论文信息
论文解读
AI 辅助整理- 方法
- 按PRISMA流程检索Scopus与Web of Science文献,做文献计量
- 发现
- 全球文献超千篇,北非仅14-15篇,区域研究缺口显著,需加强合作与能力建设。
- 机会点
- 可聚焦北非等欠发达地区消费者对有机与生态农产品的采纳行为,开展跨区域比较与政策干预研究。
论文摘要
本文献计量分析对北非地区及全球范围内消费者针对可持续食品(包括有机、生物和农业生态产品)行为的变化态势进行了全面考察。研究方法遵循PRISMA指南,在Scopus和Web of Science数据库中检索并筛选涉及消费者行为和/或可持续食品的相关文献。通过对历史脉络、发表趋势、可持续发展目标、研究领域、作者贡献及文献计量分析的细致梳理,本综述旨在界定当前研究现状并突出需要进一步探索的领域。初步观察显示,以选定关键词检索到的可持续食品消费文献在Web of Science数据库中共有1,120篇(全球范围,其中北非地区14篇),在Scopus数据库中共有1,043篇(全球范围,其中北非地区15篇)。北非地区科学出版物数量相对较少,凸显了加强研究计划和合作项目以强化区域可持续食品系统实践的必要性。本综述强调了可持续食品研究的跨学科性质,并指出在区域和全球层面培育可持续实践的合作努力的紧迫性。全球与区域尺度之间研究产出的差距为能力建设和知识交流提供了机遇,亟需战略性干预措施以弥合差距并推动可持续食品议程。此外,本综述整合了研究发现,识别了尚未探索的领域,并勾勒了消费者研究中未来的研究路径,重点关注可持续食品的采纳与消费。最终,本文倡导一项前瞻性研究议程,旨在推进理论基础、实践应用和政策框架,以全面理解和引导消费者对有机产品的行为,尤其是在北非这一独特背景下。
全文
Frontiers in Sustainable Food SystemsFrontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 01 frontiersin.org
TYPE Systematic Review
PUBLISHED 20 November 2026
DOI 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
OPEN ACCESS
EDITED BY
Olutosin Ademola Otekunrin,
Federal University of Agriculture and
Development Studies, Iragbiji (FUADSI),
Nigeria
REVIEWED BY
Selorm Dorvlo,
University of Ghana, Ghana
Abiola Adebunmi Olarinre,
University of Ilesa, Nigeria
CORRESPONDENCE
Abdellatif Boutagayout
a.boutagayout@edu.umi.ac.ma;
boutagayout.abdellatif@inra.ma
RECEIVED 30 July 2026
REVISED 02 November 2026
ACCEPTED 06 November 2026
PUBLISHED 20 November 2026
CITATION
Boutagayout A, Hamdani A, Adiba A,
Belghiti ML, El Hilali Alaoui Y and
Elfazazi K (2026) Exploring global and
regional research trends in sustainable
food consumption with a focus on
North Africa: a bibliometric analysis.
Front. Sustain. Food Syst. 10:1953564.
doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
COPYRIGHT
© 2026 Boutagayout, Hamdani, Adiba,
Belghiti, El Hilali Alaoui and Elfazazi. This
is an open-access article distributed
under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution License (CC BY).
The use, distribution or reproduction in
other forums is permitted, provided the
original author(s) and the copyright
owner(s) are credited and that the
original publication in this journal is
cited, in accordance with accepted
academic practice. No use, distribution
or reproduction is permitted which does
not comply with these terms.
Exploring global and regional
research trends in sustainable
food consumption with a focus
on North Africa: a bibliometric
analysis
Abdellatif Boutagayout 1, Anas Hamdani 2, Atman Adiba 3,
Moulay Lafdil Belghiti 4, Youssef El Hilali Alaoui 5 and
Kaoutar Elfazazi 6
1Research Unit on Environment and Conservation of Natural Resources, Regional Center of
Agricultural Research of Rabat, National Institute of Agricultural Research, Rabat, Morocco, 2Research
Unit on Environment and Sustainable Management of Natural Resources, Regional Center of
Agricultural Research of Settat, National Institute of Agricultural Research, Rabat, Morocco, 3Regional
Center of Agricultural Research of Tadla, National Institute of Agricultural Research (INRA), Rabat,
Morocco, 4Natural Resources Management and Development Team, Environment and Health
Laboratory, Department of Biology, Faculty of Sciences, Moulay Ismaıl University, Meknes, Morocco,
5Regional Center of Agricultural Research of Errachidia, National Institute of Agricultural Research,
Rabat, Morocco, 6Agro-Food Technology and Quality Laboratory, Regional Center of Agricultural
Research of Tadla, National Institute of Agricultural Research, Rabat, Morocco
This bibliometric analysis presents a comprehensive examination of the evolving
landscape of consumer behavior toward sustainable food products, encompass-
ing organic, biological, and agroecological items, both within North Africa and
on a global scale. The methodology followed PRISMA guidelines to examine
and select relevant publications addressing consumer behavior and/or sustain -
able food products within the Scopus and Web of Science databases. Through
meticulous scrutiny of historical emergence, publication trends, Sustainable
Development Goals, research areas, author contributions, and bibliometric analy-
ses, this review aims to define the present status and highlight areas that require
further exploration. Initial observations highlight the existing literature on sus -
tainable food consumption—identified using selected keywords-within the Web
of Science (1,120 documents globally, including 14 for North Africa) and Scopus
(1,043 documents globally, including 15 for North Africa) databases. This relatively
low frequency of scientific publications in North Africa underscores the need to
step up research initiatives and collaborative projects to strengthen regional prac-
tices regarding sustainable food systems. Highlighting the interdisciplinary nature
of sustainable food studies, this review underscores the urgency of collaborative
efforts to nurture sustainable practices, both regionally and globally. Disparities
in research outputs between global and regional scales offer opportunities for
capacity building and knowledge exchange, urging strategic interventions to
bridge gaps and propel sustainable food agendas. Additionally, the review con -
solidates the research findings, identifies unexplored areas, and delineates future
research pathways within consumer studies, concentrating on the adoption and
consumption of sustainable food products. Ultimately, this article advocates for
a forward-looking research agenda aimed at advancing theoretical foundations,
practical applications, and policy frameworks to comprehensively understand
and influence consumer behavior toward organic products, especially within the
unique context of North Africa.
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 02 frontiersin.org
KEYWORDS
agroecological products, consumer behavior, North Africa, organic products,
sustainable food
1 Introduction
In the contemporary food landscape, the cultivation of sustainable
foods, often referred to as organic or agroecological products, priori-
tizes ecological balance within natural systems (Araújo and Marjotta-
Maistro, 2022 ; Persiani et al., 2023 ). Although these terms are
sometimes used interchangeably, they have notable differences.
Biological products, often referred to as ‘organic’ in English-language
publications, are certified to rigorous standards that prohibit synthetic
pesticides, chemical fertilizers, GMOs, and artificial additives. In con-
trast, agroecological products are based on a global approach that
integrates environmentally friendly and socially responsible practices
without necessarily meeting specific certification criteria. These prod-
ucts avoid the use of chemical fertilizers, pesticides, growth hormones,
antibiotics, bioengineering, and genetically modified organisms
(Olson, 2017). Beyond these distinctions, sustainable food products
encompass these categories by integrating environmental, social, and
economic criteria throughout their life cycles. Sustainable food prod-
ucts are those that have been sourced from farming techniques that
maintain biodiversity, reduce the carbon footprint, and ensure that
farmers have good working conditions. Therefore, considering sus-
tainable food products that respect these fundamental principles,
organic, agroecological, and fair-trade products can be included
(Bertrand et al., 2018). These practices are grounded in the principles
of sustainable plant agriculture, aiming to ensure a healthy livelihood,
ecological balance, and solving issues related to pest and soil fertility
(Araújo and Marjotta-Maistro, 2022). Organic food typically has no
detectable chemical residues, whereas residues are frequently detect-
able in conventionally grown food (Bertrand et al., 2018).
There has been a growing interest in sustainable foods over the last
few years, with rising awareness of consumers regarding the health,
environmental, and food safety effects of traditional agricultural prac-
tices (Lazaroiu et al., 2019; Garcia et al., 2020). Consumers are becom-
ing more conscious of their food origins, making conscious choices to
use alternative food sources whose values they support. In this regard,
consumer demand for sustainable products has significantly increased
in world and North African countries (Hughner et al., 2007; Popa et
al., 2019).
There has been a tremendous increase in the demand for organic
and agroecological products over the past few decades (Thakur et al.,
2022; Chopin et al., 2023). Various factors could be responsible for this
demand for sustainable food, including increased awareness of con-
sumers about health issues and increased environmental campaigns
by concerned non-governmental organizations (NGOs), which also
have an important role in certification and the development of direct
marketing strategies for producers ( Araújo and Marjotta-Maistro,
2022; Aoudi, 2023). Moreover, the role of religious groups promoting
spiritual harmony by eating food in balance with nature and tradi-
tional farmers who question the way of large corporations also provide
alternative models (Araújo and Marjotta-Maistro, 2022). Although the
main influencers are difficult to identify, the effect of all these factors
is sufficient to lead to a significant rise in the demand for organic and
agroecological products.
The sales channels through which these products are sold are
diverse, such as supermarkets, home delivery services, hotels, restau-
rants, independent distributors, farmers’ markets, specialized retail
outlets, institutional markets, and online retail outlets (Kamenidou et
al., 2020; Baker et al., 2020; Carmona et al., 2021).
The countries of North Africa—Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya,
and Egypt (Figure 1)–present a particular context for the study of
consumer attitudes towards biological and agroecological products
(Ben Khadda et al., 2022; Serra-Majem et al., 2020). These countries
reflect a wide range of agricultural systems, cultures, and economic
statuses, which have a significant impact on consumer preferences
and behaviors towards sustainable food ( Clark et al., 2020 ). For
example, agricultural systems range from intensive commercial farm-
ing to traditional agriculture; crops vary due to distinct culinary tra-
ditions and differing levels of urbanization; and economic conditions
diverge, reflecting unequal purchasing power across the countries of
North Africa. Nevertheless, although these products are becoming
increasingly popular, understanding consumer behavior in this con-
text is lacking. Exploring consumer behavior towards biological and
agroecological products in North Africa from various angles is of
deep significance. First, knowing consumers’ preferences can reveal
the gaps in the market and the possible scope of these products in
North African countries and inform marketing actions and product
development in accordance with consumers’ preferences, thus
increasing the market for organic foods (Boz et al., 2020). Second,
increased consumer demand may encourage the region to adopt sus-
tainable farming systems, providing an opportunity for policymakers
and farmers to promote sustainable practices and reduce chemical
use (Miller and Lu, 2019; Boutagayout et al., 2023). Third, by explor-
ing consumer behavior, the potential health benefits of organic food
consumption could be identified, leading to the inclusion of this
information in public health messages aimed at promoting organic
food choices that could help improve the health status of North
African consumers. Lastly, knowledge of consumer behavior is essen-
tial for influencing policies and regulations for the development of
the organic and agroecological products sector in North Africa, with
respect to growth, food safety, and consumer rights protection (Place
et al., 2022).
Moreover, studies on consumer behavior, especially in developing
countries such as those in North Africa, remain limited. It is therefore
essential to conduct in-depth research tailored to the North African
context to better understand consumption dynamics and integrate
certified organic products into targeted experiments. This will help
bridge the significant gap between research in North Africa and the
standards observed in other parts of the world. This bibliometric
analysis aims to fill this research gap by providing a deep exploration
of consumer behavior towards biological and agroecological products
on the North African scale, compared to the global scale. Our objec-
tives are to summarize the results, detail the factors affecting con -
sumer behavior, pinpoint sustainable food consumption, and identify
emerging trends and gaps in research from the Scopus and Web of
Science databases. The findings from this analysis are expected to pro-
vide valuable insights for researchers, policymakers, and industry
players, contributing to a better understanding of consumer
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 03 frontiersin.org
preferences, improving marketing tactics, and promoting sustainable
food consumption in North African countries.
Specifically, this study focuses on the following research questions:
RQ1: What is the evolution of the number of scientific publica-
tions on sustainable food products both globally and regionally
(North Africa)?
RQ2: What are the differences and similarities in consumer
behavior towards sustainable food products between North
African countries and the rest of the world?
RQ3: What are the contributions of each North African country
to sustainable food research?
RQ4: What links exist between sustainable food publications and
the Sustainable Development Goals?
RQ5: What are the main research areas explored in the field of
sustainable food products?
RQ6: Who are the 25 most prolific authors in the field of sustain-
able food production?
RQ7: How have publications on sustainable food products
evolved?
RQ8: What are the most common types of publications on sus-
tainable food products?
RQ9: Which of the 25 journals publish the most articles on sus-
tainable food products?
RQ10: What are the main international collaborations in sus -
tainable food research?
RQ11: What are the most frequently used keywords for sustain-
able food research?
RQ12: What are the main studies on consumer behavior towards
sustainable food in North Africa?
2 Methodology
2.1 Literature compilation and screening
We found literature that covered the identified areas by carefully
searching relevant databases, journals, and literature in two presti-
gious scientific databases (Scopus and Web of Science) (Otekunrin,
2023; Zhu and Liu, 2020). The thematic search keywords used to iden-
tify pertinent publications for our study were (“Consumer behavior”
OR “Consumer attitudes” OR “Consumer Satisfaction” OR “Customer
Perception” OR “Consumer Motivation” OR “Food Consumption”)
AND (“Organic Food” OR “Organic products” OR “Biological prod-
ucts” OR “ Agroecological products” OR “Sustainable food”). The
inclusion criteria for this bibliometric analysis were as follows: only
studies published in peer-reviewed journals indexed in the Scopus
FIGURE 1
Study area on consumer behavior towards sustainable food products (North African countries).
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 04 frontiersin.org
and/or Web of Science databases were included. Publications had to
deal with consumer behavior towards sustainable food products,
including agroecological and organic products, and were published
until 2025. The year 2025 was selected as the latest complete publica-
tion year at the time of the updated search, whereas publications from
2026 were not considered because the year was still ongoing.
Publications published in English, French, or Arabic were eligible for
inclusion to ensure comprehensive coverage of the international litera-
ture and, particularly, the scientific literature relevant to the North
African context. No publications in Arabic were identified in the
retrieved datasets. Publications classified as Articles, Reviews,
Conference Papers, Book Chapters, Book Reviews, and Books were
eligible for inclusion in the bibliometric analysis. The following docu-
ment types were excluded: Notes, Errata, Editorials, Retracted
Publications, Short Surveys, Letters, Data Papers, Early Access publi-
cations, Meeting Abstracts, Reprints, and News Items. Publications
had to be available (at least the title and/or abstract) and include pri-
mary or secondary data concerning consumer behavior and sustain-
able food products or related studies. In addition, the exclusion
criteria included studies not published in academic journals or pre-
senting non-scientific data, such as non-peer-validated company
reports not indexed in Scopus and/or Web of Science. Publications not
dealing directly with consumer behavior or sustainable food products,
those published after 2025, or dealing solely with non-sustainable food
products, and those unrelated to sustainable agriculture (e.g., indus-
trial and cosmetic products) were excluded. Redundant or irrelevant
publications were excluded. The manual selection consisted of espe-
cially examining titles and abstracts focusing on consumer behavior
regarding sustainable food products to obtain an overview of included
studies. This was followed by a meticulous evaluation of the full texts
of the selected studies, focusing on consumer behavior regarding sus-
tainable food products. After obtaining results of worldwide publica-
tions, additional filter based on affiliation (AFFILCOUNTRY) was
applied to identify publications associated with Algeria, Egypt, Libya,
Morocco, and Tunisia for the analysis focusing on North Africa. This
process followed systematic methodologies based on the Preferred
Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses
(PRISMA) guidelines, a set of international recommendations
designed to ensure transparency and rigor in systematic reviews (Page
et al., 2021) (Figure 2). These guidelines ensure that the steps in the
study selection process, as well as the inclusion and exclusion criteria,
are clearly reported, enabling accurate replication of the analysis
(Figure 3) (Moher et al., 2010; Zhang et al., 2024). This provided an
overview of all articles published using the selected keywords in
Scopus (15 and 1,043 documents for North Africa and the whole
world, respectively) and Web of Science (14 and 1,120 documents for
North Africa and the world, respectively).
2.2 Data extraction and bibliometric analysis
This study undertook a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of
sustainable food publications following the five steps recommended
FIGURE 2
PRISMA flow diagram illustrating the search and selection process of studies on consumer behavior towards sustainable food products in Web of
Sciences and Scopus databases.
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 05 frontiersin.org
by Lei et al. (2022) and Li et al. (2023), as cited by Zhang et al. (2024).
A systematic data extraction framework was applied to gather relevant
information from the selected studies, involving comparative analyses
of global and regional data. Ruggeri et al. (2019) used both qualitative
and quantitative methods to uncover common themes and patterns of
consumer behavior on biological and agroecological products in
North Africa. These data were used to determine the distribution by
number and frequency of countries, alignment with Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs), alignment with research areas, authors,
types of publications, and top journals.
Furthermore, a detailed bibliometric study used data from Scopus
and the Web of Science to create a network of manuscripts related to
consumer behavior towards sustainable food products in North Africa
and globally. Analysis of data extracted in CSV and tab-delimited
format provides insights into the research landscape and its trajectory.
The results of the bibliometric analysis are displayed in VOSviewer
and include all the different indices related to the identification of the
most prominent keywords, analysis of keyword co-occurrence, and
country distribution of co-authors. These elements have enabled them
to visualize the relations between authors, institutions, and research
fields and to identify trends in sustainable food research. This method
provides a detailed profile of research dynamics, which can help
understand trends and developments in the field (Lee and Thierfelder,
2017; Boutagayout et al., 2023).
2.3 Developing research perspectives
Based on the identified research gaps, future research perspectives
are proposed to highlight potential directions, methods, and theoreti-
cal developments that could fill gaps or extend the body of knowledge.
This project aims to foster research on sustainable food systems in
the area.
3 Results
3.1 Evolution of published documents on
sustainable food products
The publication of documents on sustainable food products has
changed over time. The research years of the Scopus and Web of
Science research keywords that analyze food products, organic and
biological products, sustainability, and agroecological products reveal
the historical origin of scholarly research in each of these areas. The
largest number of document results was for “Food products, ” which
began with research in 1,878–1,900 and yielded 101,489–45,780 arti-
cles in Scopus-Web of Science, respectively. This is a huge field with a
rich academic history and a diversity of academic products. Similarly,
the research history of “Organic products, ” which began, respectively,
in 1,890–1,949, yielded 5,534–3,622 document results and had a more
focused but comparatively smaller research body within this area. The
results show scholarly interest in “biological products” and “organic
food, ” which began in 1,911–1,935 and 1,922–1,911, respectively, with
56,717–2,857 and 6,072–4,763 documents in Scopus-Web of Science,
respectively. In contrast to the other categories, “Sustainable food”
began scholarly research in 1,985–1,981 and collected 13,702–10,663
document results, which is a significant but relatively low number of
document results for an interdisciplinary field. On the other hand,
“ Agroecological products” began being studied in 2003 and showed
FIGURE 3
Five main steps in the conducted bibliometric analysis process.
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 06 frontiersin.org
very few document results (34–24 articles, respectively), indicating the
beginnings of an area of scholarly research. The differences in docu-
ment results for different keywords show a different level of scholarly
focus and depth of research in each group, providing a good sense of
the range and development of scholarly interrogation of food prod-
ucts, sustainability, and agroecological practices. The trends reflect
changing interests in research and academic focus, noting times when
there was a surge of interest and/or considerable production of
research results, such as for food products and those items that were
consistently targets of significant research attention, including those
in the organic, biological, and agroecological categories (Figure 4).
3.2 Global and regional publications on
consumer behavior in sustainable food
3.2.1 Documents number per country
Figure 5 provides insights into the distribution of countries in
studies dealing with consumer behavior and food-related products in
the Web of Science and Scopus databases, making it possible to have
a global view of the participation in these research areas.
Italy is the leading country in the Web of Science database, with
109 papers (9.73%), followed by China (101 papers, 9.02%) and India
(98 papers, 8.75%). North African countries (Egypt, Tunisia, Morocco,
and Algeria) show lower frequencies, suggesting a relatively small
number of studies or fewer on these keywords in this database.
The trend was similar in the Scopus database. The United States
and Italy were the next largest areas in the world, with 109 documents
(10.45%) and 107 documents (10. 62%), respectively, followed by
India with 90 documents (8.63%). This is consistent with the results
obtained in the Web of Science, as the document frequencies in the
Scopus database were found to be lower in the countries of North
Africa [Egypt, Tunisia, Morocco and Algeria (no documents were
located for Libya)] which indicates a comparatively low representation
in scholarly publications in these areas.
With an in-depth analysis of the countries of North Africa as the
focus, Egypt ranks 57th in the Web of Science and 72nd in Scopus.
Morocco ranks 58th in the Web of Science and 47th in Scopus, and
Tunisia ranks 62nd in the Web of Science and 66th in Scopus. Lastly,
Algeria is at the 70st position in the Web of Science and 59th in
Scopus. The rankings indicate that, in general, countries in North
Africa are not as well represented or as many have been studied with
FIGURE 4
Number of published documents in each year in the Scopus and Web of Science databases using keywords of “Food Products,” “Organic Products,”
“Biological Products,” “Organic Food,” “Sustainable Food,” and “Agroecological Products”.
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 07 frontiersin.org
regard to consumer behavior, digitalization, and food-related products
as other countries in the world (as shown in both databases).
The comparison of the two databases highlights the reliability of
the trends in some countries with regard to their active involvement
in research on organic foods related to consumer behavior. It also
highlights the rather moderate share of North African nations (Egypt,
Tunisia, Morocco, and Algeria) in these particular fields in the two
databases, Web of Science and Scopus.
3.2.2 Sustainable Development Goals
The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) are analyzed in
greater depth in Figure 6, based on the studies that were found in the
Web of Science database, which specifically provides the required clas-
sification for this analysis, using both a global and a specific North
African approach.
Worldwide analysis of SDGs by study shows (14) a significant
focus on certain SDGs. The “Responsible Consumption and
Production” (SDG 12) and “Zero Hunger” (SDG 02) SDGs are the
most widely studied, with 77.59% and 76.70% of the documents,
respectively. Furthermore, SDG 13, “Climate Action, ” has received
great interest, with 75.71% of documents dedicated to addressing
climate-related issues, reflecting a strong emphasis on climate change
in scholarly research. In addition, “Life on Land” (SDG 15) and “Life
Below Water” (SDG 14) were the documents with higher consider-
ation (75% and 59.91%, respectively).
However, this is the reverse case when looking at research in
North Africa. Interestingly, there is still considerable interest in
“Climate Action” (SDG 13) and “Responsible Consumption and
Production” (SDG 12), with 64.29% of the documents, indicating a
distinct focus on climate-production related issues in the studies con-
ducted in this area. Additionally, documents around “Zero Hunger”
(SDG 02) were also given great importance (57.14%). In addition, the
percentages of SDGs (57.14%) with a relatively similar distribution
were found in SDGs “Quality Education” (SDG 04), “Life Below
Water” (SDG 14), and “Life On Land” (SDG 15), aligning with the
global trends but with a different priority.
The overall picture is that some SDGs have seen a similar focus of
attention at global and North African level; the North African analysis
highlights the specific focus on certain SDGs, such as SDG13 (Climate
Action), which indicates a targeted strategy to tackle climate-related
issues. The results highlight the differences in focus and priorities
between research on sustainable development from a global perspec-
tive and research focused on the North African region, thus helping
to understand the specific regional issues in the context of Sustainable
Development Goals.
3.2.3 Research areas
The information presented in Figure 7 offers a detailed picture of
the research fields examined by using the documents found on the
Web of Science and Scopus databases, on the global level as well as
within the context of the North African region. When analyzed, these
databases show some variety of scientific disciplines studied in schol-
arly articles.
The Web of Science (WoS) database covers a wide range of
research fields. Important areas are food science technology (42.68%
documents), business economics (36.43% documents), and agricul-
ture (29.11% documents). In Scopus, there is a significant interdisci-
plinary interest, with Agricultural and Biological Sciences (559
documents, 53.60%) and showing the highest interest and Business,
Management and Accounting (333 documents, 31.93%) and Social
Sciences (240 documents, 23.01%), and Environmental Science (239
documents, 22.91%).
Within the Web of Science database, North Africa is a primary
focus, with the most documents listed under Environmental Sciences
Ecology (six documents, 42.86%), Science Technology (five docu -
ments, 35.71%), and agriculture (four documents, 28.57%). Likewise,
Business Economics /Food Science Technology (both eight docu -
ments, 21.43%) are among the top subject areas in this region. The
FIGURE 5
Documents number per country among investigated studies using specific keywords in Web of Sciences (n = 1,120) and Scopus (n = 1,043) databases.
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 08 frontiersin.org
results reflect the international situation, with common, core fields of
research interest that reflect different proportions and emphases. In
the Scopus, the most documents listed under the areas of Agricultural
and Biological Sciences (eight documents, 53.33%), Social Sciences
(seven documents, 46.67%), and Environmental Science (six docu-
ments, 40%).
In some sense, there is overlap among the various research areas
in the two contexts, global and North African, but the regional analy-
sis reveals a particular focus in certain areas, in particular environ-
mental and agricultural sciences. Analysing the international and
regional databases highlights the diversity of the scholarly interests
and suggests an overall convergence and specificity of research inter-
ests in the scientific field of North Africa.
3.2.4 Top 25 authors
The total number of top 25 authors who have contributed to the
research of the specific keywords globally and in North Africa is pre-
sented in Figure 8. Examining the Web of Science database globally
highlights the remarkable research output by authors such as
Thogersen, J., Duong, C. D., Hamm, U., and Paul, J., with document
frequencies ranging from 10 (0.89%) by Thogersen J to 6 (0.54%) by
Paul, J. Similarly, in the Scopus database, notable contributions come
from authors like Hamm, U. (16 documents, 1.53%), Janssen, M. (7
documents, 0.67%), Christensen, T., and Rojík, S. (each contributing
6 documents, 0.58%).
In the context of North African researchers within the Web of
Science database, Lairon, D. contributed to three research papers (two
documents, 14.89%), all other top 25 authors such as Aboussaleh, Y .,
Achir, N., Adel, A. M., and Adis, A. A. A., etc., each contributing two
documents (7.14%). In the Scopus database, Aboussaleh, Y ., El Bilali,
H., Pugliese, P ., Strassner, C., and Średnicka-Tober, D., contributed by
two documents (13.33%), all the other top 25 contributors among
North African researchers include Abdul Adis, A. A., Aboukhalaf, A.,
and Akli, S., etc. credited with one document each (6.67%). These
findings underscore the significant impact of various authors on
scholarly research within these databases, both globally and within
North Africa.
It is interesting, however, that the document frequencies of the top
contributors within the North African countries are relatively lower,
at 1.2 documents per article in the Scopus database and 1.04 docu-
ments per article in the Web of Science database. In contrast, the top
25 authors in countries other than North African countries have
higher average document frequencies in the Scopus base (5.2) and in
the Web of Science base (4.96). The fact that it is a different set of data
to that provided by the other databases, indicates that the field of study
of these databases is uncommon in the North African region, in com-
parison to the rest of the world.
FIGURE 6
Sustainable Development Goals among studies of the North African countries and worldwide using the specific keywords in Web of Sciences.
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 09 frontiersin.org
3.2.5 Evolution of published documents over time
The evolution of published documents was analyzed for the whole
world and the North African region in both the Web of Science and
Scopus databases (Figure 9).
In terms of the scope of research areas discussed in the covered
literature, the analysis of the documents published in the Web of
Science database shows that it has been changing over time at a global
level. Significant growth is clearly seen since 2010, with a sharp rise in
documents published in recent years: 142 documents (12.67%) in
2024 and 180 documents (16.07%) in 2025. Likewise, the Scopus data-
base shows a clear trend and a steady increase in documents from
2010, culminating in a large increase reaching 166 documents
(15.91%) by 2025.
As for North Africa, the information obtained from the Web of
Science shows that the research volume increased and decreased peri-
odically, with some years having particularly high volumes. In particu-
lar, in 2021, there was a significant increase, with six documents
(42.86%), then three documents (21.43%) in 2022. Likewise, the data
from the Scopus database show a slow increase in 2024 and 2025, with
four documents (26.66%) and three documents (20%), respectively.
Such shifts may represent trends in research interests or new trends or
areas of focus in North Africa.
The number of publications in the Scopus and Web of Science
databases for the global average was 34.77 and 43.08 per year,
respectively. However, in North Africa, the average publication rate
was significantly lower at 1.75 documents per year in the Web of
Science and 1.36 documents per year in Scopus. The data highlight
the slow emergence of scientific activity and its low level in North
African countries, which is marked by the delayed appearance of
these countries in the Scopus and Web of Science databases in 2015
and 2018, respectively. This belated representation could indicate
that the region is lagging behind other worldwide research centers
in the integration of research and/or in documentation of research
products.
The lag in visibility of the scientific work of the countries of
North Africa in accessible databases, including Scopus and Web of
Science, could indicate on the one hand delayed integration of
research institutes and delayed participation in international
research cooperation, and on the other hand, a gradual yet growing
participation in academic pursuits in the global scientific commu -
nity. It is very important that the barriers or the challenge faced by
the North African research output to be included in these databases
in time is addressed.
Global analysis reveals that, over time, research areas are being
explored more, with a rise in academic output in recent years, as
shown by the trends. The ups and downs of North African research
production indicate academic activity, revealing that the interests or
focus of research in the region has varied over time. These observa-
tions underline the dynamic nature of research interests, both globally
FIGURE 7
Research areas recovered by the studied documents according to Web of Sciences and Scopus databases.
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 10 frontiersin.org
FIGURE 8
Top 25 authors published research using the specific keywords among Web of Science and Scopus databases in North Africa and worldwide.
FIGURE 9
Evolution of published documents over time using the specific keywords in Web of Science and Scopus databases.
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 11 frontiersin.org
and within North Africa, illustrating the evolving landscape of schol-
arly endeavors over time.
3.2.6 Publication type
The frequency of published documents based on the different
types of publication showed in Figure 10 concerned the research con-
ducted in relation to specific keywords related to Consumer Behavior
and Organic Products in Web of Sciences and Scopus databases for
both the global context and the North African context. It offers
detailed information on document frequency and types in these data-
bases which give insight into unique characteristics of publication
trends in global and regional level.
The most common document type among the Web of Sciences
results is articles, with 90.53% (1,014 documents) of the total publica-
tions found in this document type worldwide. Review articles made
up 5.80% (65 documents), and the proceedings papers each made up
4.02% (45 documents). This prevalence of articles reflects the major
role of articles in the worldwide dissemination of research findings in
this area. Likewise, according to the Scopus database (worldwide), the
article type of publication is the most common, with 85.71% (894
documents). The book chapter and reviews were next, at 5.75% (60)
and 4.51% (47), respectively. It is a distribution similar to what is seen
in the academic world, with articles and reviews being used mainly as
avenues for disseminating research.
The focus then turned to North Africa, to the Web of Sciences,
and again the articles were the predominant document type, with
92.86% of the publications (13 documents). This regional phenome-
non is in line with the worldwide trend favoring articles as the main
form of scholarly communication, including the North African con-
text. Similarly, in the North Africa Scopus document type analysis,
articles continued being the most common type of document, with
86.67% (13 papers).
Comparing global and North Africa publications highlights that
the majority of publications worldwide and in North Africa are in
the form of articles. The document type distribution is overwhelm -
ingly dominated by articles in both contexts, although the regional
analysis for North Africa shows a greater variation of document
types, suggesting a broader range of research outputs, with different
types of publications, than global standards. This distinction shows
the differences of the research which is carried out in the region,
even though the overall number of publications is significantly
smaller.
3.2.7 Top 25 journals
Table 1 shows the top 25 journals, which were identified through
the Scopus and Web of Science databases according to publications
related to consumer behavior towards sustainable food and organic
products. It includes a comparative analysis of the publications around
the world and the ones from North Africa.
The number of papers published in global journals was examined,
and based on the research carried out in Scopus, the “British Food
Journal” journal is the most leading, with 169 papers, which accounted
for 16.20% of all the papers published. There are 3.26% (34) publica-
tions following closely behind, ‘Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems’ .
Similarly, the Web of Science database lists “British Food Journal” as
the main journal with 168 documents (15%) followed by the “Food
Quality And Preference” journal with 73 documents (6.52%).
This comparative analysis shows that there are common jour -
nals in the top journals in the two databases, especially “British
Food Journal. ” The results of this analysis indicated that there were
differences in document distribution across journals in Scopus and
Web of Science, which may reflect the preferences and/or indexing
criteria for journals between these two platforms. A change of scale
was observed in the number of documents in Africa when com -
pared to the world scale in North Africa. With two small 3–4 docu -
ments, ‘Sustainability’ takes the top spot leading the way with
20–28.57% of all regional publications in Scopus and Web of
Science, respectively.
The number of publications in this section of the data reflects the
significant difference between the number of publications in North
Africa and the worldwide total. From the small number of journals
published in North Africa, journals that are focused on sustainability
or specific food-related topics tend to dominate, reflecting a focus on
specific niches within this region.
A detailed distribution of the documents in the journals mention-
ing consumer behavior and sustainable food/organic products is given
FIGURE 10
Frequency of published documents according to publication type using the specific keywords based on Web of Science and Scopus databases in North
Africa and worldwide.
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 12 frontiersin.org
TABLE 1 Top 25 journals of published documents on consumer behavior towards sustainable food and organic products according to Web of Science and Scopus databases in North Africa and
worldwide.
Rank Top 25 Journals Scopus (Worldwide) Top 25 Journals Web of Sciences (Worldwide)
Journal Documents Frequency Journal Documents Frequency
1 British Food Journal 169 16.20% British Food Journal 168 15.00%
2 Frontiers in
Sustainable Food
Systems
34 3.26% Food Quality and
Preference
73 6.52%
3 Journal of Retailing
and Consumer
Services
18 1.73% Foods 69 6.16%
4 Agriculture
Switzerland
17 1.63% Frontiers in
Sustainable Food
Systems
46 4.11%
5 Food Policy 17 1.63% International
Journal of
Consumer Studies
32 2.86%
6 Journal of Food
Products Marketing
16 1.53% Journal of Retailing
and Consumer
Services
28 2.50%
7 Journal of
International Food
and Agribusiness
Marketing
14 1.34% Journal of
International Food
Agribusiness
Marketing
16 1.43%
8 Renewable
Agriculture and Food
Systems
13 1.25% Agriculture Basel 14 1.25%
9 Acta Horticulturae 12 1.15% Ecological
Economics
14 1.25%
10 Business Strategy and
the Environment
12 1.15% Business Strategy
and The
Environment
13 1.16%
11 Springer Proceedings
in Business and
Economics
12 1.15% Journal of Business
Research
12 1.07%
12 Organic Agriculture 11 1.05% Journal of
Consumer
Behavior
11 0.98%
13 Journal of Business
Research
10 0.96% Journal of Food
Products Marketing
11 0.98%
14 Journal of Rural
Studies
10 0.96% Sage Open 10 0.89%
15 Ecological
Economics
9 0.86% Asia Pacific Journal
of Marketing and
Logistics
9 0.80%
16 Food Research
International
9 0.86% Cogent Business
Management
9 0.80%
17 Quality Access to
Success
9 0.86% International
Journal of
Gastronomy and
Food Science
9 0.80%
(Continued)
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 13 frontiersin.org
TABLE 1 (Continued)
Rank Top 25 Journals Scopus (Worldwide) Top 25 Journals Web of Sciences (Worldwide)
Journal Documents Frequency Journal Documents Frequency
18 Developments in
Marketing Science
Proceedings of the
Academy of
Marketing Science
8 0.77% Journal of
Consumer
Marketing
9 0.80%
19 Environment
Development and
Sustainability
8 0.77% Renewable
Agriculture and
Food Systems
9 0.80%
20 Journal of
Environmental
Protection and
Ecology
8 0.77% Science of the Total
Environment
9 0.80%
21 New Medit 8 0.77% Food and Humanity 8 0.71%
22 Asia Pacific Journal
of Marketing and
Logistics
7 0.67% Future Foods 8 0.71%
23 International Journal
of Gastronomy and
Food Science
7 0.67% Journal of
Marketing
Management
8 0.71%
24 Journal of Food
Agriculture and
Environment
7 0.67% Agribusiness 7 0.63%
25 Journal of Marketing
Management
7 0.67% Ekonomika
Poljoprivreda
Economics of
Agriculture
7 0.63%
Rank Top 25 Journals Scopus (North Africa) Top 25 Journals Web of Sciences (North Africa)
Journal Documents Frequency Journal Documents Frequency
1 Sustainability 3 20.00% Sustainability 4 28.57%
2 British Food Journal 1 6.67% Agribusiness 1 7.14%
3 Frontiers in Nutrition 1 6.67% Brand Label and
Product Intelligence
1 7.14%
4 Frontiers in Sustainable
Food Systems
1 6.67% British Food Journal 1 7.14%
5 International Journal of
Environmental Impacts
1 6.67% Environment
Development and
Sustainability
1 7.14%
6 Journal of Research in
Marketing and
Entrepreneurship
1 6.67% Frontiers in
Nutrition
1 7.14%
7 New Medit 1 6.67% Frontiers In
Sustainable Food
Systems
1 7.14%
8 Nutrients 1 6.67% International Journal
of Business
Environment
1 7.14%
(Continued)
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 14 frontiersin.org
in Table 1, both at the international level and in North Africa. This
helps to illuminate which journals are leading, respectively in which
frequency, and what is the regional focus on this scholarly subject.
3.3 Bibliometric analysis
At the world-wide level and in the North African region, the bib-
liometric analysis of research papers about consumer behavior
towards sustainable products showed a very interesting result based
on the co-authorship distributions and co-occurrence-based key -
words of these papers in Web of Sciences and Scopus databases,
respectively (Figures 11, 12).
3.3.1 Co-authorship-based countries distribution
Bibliometric analysis based on the data exported from Scopus
showed that 16 countries were identified according to the networks of
co-authors of the studies analyzed for the North Africa region. In
Scopus, Morocco was found to have the most citations (58) and total
link strength (12). After Morocco, Italy had 25 citations and 12 link
strength, and Algeria-Tunisia had 39–64 citations and 5–2 link
strength, respectively. The Egyptian contributions had 64 citations, as
well as a link strength of only 1. Likewise, in Web of Sciences,
Morocco, Egypt, Tunisia, and Algeria showed different extents of col-
laboration, with Morocco (with a total link strength of 12) showing
high involvement in collaborations with several countries, namely
Italy, which stands out with the highest total connection strength,
indicating a predominant role in the network of collaborations within
the North Africa region.
Co-authorship had a number of countries at the global level in
Scopus and Web of Sciences. Within Scopus, there were 120 countries
involved in the collaborative network, Italy being the country with the
highest number of documents (107), citations (4,197), and a total link
strength of 84. The United States, India, and Germany also had strong
showings. Associations presented by collaborative clusters featured a
variety of international collaborations. Similarly, 91 countries were
involved in the Web of Sciences, with Italy, USA, China, and India
being the leaders. Groups of people collaborated and were linked with
other groups, including Spain, England, Canada, Switzerland,
Germany, and Denmark, among others.
3.3.2 Distribution of co-occurrence-based
keywords
Using the established criteria, a total of 136 keywords were found
in Scopus for North Africa, with the most common being “Organic
food” (five occurrences, total link strength of 11), “Sustainable devel-
opment goal” (two occurrences, total link strength of 10), and
“Consumer behavior” (five occurrences, total link strength of 9). The
clusters identified links between “Organic farming, ” sustainability, and
TABLE 1 (Continued)
Rank Top 25 Journals Scopus (North Africa) Top 25 Journals Web of Sciences (North Africa)
Journal Documents Frequency Journal Documents Frequency
9 Open Agriculture 1 6.67% International Journal
of Environmental
Research and Public
Health
1 7.14%
10 Pakistan Journal of
Agricultural Sciences
1 6.67% Open Agriculture 1 7.14%
11 Revista Espanola De
Antropologia Fisica
1 6.67% Pakistan Journal of
Agricultural Sciences
1 7.14%
12 Springer Proceedings
in Business and
Economics
1 6.67% Springer Proceedings
in Business and
Economics
1 7.14%
13 – – – – – –
14 – – – – – –
15 – – – – – –
16 – – – – – –
17 – – – – – –
18 – – – – – –
19 – – – – – –
20 – – – – – –
21 – – – – – –
22 – – – – – –
23 – – – – – –
24 – – – – – –
25 – – –
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 15 frontiersin.org
FIGURE 11
Bibliometric analysis of published documents on consumer behavior towards sustainable food and organic products according to the Web of Science
(left) and Scopus (right) database (A) and their worldwide co-authorship distribution (B) in the North African region. The circle diameter is proportional
to the intensity of scientific activity.
FIGURE 12
Bibliometric analysis of published documents on consumer behavior towards sustainable food and organic products in the Web of Science (left) and
Scopus (right) databases: (A) their worldwide co-authorship distribution and (B) a global scale. The circle diameter is proportional to the intensity of
scientific activity.
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 16 frontiersin.org
diet, among others. Among the 150 keywords in the Web of Sciences,
four appeared as the top keywords, which were “Organic Food, ” fol-
lowed by “Consumption, ” “Planned behavior, ” and “Sustainability. ”
Interesting clusters included associations of “Organic food” to pur-
chase intention, environmental concern, and green purchase behavior.
In the global scenario within Scopus, 3,869 keywords, 286 meet
the threshold (appear at least five times) were identified, and the most
common keywords were “Human” (134 occurrences, total link
strength of 1,736), “Organic food” (296 occurrences, total link strength
of 1,502), “Food consumption” (178 occurrences, total link strength
of 1,096), and “Consumer attitude” (87 occurrences, total link strength
of 1,040). Increased clusters showed a high association between
“Human” and consumer attitude, eating behavior, and sustainable
foods. A total of 370 keywords were identified as relevant in the Web
of Sciences, with the keyword ‘Organic Food’ appearing most (423
appearances, with a total link strength of 3,390), followed closely by
“ Attitudes” and “Consumption. ” Notable clusters included associations
with “Organic food, ” purchase intention, consumption, and percep-
tions of organic products.
This extensive bibliometric study sheds light on the co-occurrence
patterns and keywords that emerged in consumer behavior research
on organic products. It highlights different trends of co-authorship
networks and keyword co-occurrences of North Africa and the world’s
research landscape in the Web of Science and Scopus databases.
3.4 Overview of the selected studies from
North Africa
Preliminary research in North Africa on sustainable food and
consumer behavior offers valuable insights into the factors that drive
food choices of the population in this region. These research projects
include Morocco, Egypt, Tunisia and all the Mediterranean countries
and aim to emphasize the decisive influence of health, environmental
and cultural factors in preference for organic and sustainable prod-
ucts. The impact of culture on these preferences was in general posi-
tive. Farmers’ traditions still exist and are encouraging the use of local
and natural consumption. This is supported by religious beliefs, espe-
cially those of Islam which promote healthy and pure food. This is
complemented by increased awareness among consumers, and espe-
cially younger ones, of the advantages of organic products, which are
more sensitive to health and environmental concerns. Consumers in
Morocco value the safety and quality of the ‘Beldi’ products while
Egyptians show clearly that attitudes and environmental concerns
have had an impact on the intention to purchase organic food. The
different aspects have been studied in Tunisia through a mediation
factor (attitude) and a motivation (buying organic) or ethical con-
sumption. Moreover, the research that has been conducted in the
Mediterranean has stressed the importance of sustainable food sys-
tems and followed the Mediterranean diet pyramid. Taken together,
these results give a more comprehensive vision of consumers’ behavior
and give some interesting implications for the promotion of sustain-
able and healthy food practices in North Africa (Table 2).
4 Discussion
Studying consumer behavior towards sustainable food products
is essential for understanding the adoption dynamics and barriers to
transitioning to healthier and eco-friendly products. Drawing on an
in-depth bibliometric analysis of publications indexed in Scopus and
Web of Science, this study examined the historical emergence of sus-
tainable food research, publication trends, their alignment with
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), the research areas explored,
author contributions, and bibliometric analyses.
4.1 Scientific collaboration and current state
of research
An analysis of bibliometric trends has shown that North Africa is
poorly represented in the global research on sustainable food. In con-
trast to regions where scientific production is supported by well-
funded research programs, North African publications remain fewer
and have a limited impact in high-profile journals. While world-
renowned authors have higher document frequencies, North African
authors have relatively lower frequencies, indicating that research
production in these databases is limited. This is largely due to a lack
of inter-institutional collaboration and difficulties in accessing inter-
national funding (Table 3) (Bahn et al., 2021; Goumaa et al., 2023).
The results vary from what is expected due to the increasing relevance
of food sustainability in the global context, in which a more balanced
participation between the regions could be expected. It is however
important to note that academic resource disparity and funding is a
significant factor in the distribution of scientific publications. This
highlights the importance of international efforts to help narrow this
divide and promote more collaborative scientific work.
Furthermore, the results indicate a diverse distribution of research
themes in North Africa and worldwide. Studies conducted in these
areas encompass various aspects of sustainable food systems, includ-
ing agricultural, environmental, economic, and social dimensions,
reflecting a multidisciplinary approach consistent with global trends
(He, 2023). A more interdisciplinary approach integrating the con-
sumer psychology, and behavioral economics broadens the perspec-
tive of this research.
4.2 Factors influencing the transition to
sustainable food in North Africa
The debate on the health benefits of consuming sustainable and
conventional foods has attracted considerable attention. Healthy, sus-
tainable diets based on the consumption of sustainable food products
are essential not only for reducing greenhouse gas emissions from
food systems but also for improving health outcomes. These diets are
essentially characterized by a high consumption of coarse grains,
legumes, fruits, vegetables, nuts, and seeds, while limiting animal-
based and energy-dense foods ( Vicente-Vicente and Piorr, 2021 ;
Wong, 2021). The bibliometric analysis revealed that existing research
on sustainable food in North Africa has mainly focused on factors
influencing consumer behavior extracted from studies conducted in
the region. These factors include socioeconomic, cultural, and envi-
ronmental aspects that shape the food choices and preferences of
North African consumers. The latter favors organic and agroecological
products for health and food safety reasons (Table 4) (Popa et al., 2019;
Kumar, 2021). The preference for sustainable products is explained by
their superior nutritional profiles and perceived health benefits (Popa
et al., 2019 ; Kumar, 2021). Although clinical trials evaluating the
health outcomes related to sustainable food consumption are limited,
observational studies have demonstrated positive associations.
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 17 frontiersin.org
TABLE 2 Overview of some studies from North Africa on sustainable food and consumer behavior.
Country Type of food product Study type Study aims Main results References
Morocco organic and “Beldi” products Research article (survey with qualitative
approach)
This study explores the consumption patterns of
organic and “Beldi” products by Moroccan
consumers to identify different systems of
consumption values and their relationship with
consumption practices.
Consumers in Morocco favor organic and “Beldi”
products due to health concerns, seek safer options
devoid of harmful chemicals, find reassurance in
their quality, and perceive them as natural remedies
promoting overall well-being. The results proposes a
typology of consumption values for these products,
and presents the results of a qualitative study using
semi-directive interviews.
Jazi and Kasmi (2022)
Egypt Organic food products Research article (survey with quantitative
approach)
The factors examined in this study were attitudes,
subjective norms, perceived behavioral control,
e-WOM, environmental concerns, and health
consciousness.
This study found that consumers’ attitudes and
environmental concerns significantly influenced their
intention to purchase organic food. However, factors
such as e-WOM, subjective norms, perceived
behavioral control, and health consciousness did not
have a substantial impact on purchase intentions.
Interestingly, e-WOM plays a significant role in
shaping various consumer perceptions of organic
foods.
Zayed et al. (2022)
Tunisia Organic food Research article (survey with quantitative
approach)
This study delves into consumer perspectives on
organic food in Tunisia, focusing on perceived
values (functional, individual, social, and
financial) and their influence on attitudes and
subsequent buying behavior. It explores how
attitudes shape purchasing choices, and considers
the role of price sensitivity as a moderator
between attitude and behavior in organic food
consumption.
The study validates the cognitive model (value-
attitude-behavior), indicating a sequential
progression from value perceptions to attitudes, and
finally to consumer behavior regarding organic food
consumption.
Ghali-Zinoubi (2021)
Attitudes serve as a mediator between perceived
values and consumer behavior. Price sensitivity is a
substantial negative moderator that affects the link
between attitudes and behavior.
Morocco, Algeria,
and Tunisia
Organic food and bio-products Research article (survey with qualitative
and quantitative approach)
This study highlighted key motivations for
organic purchases and consumer behaviors
during the COVID-19 pandemic in the North
African context.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, dietary shifts were
aimed at boosting immunity and preventing disease.
Academic level, sex, and residency influenced eating
habits. Insights into pandemic eating behaviors can
inform policies in organic and bio-based food
production, potentially reducing allergic diseases and
obesity risk. Organic food, within a balanced diet,
holds promise for managing health crises, such as
COVID-19.
Ben Khadda et al. (2022)
(Continued)
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 18 frontiersin.org
TABLE 2 (Continued)
Country Type of food product Study type Study aims Main results References
Mediterranean
countries (France
and Tunisia)
Dietary patterns and changes in
food consumption
Research article (MEDINA “Fork-To-
Farm” Multi-Scale Approach)
This article advocates sustainable food systems in
the Mediterranean to improve nutrition and
health. This finding highlights the importance of
addressing dietary changes in food security and
positive health outcomes.
This article introduces the framework and
methodologies of the MEDINA-Study Group that
analyzes and optimizes food systems in southern
France and Tunisia with a focus on sustainability.
This study evaluated regional food system
sustainability while emphasizing adherence to the
Mediterranean diet pyramid. This article stresses the
importance of promoting the Mediterranean diet for
better health while considering local variations,
seasonal factors, and cultural traditions. Thus,
adopting sustainable diets could play a crucial role in
improving food security and quality in the
Mediterranean region.
Verger et al. (2018)
Egypt and China Research article Research article (survey with quantitative
approach)
This study explores consumer motivations that
influence behavioral intentions toward
suboptimal produce. Key motivating factors
include environmental concerns, awareness of
food waste, and familiarity (past behavior).
The extended Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB)
model, including motivating and demotivating
factors, shows promising outcomes. Although
environmental concern does not have a significant
impact on consumers’ attitudes and intentions
towards suboptimal produce in China and Egypt, the
extended TPB constructs effectively predict a
substantial portion of consumers’ intentions to buy
(79.9%) and recommend (65.3%) produce. This study
contributes to food waste research and offers
practical insights for retailers and policymakers
dealing with decisions regarding suboptimal
production.
Adel et al. (2022)
Egypt Sustainable consumerism Research article (Qualitative methods,
specifically in-depth semi-structured
interviews)
This article seeks to gauge sustainability
consciousness among youth in Egypt and their
perceptions of green products.
The results show that a consumer market is perceived
as naive globally, yet actively contributes to corporate
sustainability through informed and responsive
marketing and branding decisions.
Khalil et al. (2021)
Mediterranean
countries
Sustainable food Research article (Qualitative methods,
online consultations)
The goal was to unveil an updated version of the
Mediterranean Diet Pyramid (MDP) that
integrates diverse environmental considerations.
The updated Mediterranean Diet Pyramids (MDP)
prioritize health and environmental considerations
by advocating reduced red meat and bovine dairy
consumption while promoting increased intake of
legumes and locally sourced, eco-friendly plant-
based foods.
Serra-Majem et al. (2020)
(Continued)
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 19 frontiersin.org
TABLE 2 (Continued)
Country Type of food product Study type Study aims Main results References
Tunisia Ethical products Research article (survey with quantitative
approach)
The study seeks to explore the drivers behind
ethical consumption, concentrating on three
primary motivations: environmental concerns,
social value, and sustained engagement with
ethical products.
This study reveals that Tunisian consumers engage in
ethical consumption motivated by health,
environmental, and social status concerns. This
contributes to understanding the link between social
status and ethical consumption. Marketers in
developing countries can leverage these findings to
create effective communication strategies,
emphasizing the benefits of ethical consumption for
health, the environment, and social standing.
Ghali (2021)
Morocco Organic products Research article (survey with quantitative
approach)
This study investigates the factors influencing
consumers’ attitudes and intentions to purchase
organic food in an emerging market context both
before and after the onset of COVID-19.
This study reveals that consumers’ attitudes play a
significant role in purchasing organic food, with
crucial factors such as subjective norms, labeling, and
health consciousness influencing their decisions. A
post-COVID-19 analysis emphasized the heightened
impact of subjective norms and age on consumers’
purchase intentions. These insights hold particular
importance for organic retailers, especially in
emerging markets amidst the ongoing pandemic.
Chetioui et al. (2023)
Tunisia Organic products Research article (survey with quantitative
approach)
This study investigates the impact of variables
such as perception, attitude, motivation
(specifically health and environmental concerns),
implications, and purchasing intention on
consumer behavior toward organic products.
This study highlights the important influence of
purchase intention, involvement, and motivation,
particularly with regard to health and environmental
concerns, on organic purchasing behavior. However,
the relationships between motivation and attitude,
and between attitude or purchase intention and
attitude or purchase behavior were not significantly
correlated. Sociodemographic variables and attitude-
related factors influence consumers’ purchase
intention for organic products.
Nedra et al. (2015)
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 20 frontiersin.org
TABLE 3 Regional strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and potential collaborations for fostering knowledge exchange within the review article on consumer behavior towards sustainable food in
North Africa.
Aspects Strengths Weaknesses Opportunities Potential
collaborations
Research Emerging interest in
sustainable food
consumption
Limited research funding and
resources
Collaboration in interdisciplinary
studies
Partnerships with international
research institutions and NGOs
Academic Network Potential for regional
academic collaboration
Lack of prominent academic
institutions
Exchange programs for
researchers and students
Collaborative projects with
established universities and think
tanks
Market Access Growing consumer interest
in sustainable products
Limited access to global
markets
Development of local sustainable
food industries
Partnerships with global
distributors and sustainable food
networksPrevalence of Organic Produce
as Conventional Agriculture
Lack of Proper Labeling and
Differentiation
Technology Increasing technological
adoption in agriculture and
food production
Technological gaps in rural
areas
Adoption of innovative tech for
sustainable agriculture practices
Tech-sharing programs with
developed countries and research
institutions
Policy Support Emergence of sustainability
policies and regulations
Inadequate enforcement and
implementation of policies
Advocacy for policy reforms
supporting sustainable food
initiatives
Collaboration with governmental
bodies and NGOs advocating
sustainabilityWeak Legislative Frameworks
Longitudinal studies have linked increased organic matter consump-
tion to a reduced incidence of various health problems (Vigar et al.,
2019). According to the reviewed literature, the perception of nutri-
tional benefits and preferences to avoid exposure to pesticides are
primary factors for sustainable consumption ( Gomiero, 2018 ;
Kwiatkowski et al., 2022). Apart from that, there are also discrepancies
between the antioxidant levels and fatty acid composition of organic
and conventional products, which indicate the possible health impacts
of sustainable food consumption (Barański et al., 2014; Kwiatkowski
et al., 2022). It should be noted, however, that eating organic food does
not necessarily lead to a healthy diet. For instance, a diet of organ meat
and saturated fat is not a healthy diet. However, besides the sustainable
consumption of products, the effect of dietary changes on environ-
mental impacts is also related to the nutritional balance that is affected
by social-cultural, environmental and economic aspects (Sun et al.,
2024). Ben Khadda et al. (2022) study of consumers’ motivations and
barriers supports that the health benefits are important motives for
purchasing organic products and low availability and price are impor-
tant barriers in the dynamics of organic product consumption.
According to a study done in Tunisia, the motivations for buying
organic products are based on health concerns, environmental con-
sciousness and consumer engagement. When consumers are involved
in their organics purchase, they feel that they have higher motivation
and that organics are healthier and more environmentally responsible
(Nedra et al., 2015).
Likewise, several major challenges are the high price of organic
products, which are out of reach for many people, and the absence of
certifications and quality labels, which reduce consumer confidence
(Adenle et al., 2018). The availability of sustainable food products in
North Africa is comparatively low compared to other parts of the
world, like Europe or North America, and distribution systems are not
adequate to address the increasing demand. Unlike industrialized
countries, where regulation and consumer information are better
structured, North Africa suffers from a lack of effective regulation and
limited institutional recognition of organic and agroecological prod-
ucts (Nedra et al., 2015). Despite growing consumer interests, this
situation is returning to the adoption of sustainable food behaviors.
4.3 Challenges and opportunities for
research and public policy
Analysis of scientific publications has also enabled us to iden -
tify the strengths and weaknesses of the sustainable food research
landscape in North Africa. Several factors drive the development
of this theme in the region, including growing awareness of envi -
ronmental issues and the increasing integration of sustainable agri -
cultural technologies. Opportunities are emerging to strengthen
research and implement policies that promote sustainable food.
The bibliometric analysis of co-authorship distributions and co-
occurrence-based keywords unveils collaborative trends and asso -
ciations within consumer behavior research that focuses on
sustainable products. These findings highlight distinct patterns in
co-authorship networks and keyword co-occurrences across North
Africa and the global research landscape in the Web of Science and
Scopus databases. Global strong collaborative networks could be
the result of historical connections or shared research interests of
researchers, or a combination of both ( Zhuang et al., 2020 ; Gajdić
et al., 2023 ). Further, keyword clustering can also signify the inter -
related themes in the area of consumer behavior studies, which
represent interrelated concepts or similar foci found in the aca -
demic literature ( Ma et al., 2023 ). Digital marketing can be deliv -
ered via electronic communication channels, specifically the
Internet and social media, and is capable of targeting certain seg -
ments and customizing marketing strategies to meet consumer
concerns about sustainability ( Nadanyiova et al., 2021 ).
E-commerce and digital technology are a strategic opportunity to
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 21 frontiersin.org
educate consumers on the merits of sustainable products and
enable their direct access to products ( Alkhatib et al., 2023 ). With
the emergence of the digital age, driven by electronic devices and
digital communications, consumer consumption patterns have
been reshaped, especially in the food sector ( Deng, 2022 ). It has
created new ways for consumers to obtain information, make
informed buying choices, and connect consumers, producers and
retailers, and has had a major effect on the organic and agroeco -
logical food market ( Miquel Vidal and Castellano-Tejedor, 2022 ).
Furthermore, as more and more international bodies and NGOs
become engaged in cooperative research projects, funding and
enhanced North African participation in international research
networks are becoming possible ( Pretorius and Schönfeldt, 2023 ).
Such partnerships do not only allow knowledge transfer, capacity
development and common action plans, but can also play a role in
sustainable food consumption in North Africa ( Sonego et
al., 2022 ).
But there are some significant hurdles to be cleared. One of the
most significant challenges for generating new studies and sharing
information in higher-quality academic journals is limited research
funding (Haque and Kamal, 2019; Petrisor, 2022). One of the most
significant obstacles is also the lack of availability of international sci-
entific databases and language barriers, creating a lack of visibility of
research conducted in North Africa in the international scientific
world (Bahn et al., 2021).
Challenges such as data indexing issues, delayed integration of
research institutions, scarcity of locally indexed journals in Scopus and
Web of Sciences within this field, and a slower pace of global research
engagement might have contributed to the delayed representation of
North African scientific output (Musa et al., 2022; Lrhoul and Ameur,
2022). In addition, the absence of a structured regulatory framework
and certified labels complicates the integration of organic products
into consumer practice. The prevalence of sustainable production
marketed and consumed as conventional agriculture in North Africa
is a result of weaknesses in legislative frameworks (Adenle et al., 2019;
Jazi and Kasmi, 2022). The absence of adequate regulations has caused
a lack of adequate labelling and differentiation of organic products in
the market. Progress in the development of legislation for the organic
sector is essential to ensure transparency, trust, and development of
the organic market.
4.4 Alignment with the Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs)
In this study, North African publications related to sustainable
food were also aligned with Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
Furthermore, the results of our thematic analysis demonstrate that
research in North Africa strongly aligns with SDG 12 (Responsible
Consumption and Production) and SDG 13 (Climate Action), fol-
lowed by SDG 2 (Zero Hunger), reflecting a focused regional strategy.
This is probably due to the climate change vulnerability of the area and
its direct impact on the agricultural production and food security
(Pearson and Newman, 2019 ). The authors of Serra-Majem et al.
(2020) pointed out that Mediterranean food pyramids (MFPs) are
changing because of current trends and influences while underlining
their cultural value for health and well-being. The MFP is consistent
with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, they said.
The new version aims to make them more sustainable, to substitute
meat for plant-based and local alternatives, and to limit high-fat dairy
products and processed foods. The changes are being made as part of
efforts to align the region’s food consumption patterns with Sustainable
Development Goals, while honouring the region’s cultural heritage.
4.5 Broader contribution of the study
The overall contributions of this study in the field of consumer
behavior towards sustainable food products, especially in North Africa
are significant. The detailed knowledge about the nature of consump-
tion preferences, motivations and barriers in this region provides valu-
able insights that are vital to inform decision making in the academic,
industry and policy domains. Furthermore, the application of scien-
tific method—bibliometric analysis, co-authorship distribution and
keyword association—makes the study on research trends scientifi-
cally sound and enriches the academic method and serves as a model
for further study of similar research. Importantly, this study’s global
comparative analysis compares research findings from North African
countries with the global trend, which is likely to lead to potential
collaborations and knowledge exchange, and identify strengths, weak-
nesses and opportunities at a regional level. In addition, the study also
addresses the linking of consumer behavior to certain SDGs, which
allows for mapping regional programmes to existing international
sustainability agendas and enables policymakers to match regional
strategies and programmes. In conclusion, the results of this study can
be used as a guideline to help identify research priorities, inform poli-
cymaking and serve as inspiration for future collaboration on sustain-
able food in North Africa.
5 Limitations of the study
Our analysis of scientific production and citation counts on con-
sumer attitudes towards sustainable food was based on WoS and
Scopus databases, but other databases (e.g., Google Scholar, PubMed,
TABLE 4 Preferences, motivations, and obstacles faced by consumers in North Africa
concerning sustainable food products.
Aspects Preferences Motivations Obstacles
Product
Attributes
Organic
certification,
freshness, beldi,
natural origin
Health
consciousness,
environmental
concerns
High prices,
limited
availability, lack
of awareness
Source Local produce,
community-
supported
agriculture (CSA)
Supporting local
economies,
reducing carbon
footprint
Inadequate
distribution
channels,
distance to
markets
Information Clear labeling, and
transparency in
production
processes
Trust in ethical
practices, desire
for traceability
Misleading
marketing,
insufficient
information
Convenience Ready-to-eat,
pre-packaged
sustainable food
options
Time-saving, ease
of access to
healthy
alternatives
Limited
availability in
mainstream
stores
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 22 frontiersin.org
etc.) were not included in our search. The reason behind this omission
was that the number of annual publications that were cited in pub-
lished documents on Google Scholar could not be identified (Musa et
al., 2022). Likewise, citations of papers are dependent on the type of
field, publishing habits, and network relationships and do not neces-
sarily systematically reflect the quality or impact of articles in the co-
authorship-based countries’ distribution. Even with these restrictions,
our study gives important insights into a bibliometric analysis of pre-
vious articles on consumers’ behavior regarding sustainable food
products in North Africa versus other countries.
6 Conclusion
The present study highlights the increasing global awareness of
sustainable food and the scarcity of scientific publications in these
areas in North African countries. This underlines the need for future
research, policy advocacy, and cooperation to support sustainable
food action in the region. The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
have been analyzed with particular regional priorities identified and
revealed, including climate action and good health and well-being,
which are shared global themes or topics with specific North African
dimensions. These priorities express fine distinctions and highlight the
importance of drawing on regional needs and challenges in the con-
text of sustainable development.
A study of sustainable food research fields, co-authorship net -
works, keyword distribution, and publication type revealed the mul-
tidisciplinary nature of sustainable food research. It also emphasizes
the need to engage various fields of research, policy, and stakeholders
to bolster sustainable food practices. Moreover, the most influential
journals, authors, and publication trends help define the scientific pro-
duction landscape, highlighting disparities at the global and
regional levels.
This knowledge requires capacity building, specific investment,
and awareness campaigns to meet these gaps and further sustainable
food agendas. This sets a base for further studies to encourage sustain-
able food use in North Africa and is a helpful guideline for policymak-
ers, researchers, and stakeholders. It pinpoints opportunities and
challenges and suggests strategic initiatives to collectively move
towards a more sustainable and resilient food system in the region.
Thus, this study highlights the importance of concerted efforts and
strategic interventions to achieve a sustainable and equitable food eco-
system in North Africa.
7 Recommendations
Drawing on the empirical data presented in this document, it
offers recommendations aimed at improving food-related research
and policy-an essential step toward the transition to sustainable food
systems in North Africa. We propose the following
recommendations:
- Promote international partnerships: incentive links between uni-
versities in North Africa and international universities for the
transfer of knowledge, greater access to funding, and greater
global visibility of research. - Develop multi-disciplinary research methods: incorporate
social sciences, behavioral economics, consumer psychology,
etc. to increase understanding of the factors driving sustain -
able consumption and which actions are most likely to be
effective. - Expand institutional and financial support: make policy incentives
for the production and consumption of sustainable food products
more effective, such as those focused on awareness-raising and
subsidies or tax reliefs. - Facilitate access to scientific information: develop initiatives to
give North African researchers easier access to international sci-
entific databases and promote open-access publishing to enhance
the dissemination of knowledge. - Encourage certification and digital marketing: introduce reliable
labels and certifications to guarantee the quality of sustainable
products and boost consumer confidence. Simultaneously, digital
tools and online platforms are exploited to raise public awareness
and boost the market for sustainable products.
Data availability statement
Publicly available datasets were analyzed in this study. The biblio-
metric data were extracted from the Web of Science and Scopus data-
bases using specific search keywords.
Author contributions
AB: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis,
Investigation, Methodology, Resources, Software, Supervision,
Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review &
editing. AH: Investigation, Validation, Writing – review & editing.
AA: Formal analysis, Investigation, Writing – review & editing. MB:
Formal analysis, Writing – review & editing. YE: Validation, Writing –
review & editing. KE: Project administration, Supervision, Validation,
Writing – review & editing.
Funding
The author(s) declared that financial support was not received for
this work and/or its publication.
Acknowledgments
The author(s) extends their gratitude to all the researchers whose
work has contributed to the studies analyzed in this bibliometric
analysis. Their dedication to advancing sustainable food systems and
striving towards achieving Sustainable Development Goals is deeply
appreciated.
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 23 frontiersin.org
Conflict of interest
The author(s) declared that this work was conducted in the
absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be
construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Generative AI statement
The author(s) declared that Generative AI was not used in the
creation of this manuscript.
Any alternative text (alt text) provided alongside figures in this
article has been generated by Frontiers with the support of artificial
intelligence and reasonable efforts have been made to ensure accuracy,
including review by the authors wherever possible. If you identify any
issues, please contact us.
Publisher’s note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the
authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated
organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the
reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or
claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or
endorsed by the publisher.
References
Adel, A. M., Dai, X., and Roshdy, R. S. (2022). Investigating consumers' behavioral inten-
tions toward suboptimal produce: an extended theory of planned behavior–a cross-cul-
tural study. Br. Food J. 124, 99–139. doi: 10.1108/BFJ-03-2021-0211
Adenle, A. A., Azadi, H., and Manning, L. (2018). The era of sustainable agricultural
development in Africa: understanding the benefits and constraints. Food Rev. Int. 34,
411–433. doi: 10.1080/87559129.2017.1300913
Adenle, A. A., Wedig, K., and Azadi, H. (2019). Sustainable agriculture and food security
in Africa: the role of innovative technologies and international organizations. Technol.
Soc. 58:101143. doi: 10.1016/j.techsoc.2019.05.007
Alkhatib, S., Kecskés, P ., and Keller, V . (2023). Green marketing in the digital age: a sys-
tematic literature review. Sustainability 15:12369. doi: 10.3390/su151612369
Aoudi, R. (2023). The relation between consumer environmental attitude and the intention
to buy from proximity-short food supply chains in Lebanon . (doctoral dissertation).
Normandie Université, 1–266. Available online at: https://theses.hal.science/tel-04325391
(Accessed November 10, 2025).
Araújo, H. M. D., and Marjotta-Maistro, M. C. (2022). Profiling the consumer of agro-
ecological products using cluster analysis. Rev. Econ. Sociol. Rural. 61:e243394. doi:
10.1590/1806-9479.2021.243394
Bahn, R. A., Y ehya, A. A. K., and Zurayk, R. (2021). Digitalization for sustainable Agri-
food systems: potential, status, and risks for the MENA region. Sustainability 13:3223. doi:
10.3390/su13063223
Baker, P ., Machado, P ., Santos, T., Sievert, K., Backholer, K., Hadjikakou, M., et al. (2020).
Ultra-processed foods and the nutrition transition: global, regional and national trends,
food systems transformations and political economy drivers. Obes. Rev. 21:e13126. doi:
10.1111/obr.13126
Barański, M., Średnicka-Tober, D., Volakakis, N., Seal, C., Sanderson, R., Stewart, G. B.,
et al. (2014). Higher antioxidant and lower cadmium concentrations and lower incidence
of pesticide residues in organically grown crops: a systematic literature review and meta-
analyses. Br. J. Nutr. 112, 794–811. doi: 10.1017/S0007114514001366
Ben Khadda, Z., Ezrari, S., Radouane, N., Boutagayout, A., El Housni, Z., Lahmamsi, H.,
et al. (2022). Organic food consumption and eating habit in Morocco, Algeria, and
Tunisia during the COVID-19 pandemic lockdown. Open Agric. 7, 21–29. doi: 10.1515/
opag-2022-0064
Bertrand, C., Lesturgeon, A., Amiot, M. J., Dimier-Vallet, C., Dufeu, I., Habersetzer, T.,
et al. (2018). Organic food: state of the art and perspectives. Cah. Nutr. Diet. 53, 141–150.
doi: 10.1016/j.cnd.2018.02.004
Boutagayout, A., Belmalha, S., Rehali, M., Nassiri, L., and Bouiamrine, E. H. (2023).
Agroecology as agricultural practices for sustainable management in north African coun-
tries. Int. J. Plant Prod. 17, 389–436. doi: 10.1007/s42106-023-00251-6
Boz, Z., Korhonen, V ., and Koelsch Sand, C. (2020). Consumer considerations for the
implementation of sustainable packaging: a review. Sustainability 12:2192. doi: 10.3390/
su12062192
Carmona, I., Griffith, D. M., and Aguirre, I. (2021). Understanding the factors limiting
organic consumption: the effect of marketing channel on produce price, availability, and
price fairness. Org. Agric. 11, 89–103. doi: 10.1007/s13165-020-00331-1
Chetioui, Y ., Butt, I., Lebdaoui, H., Neville, M. G., and El Bouzidi, L. (2023). Exploring
consumers' attitude and intent to purchase organic food in an emerging market context:
a pre−/post COVID-19 pandemic analysis. Br. Food J. 125, 3979–4001. doi: 10.1108/
BFJ-12-2022-1070
Chopin, P ., Menegat, A., Bergkvist, G., Dahlke, S., Jäck, O., Karlsson, I., et al. (2023). The
reflection of principles and values in worldwide organic agricultural research viewed
through a crop diversification lens. A bibliometric review. Agron. Sustain. Dev. 43:23. doi:
10.1007/s13593-023-00875-y
Clark, M., Macdiarmid, J., Jones, A. D., Ranganathan, J., Herrero, M., and Fanzo, J. (2020).
The role of healthy diets in environmentally sustainable food systems. Food Nutr. Bull. 41,
31S–58S. doi: 10.1177/0379572120953734
Deng, J. (2022). How customer behavior has transformed as e-commerce has devel -
oped in the digital economy. BCP Bus. Manag. 33, 528–537. doi: 10.54691/bcpbm.
v33i.2836
Gajdić, D., Kotzab, H., and Petljak, K. (2023). Collaboration, trust and performance in
Agri-food supply chains: a bibliometric analysis. Br. Food J. 125, 752–778. doi: 10.1108/
BFJ-07-2021-0723
Garcia, S. N., Osburn, B. I., and Jay-Russell, M. T. (2020). One health for food safety, food
security, and sustainable food production. Front. Sustain. Food Syst. 4:1. doi: 10.3389/
fsufs.2020.00001
Ghali, Z. Z. (2021). Motives of ethical consumption: a study of ethical products’ con-
sumption in Tunisia. Environ. Dev. Sustain. 23, 12883–12903.
Ghali-Zinoubi, Z. (2021). Effects of organic food perceived values on consumers’ attitude
and behavior in developing country: moderating role of price sensitivity. Pak. J. Agric. Sci.
58, 779–788. doi: 10.21162/PAKJAS/21.218
Gomiero, T. (2018). Food quality assessment in organic vs. conventional agricultural pro-
duce: findings and issues. Appl. Soil Ecol. 123, 714–728. doi: 10.1016/j.apsoil.2017.10.014
Goumaa, R., Hay, A., and El Ayouby, L. (2023). Developing responsible management in
the Middle East and North Africa region: reviewing PRME progress. J. Manag. Dev. 42,
277–296. doi: 10.1108/JMD-01-2023-0019
Haque, M., and Kamal, Z. (2019). Challenges of publishing in high impact medical jour-
nals from lower- and middle- income countries. Bangladesh J. Med. Sci. 18, 671–674. doi:
10.3329/bjms.v18i4.42868
He, Y . (2023). Unraveling the interplay between food security, agriculture, trade policy,
and energy consumption: an environmental sustainability insight. Energy Environ. 36,
1386–1408. doi: 10.1177/0958305X231195604
Hughner, R. S., McDonagh, P ., and Prothero, A. (2007). Who are organic food consumers?
A compilation and review of why people purchase organic food. J. Consum. Behav. 6,
1–17. doi: 10.1002/cb.210
Jazi, S., and Kasmi, G. (2022). “Consumption values of organic and “Beldi” food products
in Morocco, ” in Brand, label, and product intelligence: second international conference,
COBLI 2021 (Cham: Springer International Publishing), 73–87. doi:
10.1007/978-3-030-95809-1_4
Kamenidou, I., Stavrianea, A., and Bara, E. Z. (2020). Generational differences toward
organic food behavior: insights from five generational cohorts. Sustainability 12:2299. doi:
10.3390/su12062299
Khalil, S., Ismail, A., and Ghalwash, S. (2021). The rise of sustainable consumerism: evi-
dence from the Egyptian generation Z. Sustainability 13:13804. doi: 10.3390/su132413804
Kumar, D. (2021). Nutritional quality of organic foods: a systematic review. Asian J. Res.
Soc. Sci. Humanit. 11, 604–608.
Kwiatkowski, C. A., Harasim, E., Feledyn-Szewczyk, B., and Joniec, J. (2022). The antioxi-
dant potential of grains in selected cereals grown in an organic and conventional system.
Agriculture 12:1485. doi: 10.3390/agriculture12091485
Lazaroiu, G., Andronie, M., Uţă, C., and Hurloiu, I. (2019). Trust management in organic
agriculture: sustainable consumption behavior, environmentally conscious purchase inten-
tion, and healthy food choices. Front. Public Health 7:340. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2019.00340
Lee, N., and Thierfelder, C. (2017). Weed control under conservation agriculture in dry-
land smallholder farming systems of southern Africa. A review. Agron. Sustain. Dev. 37,
1–25. doi: 10.1007/s13593-017-0453-7
Boutagayout et al. 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953564
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 24 frontiersin.org
Lei, J., Lin, S., Khan, M. R., Xie, S., Sadiq, M., Ali, R., et al. (2022). Research trends of
board characteristics and firms’ environmental performance: research directions and
agenda. Sustainability 14:14296. doi: 10.3390/su142114296
Li, H., Arslan, H. M., Mousa, G. A., and Abbas, A. (2023). Exploring sustainability dis-
closures in family firms: a bibliometric analysis. Ekon. Istraz. 36:2188238. doi:
10.1080/1331677x.2023.2188238
Lrhoul, H., and Ameur, A. (2022). A virtual library for the Maghreb? Opportunities and
challenges of open access to scientific information. J. Inf. Sci. 21, 1–13. doi: 10.34874/
IMIST.PRSM/jis-v21i1.31563
Ma, Z., Guo, G., and Jing, L. (2023). Consumer behavior research in the 21st century:
clusters, themes, and future research agenda. Int. J. Consum. Stud. 48:e12980. doi:
10.1111/ijcs.12980
Miller, B. A., and Lu, C. D. (2019). Current status of global dairy goat production: an
overview. Asian Australas. J. Anim. Sci. 32, 1219–1232. doi: 10.5713/ajas.19.0253
Miquel Vidal, M., and Castellano-Tejedor, C. (2022). Identification of marketing strategies
influencing consumers’ perception of healthy food products and triggering purchasing
decisions. Businesses 2, 410–422. doi: 10.3390/businesses2040026
Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., Altman, D. G. and Prisma Group (2010). Preferred
reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Int. J.
Surg. 8, 336–341. doi: 10.1016/j.ijsu.2010.02.007
Musa, T. H., Kawuki, J., and Musa, H. H. (2022). Bibliometric analysis of the African
health sciences’ research indexed in web of science and Scopus. Afr. Health Sci. 22,
704–716. doi: 10.4314/ahs.v22i2.80
Nadanyiova, M., Majerova, J., and Gajanova, L. (2021). Digital marketing, competitive
advantage, marketing communication, social media, consumers. Mark. Manag. Innov. 5,
92–103. doi: 10.21272/mmi.2021.4-08
Nedra, B. A., Sharma, S., and Dakhli, A. (2015). Perception and motivation to purchase
organic products in Mediterranean countries: an empirical study in Tunisian context. J.
Res. Mark. Entrep. 17, 67–90. doi: 10.1108/JRME-07-2014-0015
Olson, E. L. (2017). The rationalization and persistence of organic food beliefs in the face
of contrary evidence. J. Clean. Prod. 140, 1007–1013. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.06.005
Otekunrin, O. A. (2023). Countdown to the 2030 global goals: a bibliometric analysis of
research trends on SDG 2–zero hunger. Curr. Res. Nutr. Food Sci. J. 11, 1338–1362. doi:
10.12944/CRNFSJ.11.3.34
Page, M. J., Moher, D., Bossuyt, P . M., Boutron, I., Hoffmann, T. C., Mulrow, C. D., et al.
(2021). PRISMA 2020 explanation and elaboration: updated guidance and exemplars for
reporting systematic reviews. BMJ 372:n160. doi: 10.1136/bmj.n160
Pearson, D., and Newman, P . (2019). Climate security and a vulnerability model for con-
flict prevention: a systematic literature review focusing on African agriculture. Sustain.
Earth 2, 1–22. doi: 10.1186/s42055-019-0009-6
Persiani, A., Diacono, M., and Montemurro, F . (2023). Agroecological practices in organic
fennel cultivation to improve environmental sustainability. Agroecol. Sustain. Food Syst.
47, 668–686. doi: 10.1080/21683565.2023.2180699
Petrisor, A. I. (2022). Influence of predatory journals on the publishing behavior of
researchers from countries with a short western-style academic publishing tradition. A
language perspective. J. Teach. Engl. Spec. Acad. Purp.:493. doi: 10.22190/jtesap2203493p
Place, F ., Niederle, P ., Sinclair, F ., Carmona, N. E., Guéneau, S., Gitz, V ., et al. (2022).
“ Agroecologically-conducive policies: a review of recent advances and remaining
challenges, ” in Working Paper 1. (Bogor, Indonesia: The Transformative Partnership
Platform on Agroecology), 1–32. doi:10.17528/cifor-icraf/008593
Popa, M. E., Mitelut, A. C., Popa, E. E., Stan, A., and Popa, V . I. (2019). Organic foods
contribution to nutritional quality and value. Trends Food Sci. Technol. 84, 15–18. doi:
10.1016/j.tifs.2018.01.003
Pretorius, B., and Schönfeldt, H. C. (2023). Opportunities for higher education institu-
tions to develop sustainable food systems in Africa. Front. Sustain. Food Syst. 7:1147115.
doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2023.1147115
Ruggeri, G., Orsi, L., and Corsi, S. (2019). A bibliometric analysis of the scientific litera-
ture on Fairtrade labelling. Int. J. Consum. Stud. 43, 134–152. doi: 10.1111/ijcs.12492
Serra-Majem, L., Tomaino, L., Dernini, S., Berry, E. M., Lairon, D., Ngo de la Cruz, J., et al.
(2020). Updating the Mediterranean diet pyramid towards sustainability: focus on envi-
ronmental concerns. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 17:8758. doi: 10.3390/
ijerph17238758
Sonego, M., Echeveste, M. E. S., and Debarba, H. G. (2022). Repair of electronic products:
consumer practices and institutional initiatives. Sustainable Prod. Consumption 30,
556–565. doi: 10.1016/j.spc.2021.12.031
Sun, X., Wang, R., He, P ., and Liu, B. (2024). Effects of environmental and nutritional
labels on the dietary choices of consumers: evidence from China. Environ. Impact Assess.
Rev. 105:107407. doi: 10.1016/j.eiar.2023.107407
Thakur, N., Kaur, S., Kaur, T., Tomar, P ., Devi, R., Thakur, S., et al. (2022). “Organic agri-
culture for agro-environmental sustainability, ” in Trends of Applied Microbiology for
Sustainable Economy, eds. R. Soni, D. C. Suyal, A. N. Y adav and R. Goel (Cambridge,
Massachusetts: Academic Press), 699–735.
Verger, E. O., Perignon, M., El Ati, J., Darmon, N., Dop, M. C., Drogué, S., et al. (2018).
A “fork-to-farm” multi-scale approach to promote sustainable food systems for nutrition
and health: a perspective for the Mediterranean region. Front. Nutr. 5:30. doi: 10.3389/
fnut.2018.00030
Vicente-Vicente, J. L., and Piorr, A. (2021). Can a shift to regional and organic diets
reduce greenhouse gas emissions from the food system? A case study from Qatar. Carbon
Balance Manag. 16:2. doi: 10.1186/s13021-020-00167-y
Vigar, V ., Myers, S., Oliver, C., Arellano, J., Robinson, S., and Leifert, C. (2019). A system-
atic review of organic versus conventional food consumption: is there a measurable ben-
efit on human health? Nutrients 12:7. doi: 10.3390/nu12010007
Wong, H. (2021). Sustainable healthy diets: food swaps for our health & our planet.
Healthy Popul. J. 1. doi: 10.15273/hpj.v1i2.11080
Zayed, M. F ., Gaber, H. R., and El Essawi, N. (2022). Examining the factors that affect
consumers’ purchase intention of organic food products in a developing country.
Sustainability 14:5868. doi: 10.3390/su14105868
Zhang, Y ., San Ong, T., and Kamarudin, F . (2024). Environmental regulation and corpo-
rate environmental performance: a bibliometric analysis. J. Infrastruct. Policy Dev. 8:3149.
doi: 10.24294/jipd.v8i4.3149
Zhu, J., and Liu, W . (2020). A tale of two databases: the use of Web of Science and Scopus
in academic papers. Scientometrics 123, 321–335. doi: 10.1007/s11192-020-03387-8
Zhuang, L., Y e, C., and Lieske, S. N. (2020). Intertwining globality and locality: bibliomet-
ric analysis based on the top geography annual conferences in America and China.
Scientometrics 122, 1075–1096. doi: 10.1007/s11192-019-03325-3
论文原文与出版信息
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems