analyze groundwater/leachate
for field parameters, major ions, nutrients, DOC/COD, selected metals,
and source-specific contaminants. Include appropriate background/
upgradient and downgradient controls; use isotopes or other tracers
where source attribution remains ambiguous.
TABLE 7 Priority evidence gaps and recommended research actions for Saudi landfill investigation and environmental management.
Gap Current evidence Recommended action Priority
Sparse time-lapse evidence Most Saudi studies are single-campaign or short-duration Establish repeat ERT/IP, MASW/FDEM, chemistry and remote-
sensing baselines across wet/dry cycles
Very high
Hydraulic-property deficit Groundwater depth is commonly mapped, but K, gradients,
recharge and vadose properties are rarely measured
Require aquifer tests, slug tests, infiltration tests and seasonal
water-level monitoring in high-risk sites
Very high
Limited geophysics–
chemistry co-location
Some geophysical anomalies are interpreted without direct
fluid sampling
Pair geophysical profiles with wells/boreholes and collect
chemistry at anomaly and background locations
Very high
Insufficient closure/post-
closure datasets
Long-term trends are poorly documented National monitoring standard with explicit post-closure duration
and trigger values
High
Coastal and wadi receptors
underrepresented
Al-Qunfudhah and Wadi Al-Asla show distinct receptor
pathways
Prioritize coastal, wadi-connected and shallow-alluvial landfills for
integrated monitoring
High
Karst/fracture screening Carbonate terrain may contain preferential pathways below
GIS resolution
Use structural mapping, ERT, seismic, boreholes and, where
justified, tracer or hydrochemical studies
High
Uncertainty reporting Suitability classes often appear more precise than supporting
data
Report criterion uncertainty, sensitivity, cross-validation, spatial
resolution and independent field checks
High
Contaminant scope Many studies focus on major ions and metals Add DOC, selected organic contaminants, emerging contaminants
and microplastics where source profiles justify
Moderate
National data integration Data are distributed across municipalities, papers and
agencies
Develop standardized geodatabase linking landfill geometry,
geology, wells, chemistry, gas and monitoring history
High
Source attribution Urban wastewater, agriculture and industry can overlap
landfill signals
Use background controls, multivariate analysis, tracers/isotopes
where appropriate, and hydraulic evidence
High
Natural-background
baselines
Saline arid groundwater, carbonate reactions, agriculture,
wastewater and dust can overlap landfill signatures
Establish regional/site background ranges for major ions, trace
elements and, where feasible, isotopes before attributing anomalies
to landfill sources
Very high
Event-based monitoring Routine dry-season campaigns can miss episodic recharge
and storm-driven transport
Add targeted sampling and repeat geophysics after major rainfall/
flood events at wadi-connected, shallow-alluvial and fractured sites
High
Standardized reporting and
open data
Coordinates, sampling dates, detection limits, QA/QC,
hydraulic context and geophysical acquisition parameters are
inconsistent among studies
Adopt common metadata/reporting templates and share
interoperable data and monitoring histories where legal, ethical
and security constraints permit
High
Legacy/open-dump closure
evidence
Many older disposal areas lack verified containment, baseline
data and long-term closure-performance records
Prioritize source control, pathway verification, engineered closure/
upgrading, and post-closure monitoring tied to site-specific
performance criteria
High
Frontiers in Environmental Science frontiersin.org19
Almalki 10.3389/fenvs.2026.2002186
Tier 5: Engineering design, upgrading, and operational baseline. For
proposed or engineered facilities, translate the verified site model into
liner/containment design, storm-water control, leachate and gas
collection, monitoring-well placement, and trigger criteria, with
baseline measurements before major waste placement. For existing
open dumps, this tier becomes an upgrading/containment or closure-
design stage based on the verified hazards and receptors.
Tier 6: Operational, event-based, and post-closure surveillance.
Repeat selected geophysical lines, water chemistry, landfill-footprint
mapping, settlement/cover inspection, and gas measurements at
defined intervals and after major storm or flood events where
relevant. Continue monitoring through closure and corrective
action until site-specific performance criteria demonstrate stable
and acceptable conditions.
The method-selection matrix in Table 6 translates this tiered
framework into practical survey design. It clarifies which methods
address regional screening, f
论文原文与出版信息
Frontiers in Environmental Science