论文信息
论文解读
AI 辅助整理- 方法
- 三年田间随机区组试验,比较七种除草措施,测定杂草干重、防效、产量与收益。
- 发现
- 苗前二甲戊灵加苗后精喹禾灵防效达92.7%,产量与无草对照相当,收益成本比最高。
- 机会点
- 可探索基于物联网的杂草早期监测与精准变量施药,替代固定时序除草方案。
论文摘要
在印度,季初出苗的杂草限制了向日葵(Helianthus annuus L.)的产量,而农业劳动力成本的上升和短缺使得反复人工除草日益不经济。为比较七种杂草管理措施,包括芽前和芽后除草剂、机械除草和人工除草、农民惯行做法、无草对照和杂草对照,于2023、2024和2025年连续三个晚季风(晚kharif)季节在印度卡纳塔克邦班加罗尔农业科学大学区域农业研究站,在印度向日葵全印协作研究项目(AICRP)框架下开展了田间试验,采用随机完全区组设计,三次重复。所有处理均在同一宽行行距(75 × 25 cm)下实施,因此行距本身并非试验因素。芽前施用二甲戊灵(1.0 kg a.i. ha⁻¹),随后在播种后15–20天定向喷施精喹禾灵(62 g a.i. ha⁻¹),是最有效的实用处理。在实用处理中,该处理的杂草干重最低(41.3 g m⁻²),除草效率最高(92.7%),其种子产量(1646.3 kg ha⁻¹)与无草对照(1730.7 kg ha⁻¹)在统计上相当,比农民惯行做法(1073.0 kg ha⁻¹)高约53%。由于该处理所需除草劳动力较少,其净收益接近无草对照,效益成本比最高(2.6)。在各处理均值间,种子产量与花盘直径呈正相关(r = +0.78),这与季初杂草控制同生殖库大小之间的联系相一致。我们得出结论:序贯芽前和芽后除草剂方案可在不造成显著产量损失且降低种植成本的情况下,替代宽行向日葵中劳动密集型的人工除草。该方案推荐用于印度南部半干旱地区面临劳动力短缺的向日葵种植者,但在广泛采用前应在其他农业气候区进行验证。
全文
Frontiers in Sustainable Food SystemsFrontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 01 frontiersin.org
TYPE Original Research
PUBLISHED 19 November 2026
DOI 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
OPEN ACCESS
EDITED BY
Mamdouh Awad-Allah,
Agricultural Research Center (Egypt),
Egypt
REVIEWED BY
Ashraf E. Hamdy,
Al-Azhar University, Egypt
Anil Pokhrel,
Nepal Agricultural Research Council,
Nepal
Arnab Roy Chowdhury,
Bihar Agricultural University, India
CORRESPONDENCE
K. S. Somashekar
kssomashekar01@gmail.com
RECEIVED 07 July 2026
REVISED 02 November 2026
ACCEPTED 04 November 2026
PUBLISHED 19 November 2026
CITATION
Somashekar KS, Ramesh K,
Nagarathna TK, Abhishree R,
Manjunath MM, Rohith B and
Chethan YC (2026) Comparative
evaluation of integrated weed
management strategies for sustainable
sunflower production under field
conditions in India.
Front. Sustain. Food Syst. 10:1930960.
doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
COPYRIGHT
© 2026 Somashekar, Ramesh,
Nagarathna, Abhishree, Manjunath,
Rohith and Chethan. This is an
open-access article distributed under
the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License (CC BY). The use,
distribution or reproduction in other
forums is permitted, provided the
original author(s) and the copyright
owner(s) are credited and that the
original publication in this journal is
cited, in accordance with accepted
academic practice. No use, distribution
or reproduction is permitted which does
not comply with these terms.
Comparative evaluation of
integrated weed management
strategies for sustainable
sunflower production under field
conditions in India
K. S. Somashekar 1, K. Ramesh 2, T. K. Nagarathna 1,
R. Abhishree 3, M. M. Manjunath 1, B. Rohith 1 and Y. C. Chethan 1
1All India Co-ordinated Research Project on Sunflower, University of Agricultural Sciences, Bengaluru,
India, 2ICAR-Indian Institute of Oilseeds Research, Hyderabad, India, 3Department of Crop Physiology,
University of Agricultural Sciences, Bengaluru, India
Weeds that emerge early in the season limit sunflower ( Helianthus annuus L.)
yields in India, and the rising cost and scarcity of farm labour have made repeated
hand weeding increasingly uneconomical. Field experiments were conducted
over three consecutive late monsoon (late kharif) seasons (2023, 2024 and 2025)
at the Zonal Agricultural Research Station, University of Agricultural Sciences,
Bengaluru, Karnataka, India, under the All India Coordinated Research Project
(AICRP) on Sunflower. Seven weed-management practices, comprising pre- and
post-emergence herbicides, mechanical and manual weeding, the farmers’ prac-
tice, a weed-free check and a weedy check, were compared in a randomized
complete block design with three replications. All treatments were imposed at a
single wide-row spacing (75 × 25 cm), so row spacing itself was not an experi -
mental factor. Pre-emergence pendimethalin (1.0 kg a.i. ha −1) followed by a
directed post-emergence spray of quizalofop ethyl (62 g a.i. ha−1) at 15–20 days
after sowing was the most effective practical treatment. Among the practical
treatments, it recorded the lowest weed dry weight (41.3 g m−2) and the highest
weed control efficiency (92.7%), and its seed yield (1646.3 kg ha−1) was statisti-
cally on par with the weed-free check (1730.7 kg ha−1) and about 53% higher
than that of the farmers’ practice (1073.0 kg ha−1). Because it required less labour
for weeding, it gave net returns close to those of the weed-free check and the
highest benefit–cost ratio (2.6). Across treatment means, seed yield was positively
associated with head diameter (r = +0.78), consistent with a link between early-
season weed control and reproductive sink size. We conclude that a sequential
pre- and post-emergence herbicide programme can replace labour-intensive
hand weeding in wide-row sunflower without a significant yield penalty and at
a lower cost of cultivation. This option is recommended for sunflower growers
in the semi-arid regions of southern India facing labour shortages, although it
should be validated across other agro-climatic zones before wider adoption.
KEYWORDS
intercultivation, pendimethalin, quizalofop-ethyl, sunflower, weed indices
Somashekar et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 02 frontiersin.org
Introduction
Sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) is an introduced oilseed crop
that has gained ground in India over the past two decades (Prabhakar
et al., 2023) and is valued worldwide for its high-quality edible oil. The
crop originated in the southern United States and Mexico, and several
of its physiological traits explain why it has spread so readily across
Indian conditions: it is photo-insensitive, short in duration and day-
neutral in flowering, so it can be grown through much of the year. In
India it fits the kharif, rabi and summer seasons and performs on soils
ranging from alfisols to vertisols. A high seed-multiplication ratio and
easy establishment have kept it in the national oilseed basket.
India holds an awkward position in the world oilseed economy. It
accounts for roughly 12–15% of the global oilseed area and 9–10% of
edible-oil consumption, yet still imports about 13.6% of the world’s
vegetable oil. The oilseed sector contributes close to 3% of the coun-
try’s GDP and 5.98% of the value of agricultural output ( Paroda,
2013). Sunflower is grown on about 1.94 lakh ha nationally, producing
2.36 lakh t at an average of 1,214 kg ha−1. Karnataka is a leading pro-
ducer, with a state productivity of about 1,032 kg ha−1 (Indiastatagri,
2025); within the state the crop is concentrated in Raichur, Gulbarga,
Bijapur, Koppal, Bellary, Chamarajnagar, Tumkur, Chitradurga and
Gadag. Despite this agronomic promise, weeds hold sunflower yields
down, especially in the first few weeks after sowing. They compete for
nutrients, moisture, light and space, and they harbour pests and
pathogens. Hand weeding works, but labour is scarce and wages have
climbed, so for many growers it is no longer affordable.
India’s vegetable-oil deficit is structural. Domestic oilseed produc-
tion has not kept pace with the growth in edible-oil consumption, and
the shortfall continues to be met through imports ( Paroda, 2013).
Because most of the additional supply has to come from higher pro-
ductivity on the existing oilseed area, crops that fit into several seasons
and cropping windows are important to the national effort, and sun-
flower is one of them. Its national productivity of about 1,214 kg ha−1
nevertheless leaves a wide margin for improvement, and a large part
of that margin lies in avoidable yield losses. Among the pest groups
that reduce crop yields, weeds carry the highest potential for loss
(Oerke, 2006), and they are also among the most amenable to manage-
ment. Reducing weed-induced losses in sunflower is therefore a direct
and practical route to narrowing the domestic vegetable-oil gap.
Yield loss depends on the weed species, its density, the time it
emerges relative to the crop and the soil and crop condition (Zimdahl,
2004). Weed competition is among the main biotic limits on irrigated
sunflower (Mahapatra et al., 2023). Herbicides are an efficient and
economical answer, and pre- and post-emergence products can be
timed to the crop’s critical stages. No single tool is reliable on its own,
which is why integrated weed management (IWM) has become the
practical route forward. IWM blends preventive measures, monitor-
ing, rotation, tillage, crop competition, mechanical control, herbicide
rotation and mixtures, and other tactics so that weeds are checked
with the least economic, health and environmental cost (Swanton et
al., 2008).
Several weed-management approaches have been evaluated in
sunflower, each with recognised advantages and drawbacks. Two or
three hand weedings give the most complete control and usually the
highest seed yield (Tadavi et al., 2017; Bharati et al., 2020), but they
depend on labour that is increasingly scarce and costly at the time it
is needed. Mechanical intercultivation is cheaper, but it removes weeds
only between the crop rows and cannot control weeds that emerge
after the operation. Pre-emergence herbicides such as pendimethalin
control the first flush of weeds at low cost, but their residual activity
declines with time (Senseman, 2007), so later flushes escape unless a
second operation follows. Sequences of a pre-emergence herbicide fol-
lowed by a post-emergence herbicide, intercultivation or hand weed-
ing have therefore been tested ( Sankar and Subramanyam, 2011 ;
Mohapatra et al., 2020), and several gave seed yields comparable with
those of the weed-free check (Tadavi et al., 2017; Bharati et al., 2020;
Mahapatra et al., 2023, 2024, 2025). Most of these studies, however,
were conducted for a single season, in other agro-climatic zones or at
conventional row spacing; only Mahapatra et al. (2025) evaluated inte-
grated weed management at the 75 × 25 cm spacing that permits
mechanised inter-row weeding, in a single summer season in Odisha.
Few studies have compared herbicide sequences with mechanical and
cultural options over several seasons under such a wide-row layout,
together with weed indices and economics, and no such information
is available for late kharif sunflower on the Alfisols of the Eastern Dry
Zone of Karnataka. The present study was designed to address
this gap.
Crop-weed competition in oilseed agroecosystems is a contest for
a finite pool of growth resources. Crop biomass can be expressed as
the product of the solar radiation intercepted by the canopy and the
efficiency with which that intercepted radiation is converted into dry
matter, the radiation-use efficiency (RUE) (Monteith, 1977). Weeds
that emerge with, or shortly after, the crop reduce the share of incident
radiation intercepted by the crop canopy and, at the same time, draw
on the soil water and nitrogen needed to sustain leaf photosynthesis,
so that both the interception and the conversion terms decline
(Zimdahl, 2004). The consequences are greatest early in the season.
The critical period for weed control defines the window during which
weeds must be removed to prevent unacceptable yield loss (Knezevic
et al., 2002); in sunflower this window lies at roughly 14–37 days after
emergence (Knezevic et al., 2013; Ramesh et al., 2022). Wide inter-row
spaces delay canopy closure and leave more ground open to weed
establishment during this period ( Zimdahl, 2004 ), which makes
timely weed control particularly important where sunflower is grown
in wide rows.
In sunflower, weed competition acts on both the source and the
sink sides of yield formation. On the source side, reduced leaf area and
canopy photosynthesis limit the assimilate available for seed filling.
On the sink side, the number of seeds set per unit area is closely
related to crop photosynthesis around flowering (Cantagallo et al.,
1997), and head diameter defines the physical space available for flo-
rets and seeds. Weed stress during early growth can therefore restrict
the reproductive sink before the crop reaches flowering, and such a
restriction may not be fully recovered even if weeds are removed later
in the season. This source-sink framework is the physiological basis
on which the present study interprets weed-induced differences in
head diameter, seed yield and oil yield.
The choice and sequence of herbicides must also match the ecol-
ogy of the weed flora. Pendimethalin, a dinitroaniline herbicide,
inhibits microtubule assembly and acts on germinating seeds and
emerging seedlings in the treated surface soil. It is effective mainly
against annual grasses and certain annual broad-leaved weeds, does
not control weeds that have already emerged, and gives little control
of perennial weeds that regenerate from stolons, rhizomes or tubers;
its residual activity also declines with time after application (Senseman,
2007). Where weeds emerge in successive flushes, as in late kharif
sunflower, a single pre-emergence application therefore cannot be
Somashekar et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 03 frontiersin.org
relied upon to keep the crop clean through the whole critical period:
annual grasses such as Echinochloa colona and Dactyloctenium aegyp-
tium that emerge after the pre-emergence barrier has weakened, and
the perennial grass Cynodon dactylon regenerating from stolons, can
still establish. Quizalofop-ethyl, an aryloxyphenoxypropionate inhibi-
tor of acetyl-CoA carboxylase, is selective to grass weeds in broad-
leaved crops such as sunflower and controls grasses that have already
emerged (Senseman, 2007). A sequence of pendimethalin applied
pre-emergence followed by a directed post-emergence application of
quizalofop-ethyl was therefore included to target both the early weed
flush and the later-emerging grasses during the period in which the
reproductive sink of the crop is being established. Neither herbicide
controls sedges such as Cyperus rotundus, which remain outside the
spectrum of this sequence.
Against this background, the present study evaluated a set of pre-
and post-emergence herbicide regimes, alone and combined with
mechanical weeding, in sunflower grown under a fixed wide-row
(75 × 25 cm) layout adopted to allow inter-row mechanical weeding.
Row spacing was held constant and was not an experimental factor;
the study therefore compares weed-management practices within this
layout and does not evaluate the change in spacing itself. Several
weed-management indices were used alongside the agronomic data to
compare treatments on a common, quantitative footing.
Materials and methods
Experimental site
Field experiments were carried out for three consecutive late
kharif (late monsoon) seasons (2023, 2024 and 2025) at the All India
Coordinated Research Project on Oilseeds (Sunflower), Zonal
Agricultural Research Station, University of Agricultural Sciences,
GKVK, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India. The site is located at 13° 05′N
latitude and 77° 34′E longitude, at an altitude of 924 m above mean
sea level, and falls within the Eastern Dry Zone (Zone 5) of Karnataka.
The region is characterised by a semi-arid climate with the bulk of the
rainfall received through the south-west and north-east monsoons.
Annual rainfall at the site in 2023, 2024 and 2025 was 829.2, 1436.0
and 1009.4 mm, respectively (Figure 1).
Soil characteristics
A composite surface soil sample (0–15 cm) was drawn from the
experimental field before sowing and analysed for its physico-chemi-
cal properties. The soil was a typical Alfisol, red sandy loam in texture.
It was neutral in reaction (pH 6.8) with a low electrical conductivity
(0.35 dS m−1) and low organic carbon (0.48%). The soil was low in
available nitrogen (239.04 kg ha−1), medium in available phosphorus
(25.13 kg ha−1) and medium in available potassium (243.7 kg ha−1);
calcium and magnesium were high and medium, respectively, avail-
able sulphur was low (9.83 mg kg−1) and the micronutrient status was
adequate for sunflower (Table 1). Soil texture was determined by the
international pipette method and pH potentiometrically (Piper, 1966);
electrical conductivity was read on a conductivity bridge and organic
carbon estimated by the Walkley-Black wet-oxidation method
(Jackson, 1973). Available nitrogen was determined by the alkaline
permanganate method (Subbiah and Asija, 1956), and available phos-
phorus and potassium by Bray’s method and flame photometry,
respectively (Jackson, 1973).
Experimental design and treatments
The trial followed standard AICRP on Sunflower field-experimen-
tation protocols and the general guidelines of Gomez and Gomez
(1984) for agricultural field trials. The experiment was laid out in a
randomised complete block design (RCBD) with seven treatments,
each replicated three times. The gross plot size was 6.0 m × 4.0 m
(24 m2). Seed yield was recorded from the net plot, after excluding the
FIGURE 1
Annual rainfall at the experimental site in 2023, 2024 and 2025.
Somashekar et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 04 frontiersin.org
border rows, and converted to a per-hectare basis. The treatments
comprised combinations of pre-emergence and post-emergence her-
bicides with mechanical and manual weed-control practices, as
follows:
T1 (PE + IC): pendimethalin at 1.0 kg a.i. ha−1 applied pre-emer-
gence, followed by one weeding with a power weeder or intercultiva-
tion at 35 DAS;
T2 (IC): one weeding with a power weeder or intercultivation
at 35 DAS;
T3 (PE + PoE): pendimethalin at 1.0 kg a.i. ha−1 applied pre-emer-
gence, followed by quizalofop ethyl 5% EC at 62 g a.i. ha−1 as a directed
post-emergence spray on weeds at 15–20 DAS;
T4 (farmers’ practice): two intercultivations at 20 and 40 DAS and
one hand weeding at 30 DAS;
T5 (IC + HW): one intercultivation at 20 DAS followed by one
hand weeding at 30–35 DAS;
T6 (weed-free check): three hand weedings at 15, 30 and 45 DAS;
T7 (weedy check): no weed control throughout the crop period.
Abbreviations: PE, pre-emergence; PoE, post-emergence; IC,
intercultivation (power weeder); HW , hand weeding; DAS, days after
sowing. The short treatment labels used in Tables 2–5 and Figures 2–5
follow this nomenclature.
Crop husbandry
The sunflower hybrid KBSH-90 was used as the test material. The
crop was sown at a fixed wide-row geometry of 75 × 25 cm, in place
of the conventional spacing of 60 × 30 cm, to allow inter-row
mechanical weeding (power weeder/intercultivation) with adequate
clearance while keeping total plant population close to the recom -
mended level (53,333 vs. 55,555 plants ha−1). All seven weed-manage-
ment treatments were imposed at this single 75 × 25 cm geometry, and
no conventional-spacing control was included. The study therefore
evaluates weed-management practices under a fixed wide-row layout
and does not evaluate the effect of row spacing. The pre-emergence
herbicide (pendimethalin) was applied as a uniform spray within
3 days of sowing, while the post-emergence herbicide (quizalofop
ethyl) was directed onto the weeds at 15–20 DAS using a knapsack
sprayer fitted with a single flat-fan nozzle at an operating pressure of
approximately 2–3 kg cm−2 and a spray volume of about 500 L ha−1.
Applications were made in the morning under calm, dry conditions,
and the post-emergence spray was directed onto the weeds in the
inter-row space, away from the crop foliage. The nozzle size code, the
height of the nozzle above the target and the wind speed, air tempera-
ture and relative humidity at the time of each spraying were not
recorded during the trial; spray drift and crop exposure could there-
fore not be assessed quantitatively. Mechanical and manual operations
were carried out on the dates specified in the respective treatments.
All other agronomic operations and recommended package of prac-
tices, including fertilizer application, irrigation scheduling and plant
protection against insect pests, were kept uniform across all seven
treatments, including the weedy check (T7), throughout the crop
period; T7 differed from the other treatments only in receiving no
weed-control operation.
Observations recorded
Five plants were tagged at random in the net plot of each treat-
ment for recording growth and yield attributes. Plant height (cm) and
head diameter (cm) were measured at harvest. After threshing and
cleaning, seed yield (kg ha−1) and oil yield (kg ha−1) were recorded on
a plot basis and converted to a per-hectare basis. Oil content (%) was
estimated in seed samples drawn from each plot. The weed flora of the
experimental field was identified and grouped into grasses, broad-
leaved weeds and sedges. Weed population (number m−2) and weed
dry weight (g m−2) were recorded using a quadrat at harvest; weed dry
weight was determined after oven-drying the sampled weeds to a con-
stant weight. Population counts (data not shown) tracked the same
treatment ranking as dry weight in all 3 years; weed dry weight, which
integrates both the number and vigour of surviving weeds, was
adopted as the primary quantitative index of weed suppression
(Table 5) and is the basis for the weed control efficiency (WCE) values
reported. Methodological limitation of harvest-time weed sampling:
weed population and dry weight were recorded only once, at harvest,
and no weed observations were made during the critical period for
weed control, which in sunflower lies at roughly 14–37 days after
emergence (Knezevic et al., 2013; Ramesh et al., 2022). Weeds that
emerge after the crop canopy has closed contribute little to seed-yield
loss (Knezevic et al., 2002) but are included in harvest-time samples
and inflate the weed biomass recorded. The harvest-time data there-
fore capture weed persistence and the potential contribution of surviv-
ing weeds to the soil seedbank, not the competitive stress imposed on
the crop during the critical early-season window. Because weed con-
trol efficiency (WCE) and the herbicide efficiency index (HEI) are
calculated from these harvest-time dry weights, both indices should
be read as measures of season-end weed suppression and may not
reflect the relative control achieved during the critical period.
TABLE 1 Chemical properties of the soil at the experimental site.
Parameter Value Status Method/
reference
pH 6.8 Neutral Piper (1966)
EC (dS m⁻1) 0.35 Low Jackson (1973)
Organic carbon (%) 0.48 Low Walkley and Black
(1934)
Available N (kg ha⁻1) 239.04 Low Subbiah and Asija
(1956)
Available P (kg ha⁻1) 25.13 Medium Jackson (1973)
Available K (kg ha⁻1) 243.70 Medium Jackson (1973)
Calcium (meq
100 g⁻1)
5.32 High Jackson (1973)
Magnesium (meq
100 g⁻1)
1.08 Medium Jackson (1973)
Sulphur (mg kg⁻1) 9.83 Low Bardsley and
Lancaster (1965)
Iron (ppm) 39.12 Sufficient Lindsay and
Norvell (1978)
Manganese (ppm) 18.55 Sufficient Lindsay and
Norvell (1978)
Zinc (ppm) 1.07 Sufficient Lindsay and
Norvell (1978)
Copper (ppm) 0.46 Sufficient Lindsay and
Norvell (1978)
Somashekar et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 05 frontiersin.org
Early-season (e.g., 30–35 DAS) weed counts and dry weights are rec-
ommended in future trials.
Weed-management indices
To compare treatments on a common quantitative basis, the follow-
ing weed-management indices were computed for each season from the
treatment means of seed yield (Table 4) and weed dry weight at harvest
(Table 5); the seasonal values of WI, HEI and WMI were then analysed
as a randomised complete block with the three seasons as replicates, and
treatment means were separated by the CD at p = 0.05:
Weed control efficiency (WCE, %; Mani et al., 1973) was worked
out from the reduction in weed dry weight in a treated plot relative to
the unweeded check: WCE = [(WC − WT) / WC] × 100, where WC and
WT are the weed dry weights in the control and treated plots, respec-
tively. WCE was calculated for each year from the treatment mean
weed dry weights of that year, using the unweeded control of the same
year as the reference ( Table 5), and for the pooled data from the
pooled mean weed dry weights.
Weed index (WI, %; Gill and Kumar, 1969) expresses the yield
reduction in a treatment relative to the weed-free plot:
WI = [(YWF − YT) / YWF] × 100, where YWF and YT are the seed yields
of the weed-free and treated plots, respectively. A higher value indi-
cates greater loss.
Herbicide efficiency index (HEI; Krishnamurthy et al., 1975) indi-
cates the weed-killing potential of a treatment relative to its effect on
TABLE 2 Plant height and head diameter of sunflower as influenced by integrated weed management under a fixed 75 × 25 cm wide-row layout.
Treatment Plant height (cm) Head diameter (cm)
2023 2024 2025 Pooled 2023 2024 2025 Pooled
T1: Pendimethalin
PE + IC 35 DAS
154.8 156.1 150.2 153.7 16.86 16.45 15.78 16.36
T2: IC 35 DAS 134.1 135.4 131.5 133.7 12.77 12.91 12.05 12.58
T3: Pendimethalin
PE + quizalofop ethyl
PoE
162.9 164.2 153.9 160.3 17.04 16.95 16.45 16.81
T4: Farmers’ practice 148.5 149.8 145.6 148.0 15.39 15.27 14.29 14.98
T5: IC 20 DAS + HW
30–35 DAS
145.8 147.1 140.9 144.6 12.03 11.89 11.46 11.79
T6: Weed free 164.7 166 157.4 162.7 18.59 18.43 17.55 18.19
T7: Unweeded control 133.2 134.5 127.7 131.8 9.77 9.7 8.78 9.42
S. Em± 1.23 1.16 1.88 1.42 0.57 0.54 0.56 0.56
CD (p = 0.05) 3.79 3.57 5.79 4.36 1.76 1.66 1.73 1.72
PE, pre-emergence; PoE, post-emergence; IC, intercultivation; HW , hand weeding; DAS, days after sowing (abbreviations apply to Tables 2–5). Pooled = mean of the three seasons, with S. Em±
and CD from the pooled analysis. Y ear-wise CD = t (0.05, 12) × √2 × S. Em±. Values in bold are the standard error of the mean (S. Em±) and the critical difference (CD) at p = 0.05.
TABLE 3 Oil content and oil yield of sunflower as influenced by integrated weed management under a fixed 75 × 25 cm wide-row layout.
Treatment Oil content (%) Oil yield (kg ha⁻1)
2023 2024 2025 2023 2024 2025 Pooled
T1: Pendimethalin
PE + IC 35 DAS
38.68 38.59 38.15 585 597 564 582.0
T2: IC 35 DAS 38.28 38.25 37.75 367 380 357 368.0
T3: Pendimethalin
PE + quizalofop ethyl
PoE
38.84 38.79 38.31 638 651 621 636.7
T4: Farmers’ practice 38.33 38.35 37.8 411 425 392 409.3
T5: IC 20 DAS + HW
30–35 DAS
38.3 38.3 37.77 541 555 519 538.3
T6: Weed free 39.11 38.86 38.58 678 687 652 672.3
T7: Unweeded control 37.68 37.49 37.15 355 367 338 353.3
S. Em± 0.69 0.71 0.13 14.16 14.26 25.66 18.03
CD (p = 0.05) NS NS 0.40 43.63 43.94 79.07 54.34
Oil yield is pooled over the three seasons; oil content was not pooled because its error variances were heterogeneous across seasons (Bartlett’s test, p < 0.001). NS, non-significant.
Values in bold are the standard error of the mean (S. Em±) and the critical difference (CD) at p = 0.05.
Somashekar et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 06 frontiersin.org
the crop, derived from the relative increase in seed yield over the
unweeded control and the treated-to-control ratio of weed dry weight,
expressed as HEI = [(YT − YC)/YC] ÷ (WT/WC), where YT and YC are
the seed yields and WT and WC the weed dry weights of the treated
plot and the unweeded control, respectively. HEI is not defined for the
weed-free check, in which WT = 0.
Weed management index (WMI; Mishra and Misra, 1997) was
computed from the relative yield gain [(YT − YC) / YC] and the relative
reduction in weed dry weight [(WC − WT)/WC], and was expressed as
the ratio of the two, i.e., the relative yield gain obtained per unit of
relative weed control: WMI = [(YT − YC)/YC] ÷ [(WC − WT)/WC].
Economic analysis
The cost of cultivation of each treatment was worked out from the
prevailing costs of inputs, labour and machinery, including the cost of
the herbicides and of each weed-control operation. Gross returns were
calculated by multiplying the seed yield by the prevailing market price
of sunflower seed, net returns as gross returns minus the cost of cul-
tivation, and the benefit–cost (B:C) ratio as gross returns divided by
the cost of cultivation.
Statistical analysis
The data recorded on growth, yield, weed parameters and eco -
nomics were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOV A) appropriate
for a randomised complete block design (Gomez and Gomez, 1984).
The significance of treatment effects was tested by the F-test at the
5% probability level. Wherever the treatment effects were signifi -
cant, the critical difference (CD) at p = 0.05 was computed as t (0.05,
error df) × √2 × S. Em ± (error df = 12 in each season) for mean
separation; treatment means that did not differ by more than the CD
were considered statistically on par. Standard error of the mean
(S. Em±) is reported alongside each set of means. Homogeneity of
error variances across the three seasons was tested with Bartlett’s test
before pooling. Error variances were homogeneous for all traits
except oil content (p < 0.001), for which treatment effects are inter -
preted season by season; for the other traits, a pooled analysis over
the three seasons was carried out ( Gomez and Gomez, 1984 ) to
assess the consistency of treatment responses. The treatment × year
interaction was non-significant for the pooled traits, supporting the
use of pooled means; year-wise and pooled means are presented in
Tables 2–5. In addition, relationships among independently mea -
sured growth, yield and weed traits were examined using Pearson
correlation and linear regression on treatment means ( n = 7).
Results and discussion
Grasses, broad-leaved weeds and sedges
dominated the experimental field
The dominant weeds in the experimental field were Echinochloa
colona, Cynodon dactylon and Dactyloctenium aegyptium among
grasses; Celosia argentea, Abutilon indicum, Amaranthus viridis,
Parthenium hysterophorus, Portulaca oleracea and Commelina bengha-
lensis among broad-leaved weeds; and Cyperus rotundus among
sedges. A comparable flora was reported by Sankar and Subramanyam
(2011) and Baskaran and Kavimani (2014).
Soil fertility status likely sharpened the
crop-weed competition observed
The site’s low organic carbon (0.48%) and low available nitrogen
offer little competitive buffering for the crop, so early nutrient capture
by weeds is likely to have been especially costly in this soil; this may
help explain why the treatments that began with a pre-emergence her-
bicide (T3, T1) showed the clearest separation from the cultural-only
treatments (T2, T5). The medium phosphorus and potassium status
was adequate for normal crop growth and is unlikely to have been a
limiting factor in the treatment comparisons.
Integrated weed management produced
taller plants and larger heads
Pooled over 3 years, the weed-management treatments lifted both
vegetative and reproductive growth (Table 2). The weed-free check
(T6) set the ceiling, with the tallest plants (162.7 cm) and the widest
heads (18.2 cm), a reminder of how sensitive sunflower is to early
competition. Among the field-practical options, pendimethalin fol-
lowed by quizalofop ethyl (T3) came closest, at 160.3 cm and 16.8 cm,
on par with the weed-free check and clearly ahead of the farmers’
practice (148.0 cm and 15.0 cm). Pendimethalin at 1.0 kg ha−1 applied
pre-emergence and followed by intercultivation has also performed
on par with the weed-free check in summer sunflower in Odisha
(Mahapatra et al., 2024). The weedy check fell to 131.8 cm, and head
TABLE 4 Seed yield of sunflower as influenced by integrated weed management under a fixed
75 × 25 cm wide-row layout.
Treatment Seed yield (kg ha⁻1)
2023 2024 2025 Pooled
T1:
Pendimethalin
PE + IC 35 DAS
1,512 1,547 1,478 1512.3
T2: IC 35 DAS 959 994 945 966.0
T3:
Pendimethalin
PE + quizalofop
ethyl PoE
1,642 1,677 1,620 1646.3
T4: Farmers’
practice
1,074 1,109 1,036 1073.0
T5: IC 20
DAS + HW 30–35
DAS
1,413 1,448 1,375 1412.0
T6: Weed free 1,734 1,769 1,689 1730.7
T7: Unweeded
control
943 978 911 944.0
S. Em± 40.28 38.65 68.18 49.04
CD (p = 0.05) 124.12 119.09 210.08 146.05
Values are means of three replications. Oil yield is presented in Table 3 and is not repeated
here. S. Em± = standard error of the mean; CD = critical difference at p = 0.05. Treatment
abbreviations as in Table 2.
Values in bold are the standard error of the mean (S. Em±) and the critical difference (CD) at
p = 0.05.
Somashekar et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 07 frontiersin.org
diameter collapsed to 9.4 cm - close to a 48% loss in head size where
weeds were left to compete for moisture, light and nutrients.
The taller, larger-headed plants under the better treatments are
consistent with reduced weed competition early in the season. The
critical period of weed control in sunflower falls at roughly 14–26 or
25–37 days after emergence (Knezevic et al., 2013, as cited by Ramesh
et al., 2022); a pre-emergence herbicide backed by intercultivation or
a directed post-emergence spray is timed to cover that window,
although weeds were not sampled during it in the present study. The
likely result is steadier biomass accumulation and a larger sink, both
of which feed into oilseed yield. Similar gains were reported by Bharati
et al. (2020), Singh et al. (2015), Sumathi et al. (2009) and Mahapatra
et al. (2024). A plausible explanation, consistent with earlier work,
involves light and nitrogen: weeds that establish with the crop inter-
cept part of the incident radiation and draw on the soil water and
nitrogen that sustain leaf area and photosynthesis (Zimdahl, 2004),
and a smaller supply of assimilate around flowering reduces the
number of seeds set per unit area (Cantagallo et al., 1997). The 48%
smaller heads of the weedy check are consistent with this pathway.
Effective weed management raised oil
content and oil yield
Oil content and oil yield both responded to weed management
(Table 3). The weed-free check recorded the highest oil content
(38.9%, mean of the three seasons) and oil yield (672.3 kg ha−1),
against 37.4% and 353.3 kg ha−1 in the weedy check. T3 again
proved the best practical option, with an oil yield of 636.7 kg ha−1,
statistically on par with the weed-free plots. The roughly 47% drop
in oil yield in the unweeded control traces mostly to poorer seed
filling and lower seed yield rather than to a large change in oil con -
centration itself. Treatment differences in oil content were not
TABLE 5 Weed dry weight at harvest and weed control efficiency of sunflower as influenced by integrated weed management.
Treatment Weed dry weight at harvest (g m⁻2) Weed control efficiency (%)
2023 2024 2025 Pooled 2023 2024 2025 Pooled
T1: Pendimethalin
PE + IC 35 DAS
58.85 61.79 62.38 61.01 89.11 89.12 89.52 89.26
T2: IC 35 DAS 103.95 109.15 110.19 107.76 80.77 80.77 81.49 81.02
T3: Pendimethalin
PE + quizalofop ethyl
PoE
39.82 41.81 42.21 41.28 92.63 92.63 92.91 92.73
T4: Farmers’ practice 61.82 64.91 65.53 64.09 88.57 88.57 88.99 88.71
T5: IC 20 DAS + HW
30–35 DAS
70.62 74.15 74.86 73.21 86.94 86.94 87.42 87.11
T6: Weed free 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.00 100 100 100 100
T7: Unweeded control 540.65 567.68 595.15 567.83 0 0 0 0
S. Em± 5.38 4.96 8.28 6.21 NA NA NA NA
CD (p = 0.05) 16.58 15.28 25.51 18.88 NA NA NA NA
Weed dry weight was recorded once, at harvest; it reflects season-end weed persistence rather than competition during the critical period for weed control (see Materials and Methods). NA:
weed control efficiency (WCE) is a derived percentage referenced against the unweeded control (which is fixed at 0% by definition); it therefore has no independent error term of its own, and
S. Em±/CD values are not applicable for this row. Pooled WCE is calculated from the pooled weed dry weights.
Values in bold are the standard error of the mean (S. Em±) and the critical difference (CD) at p = 0.05.
FIGURE 2
Weed-management indices (means of the 2023, 2024 and 2025 seasons). Bars are means of the three seasonal values; error bars are S. E. (n = 3
seasons); within each index, bars sharing a letter do not differ at p = 0.05 (CD: Weed index 0.90; HEI 0.47; WMI 0.02). Lower weed index and higher HEI
and WMI indicate superior weed management. HEI is not defined for the weed-free check, and neither HEI nor WMI is defined for the unweeded
control.
Somashekar et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 08 frontiersin.org
FIGURE 3
Economics of sunflower production. Bars show gross and net returns (left axis); the line shows the B:C ratio (right axis).
FIGURE 4
Pearson correlation matrix of independently measured agronomic and weed traits across the seven treatments (pooled, 2023–2025). *p < 0.05,
**p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001. Indicators calculated from seed yield (weed index, herbicide efficiency index, net returns and B:C ratio) and oil yield are
excluded because their correlations with seed yield are fixed by construction.
Somashekar et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 09 frontiersin.org
significant in 2023 and 2024 and were significant only in 2025
(Table 3); because the error variances for oil content differed mark -
edly between seasons, oil content was not pooled, and the effect of
weed management on oil yield arose mainly through seed yield.
Keeping the field clean, whether by a herbicide sequence or a her -
bicide-mechanical combination, lets the crop direct its resources
into seed development and oil. Tadavi et al. (2017) and Mahapatra
et al. (2024) reported the same advantage for the weed-free
treatment.
Pendimethalin followed by quizalofop ethyl
matched the weed-free check for seed yield
The pooled yield data echo the growth response ( Table 4). The
weed-free check gave the highest seed yield (1730.7 kg ha−1). T3
followed at 1646.3 kg ha −1, statistically on par with the weed-free
plots and well above the farmers’ practice (1073.0 kg ha−1). The
critical difference for pooled seed yield was 146.05 kg ha−1. The
weedy check produced only 944.0 kg ha−1, a loss of about 45%,
reflecting the heavy removal of nutrients and moisture by weeds
and a weakened source-sink relationship ( Watson et al., 1958 ;
Suresh and Venkat Reddy, 1994). Better weed control in the herbi -
cide and integrated treatments lowered weed biomass and improved
head size and seed yield, which is consistent with Sumathi et al.
(2009) and Tripathi and Vivek (2001) . The higher seed yield of T3
than of T1, which received the same pre-emergence herbicide, is
consistent with a contribution of the post-emergence graminicide
in removing the grasses that escape pendimethalin. Bharati et al.
(2020) likewise obtained the highest net returns in sunflower with
pendimethalin followed by a post-emergence graminicide, and
Tadavi et al. (2017) found pendimethalin followed by a post-emer -
gence graminicide to be the most effective herbicidal treatment after
the weed-free check.
The pre- plus post-emergence sequence
gave the lowest weed biomass and highest
control efficiency
Setting aside the absolute weed-free check, the lowest pooled weed
dry weight (41.28 g m −2) and the highest weed control efficiency
(92.73%) were recorded under T3, ahead of every other herbicidal and
cultural treatment, including the farmers’ practice (64.09 g m−2;
88.71%) (Table 5). Pendimethalin applied pre-emergence acts on ger-
minating weeds and does not control weeds that emerge after its
residual activity has declined, nor perennial grasses that regenerate
vegetatively (Senseman, 2007); the directed post-emergence gramini-
cide at 15–20 DAS was included in T3 to remove the grass weeds that
escaped or outlasted the pre-emergence barrier. The lower weed dry
weight under T3 than under T1 (61.01 g m−2), in which the same pre-
emergence application was followed by a single intercultivation at 35
DAS instead of the graminicide, is consistent with this rationale.
Mahapatra et al. (2025) likewise found pendimethalin followed by
post-emergence quizalofop-p-ethyl to be as effective as manual weed-
ing in sunflower grown at 75 × 25 cm. The unweeded control carried
the heaviest weed load (567.83 g m−2). Mechanical weeding alone with
a power weeder left far more weed biomass (107.76 g m−2) than the
chemical integration, since a single pass at 35 DAS lets a good deal of
early weed growth establish and leaves weeds within the crop rows
untouched. The findings agree with Selvakumar et al. (2018). Because
these values were recorded at harvest, they describe season-end weed
FIGURE 5
Relationship between head diameter and seed yield. Each point is a treatment mean (pooled, 2023–2025); shaded band is the 95% confidence interval
of the regression.
Somashekar et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 10 frontiersin.org
persistence rather than the intensity of competition during the critical
period, and the WCE values should be interpreted accordingly.
Rainfall variation and the performance of
pre-emergence pendimethalin
Annual rainfall differed widely between the 3 years: 829.2, 1436.0
and 1009.4 mm were recorded in 2023, 2024 and 2025, respectively
(Figure 1). Because these are annual totals, they describe the general
wetness of each year rather than the rainfall received within the crop
season itself; the variation is nevertheless relevant to the behaviour of
soil-applied pendimethalin. Pendimethalin has very low water solubil-
ity and is strongly adsorbed to soil organic matter and clay, so it nor-
mally remains in the surface few centimetres of soil and has a low
potential for leaching; its dissipation proceeds mainly through micro-
bial degradation, volatilisation and photodecomposition (Senseman,
2007). Adsorption is, however, weaker in coarse-textured soils that are
low in organic matter. The experimental Alfisol was a red sandy loam
with low organic carbon (0.48%) in the 0–15 cm layer (Table 1), a
combination that offers comparatively few sorption sites. Under the
high rainfall of 2024, some downward displacement of pendimethalin
below the zone from which most weed seeds germinate, together with
faster dissipation in persistently moist soil, is therefore plausible, and
either process would be expected to shorten the residual activity of the
pre-emergence barrier and allow later weed flushes to establish.
The weed data do not, however, show a rainfall-specific loss of
performance in the pendimethalin-based treatments. Weed control
efficiency under pendimethalin followed by intercultivation (T1) was
89.11, 89.12 and 89.52% in 2023, 2024 and 2025, and under pendi-
methalin followed by quizalofop ethyl (T3) 92.63, 92.63 and 92.91%
(Table 5). Weed dry weight at harvest was higher in 2024 than in 2023
by a similar proportion in every treatment, including the unweeded
control (540.65 vs. 567.68 g m−2), and the largest weedy-check bio-
mass was recorded in 2025 (595.15 g m−2), the year of intermediate
rainfall. The season-to-season change in weed biomass therefore fol-
lowed the general vigour of the weed community in each season rather
than a loss of pendimethalin activity in the wettest year. One possible
explanation is that, in every pendimethalin-based treatment, the pre-
emergence application was followed by a second control operation, a
directed quizalofop ethyl spray at 15–20 DAS in T3 or intercultivation
at 35 DAS in T1, which would remove weeds that escaped a weakened
pre-emergence barrier. Soil moisture, herbicide residues and the
timing of rainfall relative to herbicide application were not measured,
so the adsorption–desorption behaviour and any vertical movement
of pendimethalin in this soil could not be quantified, and residue
monitoring in the 0–15 cm layer is recommended for future studies.
Weed indices confirmed the superiority of
the herbicide sequence over cultural
practices
The indices reinforce the agronomic picture ( Figure 2 ). The
weed index, which scales yield loss to weed competition, was lowest
under T3 (4.86%), followed by the herbicide-mechanical integra -
tion of T1 (12.61%), both far below the farmers’ practice (38.01%).
The unweeded control reached the maximum weed index (45.46%),
marking the yield at stake when no control is applied. Among the
treatments for which it is defined, the herbicide efficiency index
was highest under T3 (10.25), and T3 also recorded the highest
weed management index among the practical treatments (0.80),
second only to the weed-free check (0.83). All three indices differed
significantly among treatments ( p < 0.001), and the differences
among the practical treatments exceeded the CD in every case
(Figure 2). Effective control reduced weed dry matter, which lifted
weed control efficiency. Comparable results were reported by
Tadavi et al. (2017) , Selvakumar et al. (2018) and Kumar et
al. (2019) .
Lower weeding cost made the herbicide
sequence the most cost-effective treatment
The weed-free check earned the highest gross returns
(₹72,655 ha−1), but the most cost-effective treatment was the pre- plus
post-emergence herbicide sequence, T3, whose net returns
(₹42,572 ha−1) were close to those of the weed-free check
(₹43,073 ha−1) at a lower cost of cultivation (Figure 3). By cutting the
labour bill for manual weeding, T3 held the cost of cultivation to
₹26,248 ha−1 and returned the best B:C ratio of 2.6. The unweeded
control had the lowest cost (₹23,500 ha−1) but its gross returns were
limited to ₹39,704 ha−1, giving the poorest B:C ratio of 1.7. A targeted
chemical approach therefore balanced yield value against input cost
better than either the farmers’ practice (1.8) or the labour-intensive
weed-free method (2.5). The B:C ratio under T3 was about 1.5 times
that of the unweeded control, driven by higher seed yield and net
returns, in line with Sumathi et al. (2009), Kumar et al. (2019) and
Bharati et al. (2020).
Head diameter and plant height were
associated with seed yield
Correlations were computed across the seven treatment means
for traits that were measured independently of one another
(Figure 4). Net returns and the B:C ratio are calculated from seed
yield multiplied by the produce price, and the weed index and the
herbicide efficiency index are calculated from seed yield relative to
the weed-free check and the unweeded control, respectively; their
near-perfect correlations with seed yield are therefore arithmetical
consequences of how these indicators are constructed. These indica-
tors, together with oil yield (the product of seed yield and oil con -
tent), were excluded from the matrix and are not interpreted as
findings. Among the independently measured traits, plant height
tracked seed yield ( r = +0.92, p < 0.01), head diameter and oil con -
tent moved together (r = +0.95, p < 0.001), and oil content declined
as weed dry weight increased (r = −0.86, p = 0.012), whereas the cor-
relation between seed yield and weed dry weight at harvest was
weaker and not significant (r = −0.63, p = 0.13), as would be expected
if harvest-time weed biomass reflects season-end persistence more
than the competition experienced by the crop during the critical
period. One plausible explanation, consistent with these associations,
is that effective early-season weed control allows the plant to build a
larger frame and a bigger head, with that capacity later carrying seed
and oil; as weeds were not sampled during the critical period and
these correlations are based on only seven treatment means, they
should be read as descriptive associations rather than confirmed
causal pathways.
The clearest relationship between independently measured
traits is shown in Figure 5 . Across the seven treatment means,
seed yield increased linearly with head diameter
Somashekar et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 11 frontiersin.org
(y = 82.01x + 153.1; R2 = 0.62, p = 0.037; r = +0.78), so each addi -
tional centimetre of head diameter was associated with roughly
82 kg ha −1 of seed across the treatment range. Unlike the eco -
nomic indicators, head diameter and seed yield are measured
independently, so this association is not a product of calculation.
The weed-free check (T6) and the pendimethalin-plus-quizalofop
sequence (T3) sit at the top of the line, while the weedy check
(T7), with the smallest head, anchors the bottom. The scatter
around the line is appreciable: T5 yielded more, and T4 less, than
their head diameters alone would predict, indicating that seed
number per head and seed filling also contributed to the treat -
ment differences. Head diameter nonetheless accounted for about
three-fifths of the variation in seed yield among treatment means,
which fits the idea that head size sets a ceiling on the reproductive
sink that the crop can fill; with n = 7, this remains a descriptive
association.
Net returns and the B:C ratio are calculated from seed yield, the
price of the produce and the cost of cultivation, so a regression of
either indicator on seed yield would be determined largely by the way
these indicators are constructed and would add no independent infor-
mation. The economic comparison of treatments is therefore pre -
sented directly in Figure 3 and is not analysed further as a yield
relationship.
Correlation here is computed across seven treatment means
(pooled over 2023–2025), so it summarizes treatment-level relation-
ships rather than plant-to-plant variation. Of the relationships exam-
ined, only those between independently measured traits, such as head
diameter and seed yield, carry interpretive weight.
Conclusion
The three-year investigation showed that integrated weed
management was associated with markedly higher productivity
and profitability of sunflower grown under a fixed wide-row
(75 × 25 cm) layout. As all treatments were imposed at this single
spacing, the study demonstrates the relative performance of weed-
management practices within a wide-row layout and not an effect
of row spacing itself. Among the treatments evaluated, the pre-
emergence application of pendimethalin at 1.0 kg a.i. ha −1 fol -
lowed by a directed post-emergence spray of quizalofop ethyl 5%
EC at 62 g a.i. ha −1 at 15–20 DAS (T3) proved the most effective
practical option. This sequence, in which the pre-emergence her -
bicide targets the early weed flush and the post-emergence gra -
minicide targets later-emerging grasses, recorded the lowest weed
dry weight at harvest, the highest weed control efficiency and the
lowest weed index among the practical treatments. As a result, it
produced growth, yield attributes and seed yield statistically on
par with the labour-intensive weed-free check, while substantially
lowering the cost of weeding. The treatment consequently
returned the highest benefit–cost ratio (2.6), making it both agro -
nomically sound and economically attractive for resource-limited
growers. Regression analysis across treatment means further
showed that seed yield was positively associated with head diam -
eter, consistent with effective early-season weed control support -
ing a larger reproductive sink; because this relationship was
estimated across only seven treatment means, it should be read as
a descriptive association rather than as an independently
confirmed causal mechanism. The pre- plus post-emergence her -
bicide sequence is therefore recommended as a promising, labour-
saving weed-management option for sunflower grown at wider
row spacing, and merits validation across diverse agro-climatic
zones, and against a conventionally spaced comparison, before
large-scale adoption. Future work should also test additional her -
bicide combinations and sequences, evaluate the longer-term
effects of repeated herbicide use on the weed seedbank, assess the
environmental and non-target impacts of the herbicides used, and
integrate this chemical–mechanical sequence with other IWM
components such as crop rotation and cover cropping.
Limitations of the study
All seven treatments were imposed at a single 75 × 25 cm row
geometry and no conventional-spacing (60 × 30 cm) control was
included. Row spacing was therefore not an experimental factor: no
effect on weeds, crop growth, yield or economics can be attributed to
the wider row spacing itself, and no spacing × weed-management
interaction can be inferred. The results apply to weed management
within a wide-row layout.
Data availability statement
The original contributions presented in the study are included in
the article, further inquiries can be directed to the correspond -
ing author.
Author contributions
SK: Conceptualization, Methodology, Project administration,
Supervision, Investigation, Writing – original draft, Writing – review
& editing. KR: Methodology, Writing – review & editing. TN:
Conceptualization, Resources, Visualization, Writing – review & edit-
ing. AR: Formal analysis, Writing – review & editing. MM:
Investigation, Writing – review & editing. RB: Writing – review &
editing. CC: Writing – review & editing.
Funding
The author(s) declared that financial support was received for this
work and/or its publication. The research was funded by All India
Co-ordinated Research Project on Sunflower.
Acknowledgments
The authors thank the technical staff of the AICRP on
Sunflower, ZARS, GKVK, UAS Bengaluru for field and laboratory
assistance, and the Analytical Laboratory, Department of Soil
Somashekar et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1930960
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 12 frontiersin.org
Science and Agricultural Chemistry, UAS Bengaluru for plant
tissue analysis.
Conflict of interest
The author(s) declared that this work was conducted in the
absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be
construed as a potential conflict of interest.
The author KR declared that they were an editorial board member
of Frontiers, at the time of submission. This had no impact on the peer
review process and the final decision.
Generative AI statement
The author(s) declared that Generative AI was used in the creation
of this manuscript. ChatGPT (OpenAI) was used to improve the
readability of the text, and all content was reviewed and verified by the
authors.
Any alternative text (alt text) provided alongside figures in this
article has been generated by Frontiers with the support of artificial
intelligence and reasonable efforts have been made to ensure accuracy,
including review by the authors wherever possible. If you identify any
issues, please contact us.
Publisher’s note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the
authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated
organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the
reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or
claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or
endorsed by the publisher.
References
Bardsley, C. E., and Lancaster, J. D. (1965). “Sulfur, ” in Methods of Soil Analysis, Part 2, ed.
C. A. Black (Madison, WI: American Society of Agronomy), 1102–1116.
Baskaran, R., and Kavimani, R. (2014). Productivity of sunflower as influenced by tillage
and weed management. Indian J. Weed Sci. 46, 138–141.
Bharati, V ., Kumar, K., Prasad, S. S., Singh, U. K., Hans, H., and Dwivedi, D. K. (2020).
Effect of integrated weed management in sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) in Bihar. J.
Pharmacogn. Phytochem. 9, 356–359.
Cantagallo, J. E., Chimenti, C. A., and Hall, A. J. (1997). Number of seeds per unit area in
sunflower correlates well with a photosynthesis based index. Crop Sci. 37, 1780–1786.
Gill, G. S., and Kumar, V . (1969). “Weed index” – a new method for reporting weed-
control trials. Indian J. Agron. 14, 96–98.
Gomez, K. A., and Gomez, A. A. (1984). Statistical Procedures for Agricultural Research.
2nd Edn New Y ork: John Wiley and Sons.
Indiastatagri. (2025). Indiastat Agriculture Database: area, Production and Productivity of
Sunflower. Available online at: https://www.indiastatagri.com.
Jackson, M. L. (1973). Soil Chemical Analysis. New Delhi: Prentice Hall.
Knezevic, S. Z., Elezovic, I., Datta, A., Vrbnicanin, S., Glamoclija, D., Simic, M., et al.
(2013). Delay in the critical time for weed removal in imidazolinone-resistant sunflower
(Helianthus annuus) caused by application of a pre-emergence herbicide. Int. J. Pest
Manag. 59, 229–235. doi: 10.1080/09670874.2013.830797
Knezevic, S. Z., Evans, S. P ., Blankenship, E. E., Van Acker, R. C., and Lindquist, J. L.
(2002). Critical period for weed control: the concept and data analysis. Weed Sci. 50,
773–786. doi: 10.1614/0043-1745(2002)050[0773:CPFWCT]2.0.CO;2
Krishnamurthy, K., Raju, B. G., Raghunath, G., Jagannath, M. K., and Prasad, T. V . R.
(1975). Herbicide efficiency index in sorghum. Indian J. Weed Sci. 7, 75–79.
Kumar, A., Dhaka, A. K., Kumar, S., Singh, S., and Punia, S. S. (2019). Weed management
indices as affected by different weed control treatments in pigeon pea [Cajanus cajan (L.)
Millsp.]. J. Pharmacogn. Phytochem. 8, 3490–3494.
Lindsay, W . L., and Norvell, W . A. (1978). Development of a DTPA soil test for zinc, iron,
manganese, and copper. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 42, 421–428. doi: 10.2136/sssaj197
8.03615995004200030009x
Mahapatra, A., Bisoyi, B. B., and Ramesh, K. (2025). Integrated weed management in
sunflower under modified spacing. J. Oilseeds Res. 42, 176–180. doi: 10.56739/1dwfqf94
Mahapatra, A., Mohanty, L., Ramesh, K., and Bhol, R. (2023). Response of sunflower-
weed ecosystem to herbicide oxadiargyl and integrated weed management options. J.
Oilseeds Res. 40, 203–206. doi: 10.56739/3mwnth72
Mahapatra, A., Nikhitha, D., Mohanty, S., and Khatua, R. (2024). Integrated weed man-
agement in sunflower. Int. J. Res. Agron. 7, 574–577. doi: 10.33545/2618060X.2024.
v7.i11Sh.2076
Mani, V . S., Malla, M. L., Gautam, K. C., and Bhagwandas, B. (1973). Weed-killing chemi-
cals in potato cultivation. Indian Farming 23, 17–18.
Mishra, M., and Misra, A. (1997). Estimation of integrated pest management index in
jute – a new approach. Indian J. Weed Sci. 29, 39–42.
Mohapatra, S., Tripathy, S. K., and Mohanty, A. K. (2020). Weed management in sun-
flower through sequential application of herbicides in Western Odisha. Indian J. Weed
Sci. 52, 197–199. doi: 10.5958/0974-8164.2020.00037.4
Monteith, J. L. (1977). Climate and the efficiency of crop production in Britain. Philos.
Trans. R. Soc. London B Biol. Sci. 281, 277–294. doi: 10.1098/rstb.1977.0140
Oerke, E.-C. (2006). Crop losses to pests. J. Agric. Sci. 144, 31–43. doi: 10.1017/
S0021859605005708
Paroda, R. S. (2013). The Indian oilseeds scenario: challenges and opportunities. J.
Oilseeds Res. 30, 111–126. doi: 10.56739/jor.v30i2.143296
Piper, C. S. (1966). Soil and Plant Analysis. Bombay: Hans Publishers.
Prabhakar, K., Venkataramanamma, K., Reddy, B. V . R., Kumar, Y . S. S., Ramesh, K.,
Narasimhulu, R., et al. (2023). The effect of site-specific nutrient management (SSNM)
on sunflower production. Int. J. Plant Soil Sci. 35, 753–762. doi: 10.9734/ijpss/2023/
v35i203862
Ramesh, K., Vijaya Kumar, S., Upadhyay, P . K., and Chauhan, B. S. (2022). Revisiting the
concept of the critical period of weed control. J. Agric. Sci. 159, 636–642. doi: 10.1017/
S0021859621000939
Sankar, K. S., and Subramanyam, D. (2011). Weed flora and yield of sunflower (Helianthus
annuus L.) as influenced by pre- and post-emergence application of herbicides. Indian J.
Weed Sci. 43, 105–109.
Selvakumar, T., Srinivasan, K., and Rajendran, L. (2018). Performance of chemical weed
management in irrigated sunflower. Int. J. Agric. Sci. 10, 7395–7397.
Senseman S. A. (ed.) (2007). Herbicide Handbook. 9th Edn Lawrence, KS: Weed Science
Society of America.
Singh, G., Kaur, H., Aggarwal, N., and Sharma, P . (2015). Effect of herbicides on weed
growth and yield of green gram. Indian J. Weed Sci. 47, 38–42.
Subbiah, B. V ., and Asija, G. L. (1956). A rapid procedure for the estimation of available
nitrogen in soils. Curr. Sci. 25, 259–260.
Sumathi, V ., Koteswara Rao, D. S., Subramanyam, D., and Reddy, D. S. (2009). Effect of
planting pattern and weed management on nutrient uptake and economics of Rabi sun-
flower and its associated weeds. Indian J. Weed Sci. 41, 65–70.
Suresh, G., and Venkat Reddy, N. (1994). Weed-management studies in kharif sunflower.
J. Oilseeds Res. 11, 297–299.
Swanton, C. J., Mahoney, K. J., Chandler, K., and Gulden, R. H. (2008). Integrated
weed management: knowledge-based weed-management systems. Weed Sci. 56,
168–172. doi: 10.1614/WS-07-126.1
Tadavi, A. G., Chorey, A. B., Gaikwad, G. S., and Sawadhkar, S. M. (2017). Integrated
weed management in sunflower. Int. J. Curr. Microbiol. Appl. Sci. 6, 1080–1088. doi:
10.20546/ijcmas.2017.609.129
Tripathi, S. S., and Vivek, V . (2001). Critical period of weed competition in spring
sunflower ( Helianthus annuus L.). Indian J. Weed Sci. 33, 212–214.
Walkley, A., and Black, I. A. (1934). An examination of the Degtjareff method for
determining soil organic matter, and a proposed modification of the chromic acid
titration method. Soil Sci. 37, 29–38. doi: 10.1097/00010694-193401000-00003
Watson, D. J., Thorne, G. N., and French, S. A. W . (1958). Physiological causes of
differences in grain yield between varieties of barley. Ann. Bot. 22, 321–352. doi:
10.1093/oxfordjournals.aob.a083616
Zimdahl, R. L. (2004). Weed-Crop Competition: A Review . 2nd Edn Ames, IA:
Blackwell Publishing.
论文原文与出版信息
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems